Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

If two equally skilled and similar (in terms of physique and metabolic processes) wizards played against each other in a game of chance (dice, card games, whatever) after drinking the same amount of felix felicis of same quality, who would win?

Would the felix felicis in their systems cancel each other out, so that it would be as if neither of them drank anything at all?

Or is it possible that one would ultimately come out as a winner due to very slight variations in how their body would react to felix felicis?

Or is it something else entirely?

share|improve this question
39  
a third person would come to the table and loose all his money – Eumel Jan 25 at 10:30
28  
Both are forced not to attend the game due to much more important immediate business. Both earn more than was on the table while dealing with it. – Deltharis Jan 25 at 10:43
9  
One would win it all. The other one would then realize that money has been holding him/her back from pursuing his/her dream. She/he would pursue it and make millions. – Misha Rosnach Jan 25 at 11:53
3  
I've flagged this question as too broad because answers will be purely speculative. – TylerH Jan 25 at 15:25
3  
Depends who drinks it first. The second person to drink would slip and spill it, and then decide to play anyway so as not to lose face. – anaximander Jan 25 at 16:12
up vote 39 down vote accepted

Felix would lead them both away from playing with each other, as that would be the most lucky scenario for each of them (Thanks @Deltharis).

If you consumed some Felix and went to a gambling table, it would be highly unlucky if you met another person who had consumed Felix at the same table. This would violate the basic effect Felix brings upon you.

If you're wondering how Felix would know that another person would arrive at the same table having consumed Felix as well, that's basically how the potion works. Taking an instance from the sixth Harry Potter book, Harry consumed Felix to get some information out of Slughorn and, instead of heading to Slughorn's office where he'd most likely find him, headed toward Hagrid's hut, on Felix's direction. He then took a detour towards the Herbology greenhouses on another prod from Felix. He happened to run into Slughorn there, by the greenhouses. How did Felix know Slughorn would be at the greenhouses? That's just how the potion of luck works.

share|improve this answer
    
what would happen if they deliberatly both drink felix at the table with the intent to see who it works on better? – Eumel Jan 25 at 12:00
8  
Then, as mentioned in the comments to the question, either one would get the urge to walk away, or one would lose, but would lead to another situation where one would win big (maybe not in monetary form, but definitely win big in some way that would justify the loss). – ʀᴇᴅ_ᴅᴇᴠɪʟ226 Jan 25 at 12:20
    
They may lose a small amount from that table, then walk away and win at another table. – Carcigenicate Jan 25 at 14:51
3  
To be honest, my comment wasn't meant as a serious answer, because I don't belive potion like Felix as presented can be a part of a coherent world outside of the narrative. Though I'm glad it inspired you. – Deltharis Jan 25 at 15:23
    
probably even if you try to force an event like this to happen, then i things way out of your control will happen, like the table catching fire or the card flying out of the windows or similar things, forcing the contender to take different patch and then thing will develop to some hard to predict by probably interesting way. – lesto Jan 25 at 23:08

After some fan analysis regarding all instances of canon use, the following two points appear to be self-consistent in the use and application of this potion:

Felix Felicis causes the drinker to have a limited period of good luck, during which they are likely to to succeed in all endeavours in which success is possible.

This is accomplished not through direct application of force or granting the drinker any extraordinary powers, but by inspiring the drinker with a favorable pathway through the circumstances.

(emphasis added)

So the question, "If two equal wizards played against each other in a game of chance after drinking the same amount of felix felicis of same quality, who would win?" becomes moot.

"Success" for one of them is not possible, and it's entirely through chance that one or the other would come out ahead. It quite possible, though, that the one thing the question doesn't take into account, the desires of the individual players, would make a difference.

For instance, one may merely be playing for money, while the other might be playing for fame. It's quite possible that the outcome of the game could give both of them their desires, even if the game appears to pit the one against the other. If, for instance, the fame desiring champion was influenced by Felix to choose to give the money to the loser before the game started (perhaps because he feels he's cheating?), then both potions could work together to cause the fame desiring one to win, while the money desiring one would feel lucky at the end once the winner privately gave the winnings to the loser - as he merely desired the fame.

Perhaps something outside the game provides an influence. One of them might have some "friends" or relatives who, upon seeing their friend win, would pester them or complicate their lives, and so losing might actually be luckier than winning - though in this case the loser might in fact believe the potion didn't work.

Unfortunately there are too many other influences, and too little known about the potion, to make a good objective answer to this question.

At best the result is undefined.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.