Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

In Chapter 33 of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Voldemort apparently knows which Death Eaters usually stood where.

Voldemort moved on, and stopped, staring at the space — large enough for two people — that separated Malfoy and the next man.
“The Lestranges should stand here,” said Voldemort quietly.

How did Voldy know which Death Eaters should have stood there? Did the Death Eaters all have pre-assigned spaces to stand in? Who decided these places? When did they practice?

If they didn't have a seating chart, how did Voldy know who was who under the mask?

How did Voldemort know which Death Eaters were missing?

Inspired by this tumblr post.

share|improve this question
2  
Speculation and this a comment; Voldermort is highly acomplished at mind reading, so it's possible he could read the minds of the death eaters to see who was behind the mask. He also understands wand lore so he might have been able to sense the wand and relate that to an owner – gabe3886 Feb 29 at 13:53
1  
@gabe3886 "He also understands wand lore"? Sounds like you and I read two entirely different series of Harry Potter books! Voldemort definitely does not understand wand lore at that point in the books, and arguably never truly understands it at any point before his death. – Anthony Grist Feb 29 at 15:41
    
@AnthonyGrist Thinking further, I'm mis-remembering about want lore. I thought he detected the core of Lucius Malfoy's wand, but he asks him what the core is. My mistake there. My assumption was that if he could detect the core in a wand, he could use that to identify death eaters – gabe3886 Feb 29 at 15:46

I don't believe that there is any direct canon answer to this question, so please be aware that my answer is purely speculative (within the spirit of canon).

The simplest answer is the old Voldy is shown throughout the series to be a character who needs to be in control, whether it be by pulling strings in the background (Pius Thicknesse becoming Minister upon the assassination of Rufus Srimgeour) or by directly controlling those around him (either through fear and intimidation or the imperious curse). That being said it is not that far fetched to suggest that Voldemort would be controlling to the point of assigning his death eaters specific places, or a particular order, to stand in upon being summoned.

Based on where a particular death eater is assigned to stand may indicate prominence and/or rank within the death eater order. For instance, in the beginning of the Deathly Hallows, Snape is afforded a seat of prominence, emphasis is my own:

"Severus, here," said Voldemort, indicating the seat on his immediate right." "Yaxley -- beside Dolohov."

The two men took their allotted places.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, page 3, US Hardcover Edition

As we can see in the italicized part of the quote, Snape is given the seat on Voldemort's right hand, which is typically regarded is a prominent spot, that would seem to have been saved particularly for Snape. Yaxley, on the other hand was assigned a seat elsewhere at the table. The boldface text shows that seats were indeed assigned to Death Eaters, and based on the preceding text, we can easily assume that it was Voldemort himself that assigned the seats, instead of say Malfoy who owned the manor.

Furthermore, it is not uncommon that in the military (or even militia armies) that soldiers assemble in a given order, generally by rank. As the death eater order is the closest thing we see to a trained army/militia in the Harry Potter series, it makes sense that they would operate and assemble in a similar manner.

And just to cover all of my bases here, before anyone can say that Voldermort would be completely ignorant of military history/formations, let's remember that for the first eleven years of his life, Tom Riddle was raised in a Muggle orphanage and presumably attended a muggle school during this time. I'm not so sure about the English education system, but here in the States, we do start learning a bit of military history, particularly WWI and WWII in primary school. A very basic knowledge of Muggle armies could have planted a seed in Tom Riddle's head, long before he became Voldemort, on how armies assemble, attack, defend, and ultimately achieve victory, or lose in battle.

share|improve this answer
8  
Young Riddle would definitely have learnt about WWI. Remember, he was born in 1926 and thus lived in the orphanage in the early 1930s when WWI was still quite fresh in the public memory and the political climate in Germany was starting to build up towards what would eventually become WWII. I too have always read the GoF chapter as implying, if not actually stating outright, that each Death Eater had their own, specific place. I assume part of the magic behind the Dark Mark is that they always Apparate to where Voldemort wants them, in this case in their own spot in the circle. – Janus Bahs Jacquet Feb 29 at 6:03
3  
I don't see why muggle military history is relevant. You can have or create a hierarchy without copying one from the muggle world. – The Giant of Lannister Feb 29 at 7:53
3  
@JanusBahsJacquet So Voldemort could have retired in one more year if Harry hadn't killed him... how sad. – TylerH Feb 29 at 17:23

In canon Voldemort is a Legilimens of great skill, capable of basically reading minds. (Basically, Snape goes on a decent rant about it.)

"The mind is not a book, to be opened at will and examined at leisure. Thoughts are not etched on the inside of skulls, to be perused by any invader. The mind is a complex and many-layered thing... It is true, however, that those who have mastered Legilimency are able, under certain conditions, to delve into the minds of their victims and to interpret their findings correctly."

-- Severus Snape

Voldemort is known for overpowering weak minds, I can't imagine many of his followers could withstand his Legilimency.

While it is never directly addressed in the books, it's probable that Voldemort can tell the difference between his followers very easily.

Edit: I suppose my point was that he knew which ones were there, and he was certainly an authoritative enough fellow to simply call out the missing as he came upon a gap; assuming he didn't remember the seating chart I assume he assigned because he's a control freak.

share|improve this answer
3  
How exactly does this answer the question? What does Legilimency have to do with anything? We know that Voldemort is perfectly capable of telling the difference between his Death Eaters, just like he and anyone else is perfectly capable of telling the difference between any other people they know personally… you don’t have to read someone’s mind to recognise them. The question here is why he is able to put specific names to specific gaps in a circle of people. This answer seems… completely unrelated. – Janus Bahs Jacquet Feb 29 at 17:35
2  
I suppose this is meant to address the implication in the question that the Death Eaters conceal their identities when "on the job". If the identities are concealed and Voldemort hadn't assigned spots in the first place (e.g. perhaps the Death Eaters self-organized but kept their own chosen spots from meeting to meeting), you'd wonder how he would have known who used to stand in those spaces back when they were there - and the answer, of course, could be Legilimency. (I don't find that whole chain of reasoning very convincing though.) – David Z Feb 29 at 18:35

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.