Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Captain Picard was assimilated by the Borg collective and turned into a drone. When he was freed from it, all traces of Borg hardware were removed from his body and he returned to being a fully-functional human (physically, at least). That shows that it is possible to completely reverse the Borg assimilation process.

However, when Seven of Nine was rescued from the collective, the Doctor left a large number of Borg implants in her body. Why didn't he restore her human physique completely using the same methods which were applied to Picard?

share|improve this question
18  
If I remember correctly, they never fully Borg-ified Captain Picard, because their plans for him required him to retain part of his humanity. – Ixrec Jan 8 at 15:49
20  
its important to note, that picard was a fully functioning adult, while seven of nine was a child still with a developing body, the nanites may have taking over parts of her body they were still under developed, leading to certain parts of her body entirly relient on borg tech, while picards body already fully worked, and so only needed modifications. – Himarm Jan 8 at 16:13
2  
Picard had a prosthetic arm from BoBW until the end of his life. Vaguely relevant perhaps, as it shows that Picard's assimilation wasn't completely reversible. – Lightness Races in Orbit Jan 8 at 18:10
1  
@LightnessRacesinOrbit This is the first I'd heard of his prosthetic arm - is there a canon source for that? – fluffy Jan 9 at 0:08
1  
Although he appears fully human externally, the events of First Contact lead me to think that he still has a tiny bit of Borg technology inside him, especially as he knows the Borg is coming from a dream/nightmare. Now I want to ask about Picard's artificial heart which failed in Tapestry! Wasn't it upgraded by the Borg? – CJ Dennis Jan 9 at 2:07

According to Memory Alpha's entry on Seven of Nine:

The Doctor, Voyager's holographic chief medical officer, was able to remove most of her implants and restore most of her Human appearance, but her long-term assimilation meant that some parts were vital to her survival and could not be removed.

That implies that the longer one has been assimilated, the more one relies on the implants, presumably because the biological systems atrophy or are removed by the Collective as being inefficient. Picard, having been recently assimilated, has fewer problems. Also, as noted by enderland, she was assimilated at an early age, which might lead to further complications due to fewer years of her systems running on their own and/or assimilation happening alongside or as the result of maturation.

share|improve this answer
    
@Philipp: Is there anything more I can add for you? – FuzzyBoots Jan 15 at 17:56

Out-of-Universe: Patrick Stewart probably didn't want to permanently don a costume like the experience that Michael Dorn had to endure. Being anti-Borg may not have been a primary defining characteristic of Picard's overall character, at least when they starting showing the very next episode. In contrast, Seven's character was always intended to have lingering Borg references.

In-Universe: Picard could sense the Borg via a dream, as shown in the opening scene of Star Trek: First Contact. He also seemed to be able to listen to their communications, which led to Picard choosing how Starfleet should start to act during the remainder of the battle with the Borg Cube from that movie. So, Picard may have been de-Borgified in external appearance, but perhaps still had some lingering Borg pieces lying around.

Yes, I know the counter argument: IMBD Quotes from The Drumhead (Drumhead script,Drumhead script) where Picard says "Yes, I have completely recovered." However, Picard was making a statement to defend what was at stake, which was his credibility. As shown in the Star Trek: First Contact movie, that statement may not have been entirely true, from a Biological point of view. Even if Picard did have some remaining nanites in his blood, if his day-to-day life wasn't consciously affected, and his judgments were purely originating only from biological components, Picard's statement may have been entirely honest.

share|improve this answer
1  
FWIW, the dream could have been just that, and the "whispering" on the bridge a hint at a flashback. – Raphael Jan 8 at 18:24
6  
@Raphael: It is highly unlikely that the whispering on the bridge was a flashback since Picard knew exactly where to target the Borg in the circumstances he was currently in. It is much more logical that he heard how the Borg were responding to the existing damage the battle had caused and realized he could destroy the cube by focusing fire on something that "does not appear to be a vital system". In fact, later in the movie, the Borg Queen confirms: "What's wrong, Locutus? [snip] You can still hear our song." – Ellesedil Jan 8 at 19:15
1  
@Ellesedil I always assumed he had some inside knowledge on Borg cube design which he remembered. The hestitation and whispering are him getting drawn back to his trauma, then he catches himself applies the knowledge he gained during that time. But nevermind, I forgot the Queen said that. Not that she's the most reliable of conversation starters. (And it can be understood figuratively, as in "you remember the song, you know the allure".) – Raphael Jan 8 at 19:19
1  
@Ellesedil Indeed, I don't remember thinking of that quote as being tied to Picard's extra Borg sense. However, it does make quite a bit of sense. At times like these, I'm sorry that upvoting comments doesn't affect your overall rep. Thank you for the insight. – TOOGAM Jan 8 at 19:22

According to the Seven of Nine article on Memory Alpha, it was due to the amount of time she'd spent as a drone.

The Doctor, Voyager's holographic chief medical officer, was able to remove most of her implants and restore most of her Human appearance, but her long-term assimilation meant that some parts were vital to her survival and could not be removed.

Picard spent significantly less time as a drone, a matter of days. Though not stated, there was significantly better medical capabilities available for the de-assimilation of Picard - he was at Earth, rather than on a small starship in the middle of nowhere.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.