Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

The Jedi are presented as peacekeepers or as police officers. They obviously don't just kill all the bad guys they run into or do mind tricks on them to make them go home and 'rethink their lives', so what do they do with the people they arrest and take into custody? Do they have jails?

share|improve this question
2  
There was a jail in the Clone Wars IIRC. – ibid Feb 19 at 16:18
    
If you want Legends answers (and add the tag), I can give you a nice write up on what they used to do. – Axelrod Feb 19 at 16:45
    
@Axelrod I'm unfamiliar with 'Legends'... I don't get out much. Is it considered Canon? – Morgan Feb 19 at 18:22
    
@Morgan "Legends canon" is the old EU, including books, video games, and comics. These days the only things considered canon without a tag are "Disney Canon", so the films, books written after TFA, a few new comics, and the CGI cartoons. – Axelrod Feb 19 at 18:25
5  
If the Jedi have jails, do the Sith have sails? – Valorum Feb 19 at 23:24
up vote 21 down vote accepted

As peacekeepers for the Republic, the Jedi work alongside the Judicials and other law enforcement agencies of the Republic such as the Coruscant Security Force. These Republic agencies appear to run their own prisons, such as the Republic Judiciary Central Detention Center on Coruscant. Wookieepedia has images of the interior and exterior of this prison from Star Wars: The Clone Wars episodes "Hostage Crisis" (S1E22) and "Assassin" (S3E7), respectively:

RJCDC interior

RJCDC exterior

Note that the prison's name indicates it is run by the Republic, not the Jedi. Furthermore, the image of the interior shows that it is guarded by clones, not Jedi. Therefore, the Jedi don't maintain their own prisons -- they hand criminals over to the appropriate Republic law enforcement agency so the criminals can be tried and incarcerated in a prison run by the Republic.

The only reason the Jedi might require their own special prison would be to deal with trained users of the dark side of the Force. However, there aren't enough of these individuals to justify a separate Jedi-run prison (and that's assuming such individuals would allow themselves to be captured rather than fight to the death). In the event the Jedi managed to capture a trained user of the dark side, that person would probably be placed in a special cell in a Republic prison (such as the one Obi-Wan was held in when he was captured on Geonosis) and would perhaps be guarded by a Jedi rather than a regular prison guard.

share|improve this answer
1  
This answer looks right, but I think it would be improved if you could cite some specific canon sources (probably episodes of The Clone Wars) to back it up--the prison article on wookieepedia cites a bunch of episodes where prisons are shown, so that could be a good starting point, though I haven't seen most of the episodes listed yet. – Hypnosifl Feb 19 at 18:09
1  
@Hypnosifl Better now? – Null Feb 19 at 18:23
5  
If Mace Windu vs. Palpatine is any evidence, the Jedi have shown that they're willing to play judge/jury/executioner when it comes to the Sith / dark-side users. No need for a prison for people who are "too dangerous to be left alive!" – Luke Feb 19 at 19:26
1  
It is common for societies to differentiate between crimes against the state (handled by the state court system, the state penal system, etc.) and crimes against god (handled by the church). In this instance, dark-side force users would be heretics or blasphemers and subject to judgement and punishment by the clergy (jedi). – Rich Remer Feb 19 at 21:17

As another thought, Count Dooku in Episode II, holds Obi-wan captive. The technology he used, was used to hold a Jedi captive, but I'm sure that same technology could be used to hold a Sith.

enter image description here

So if the Jedi needed to use technology to "jail" a Sith, or other force-sensitive, theoretically, it should be possible.

Also, technology like that probably wasn't designed for Count Dooku specifically to hold Obi-wan, that'd make little sense, so its a reasonable assumption that the technology was mass produced for a holding facility, by someone, somewhere; though I know of no references in canon that refer to it.

share|improve this answer
    
Holding someone suspended/immobile seems generally useful, I'm not sure this has anything to do with Jedi or Sith. – Matthew Read Feb 20 at 4:58
    
very true, other than traditional holding methods mean far less for a Jedi than being suspended/immobile, especially since Count Dooku was still able to question Obi Wan when he was in the above state, safely. Trying to question a Jedi or Sith against their will, held in a traditional manner would be a very bad idea. – Brian Deragon Feb 20 at 5:47

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.