Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

If Snape was removing his memories of Lily and placing them in the pensieve every time he and Harry practiced Occlumency to keep Harry from seeing them, does that mean that Snape, in essence, could no longer remember them? Does that also mean that if you removed a memory to the pensieve to keep someone from seeing it, would this be a way to avoid the truth telling effects of Veritiserum?

share|improve this question
3  
Everything I can recall from the books suggests you do keep memories placed in the Pensieve, which does leave us to wonder why Snape putting his memories in the Pensieve would have prevented Harry from seeing them. – Torisuda Mar 26 at 20:57
6  
As they were unflattering memories of James Potter, and Harry was known to be curious in the extreme, I've always assumed the memories were a trap. Additionally, this sort of pettiness is consistent with Snape's character. – Morgen Mar 26 at 23:05
3  
A lot of overlap with this question, you might want to look at the answers: How does removing a memory work in Harry Potter? – sumelic Mar 27 at 1:35
    
Seems odd that you would forget them. How would you know what is in your basin when you need to remember something? Also, when you go in to experience your memory, you would either trigger your memory of it or be experiencing it all over (and creating a second memory of it in the process). – David Starkey Mar 28 at 13:03
up vote 24 down vote accepted

Based on a convincing argument I've decided to amend my answer to say that it must depend on the situation.

Dumbledore showed Harry several of his own memories in the series (meeting Voldemort, trials of Death Eaters after the first war) at times he even accompanied him into them.

Memories like these were stored in his office and not his head, so they must be copies. If he couldn't remember them himself when they were in the bottles/phials in his office or in the Pensieve itself, the situation would have been very different.

Since Snape seems to use the Pensieve for protecting his memories, perhaps there is a way of either copying or storing the original depending on your need. Though, thinking about it, if Snape forgot what he put in there, how would he know to go back for them? Perhaps they are protected in a different fashion in the Pensieve.

Pottermore has JKR's writing on the Pensieve which explains:

"The Pensieve is enchanted to recreate memories so that they become re-liveable, taking every detail stored in the subconscious and recreating it faithfully, so that either the owner, or (and herein lies the danger) a second party, is able to enter the memories and move around within them."

And later:

"Even more difficult than the recreation of memories is the use of a Pensieve to examine and sort thoughts and ideas, and very few wizards have the ability to do so."

There is no mention of hiding memories in the way that Snape does. It clearly is primarily an aid to thinking and studying memories, not something designed to make you forget.

share|improve this answer
3  
I don't see the problem. First, Dumbledore stores a memory in the Pensieve, so he forgets about it. But he still remembers he has just stored an important memory in the Pensieve. Then he can use the Pensieve to see the memory. And after that he will remember the memory he has seen using the Pensieve. – Oriol Mar 26 at 21:42
3  
@Oriol: That's what ThruGog means by "making a copy." – Kevin Mar 26 at 22:21
12  
"if Snape forgot what he put in there, how would he know to go back for them" The same way you remember that you need to grab your grocery list before you go out the door, without having to remember what's on the list. – Josh Caswell Mar 26 at 23:45
7  
So what you're saying is that you can either ctrl-X or ctrl-C before ctrl-V'ing your memories in the pensieve? :P – MPF Mar 27 at 5:43
4  
The fact that Slughorn gave Dumbledore a modified version of the memory (in the film at least) and still possessed the original is probably a fairly noteworthy example. – Obsidian Phoenix Mar 28 at 9:22

It seems you don't remember memories in the Pensieve. As you say, Snape used this as a protection against Harry during Occlumency practices in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix:

The light was coming from the Pensieve sitting on Snape’s desk. The silver-white contents were ebbing and swirling within. Snape’s thoughts … things he did not want Harry to see if he broke through Snape’s defenses accidentally. … Harry gazed at the Pensieve, curiosity welling inside him. … What was it that Snape was so keen to hide from Harry?
— Chapter 28, Snape’s Worst Memory

If he did remember the memories, there would be no need to restore them after each practice:

As he opened it he glanced back at Snape, who had his back to Harry and was scooping his own thoughts out of the Pensieve with the tip of his wand and replacing them carefully inside his own head.
— Chapter 24, Occlumency

And he wouldn't be that worried about them:

Panting slightly, Snape straightened the Pensieve in which he had again stored some of his thoughts before starting the lesson, almost as though checking that they were still there.
— Chapter 26, Seen and Unforeseen

And in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Dumbledore says he uses the Pensieve when he has too many thoughts:

“This? It is called a Pensieve,” said Dumbledore. “I sometimes find, and I am sure you know the feeling, that I simply have too many thoughts and memories crammed into my mind.” “Er,” said Harry, who couldn’t truthfully say that he had ever felt anything of the sort. “At these times,” said Dumbledore, indicating the stone basin, “I use the Pensieve. One simply siphons the excess thoughts from one’s mind, pours them into the basin, and examines them at one’s leisure.”
— Chapter 30, The Pensieve

If the Pensieve didn't remove the memories from your head, it wouldn't help in this situation.

share|improve this answer
5  
Not sure how it relates to the book, but doesn't Dumbledore possess a version of Slughorns memory that is different from truth, and Slughorn still possesses the original. Doesn't this indicate its not always a removal? – Obsidian Phoenix Mar 28 at 9:18
2  
It does indicate that, yes. And I don't think for one second that Slughorn gives Harry his original, genuine memory and then immediately forgets it. Added to the fact that Pottermore makes no mention of the hiding of memories, I personally think that too much is being made of that scene. – ThruGog Mar 28 at 14:25
    
@ObsidianPhoenix It might be that Slughorn uses his imagination to create a new, fake memory based on the real one, and then he forgets about the fake one, but still has the original. – Oriol Mar 28 at 17:28

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.