Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Batman always seems to surprise him with kryptonite.

Has he ever defeated Superman without it? By defeat I mean incapacitate, not just talk him around.

This answer fails to list an instance of this (after asking, Batman uses kryptonite gum, exactly the shenanigans I want to avoid). The other answer doesn't mention how Batman defeats him.

All media is fine, movies, comics, cartoons etc.

Magic is allowed.

share|improve this question
    
IRTA as "decapitate" at first!! – Lightness Races in Orbit Mar 29 at 13:00
34  
1  
Not batman himself but i remember that Alfred beat superman up pretty bad after consuming some sort of a "superpill" that lex engineered from Superman's DNA. It was pretty bad, Alfred ended the fight in the most badass way by saying "i'm very disappointed in you." before knocking him on the ground. – Amirius Mar 29 at 21:18
    
Where did you see this? – AJL Mar 29 at 21:45
1  
There are only three ways to defeat Superman: red sunlight (or lack of yellow sunlight), kryptonite, and magic. This kind of limits Batman's options. – Omegacron Jul 5 at 18:53
up vote 51 down vote accepted

Yes

Red Son universe Pre New 52 (Earth 30), the soviet Batman had fought against Superman using Red Sun lamps, weakening Superman enough for him to beat him up.

However Wonder Woman, who was used as bait, was convinced by Superman to break the lamps, which lead to Superman's powers returning and Batman kills himself (as this Superman lobotomizes his victims).

Edit: to clarify, exposed to kryptonite, kryptonians are harmed whilst red sun removes (temporarily) their powers, normally without them knowing.

share|improve this answer
    
Awesome! I had completely forgotten about Red Son – AncientSwordRage Mar 29 at 13:36
    
@AncientSwordRage most people do, it's a rare jewel in the multiverse – Recycle Mar 29 at 16:05
16  
Russian Batman is best Batman – System Down Mar 29 at 18:04
10  
While technically right, using something other than kryptonite to do exactly what kryptonite does is kind of unsatisfying, isn't it? – Martin Carney Mar 29 at 18:06
    
@MartinCarney it is, but superman isn't weakened just power deprived, if it was zod or another military kryptonian they would be able to hold their own – Recycle Mar 29 at 18:23

According to Batman Wikia Anarchistic Russian Terrorist Batman, defeats Soviet Weapon Superman (briefly) on Earth(30):

Batman forges a temporary alliance with Lexcorp and with his parents' killer to attempt a coup. He then kidnapped Superman's colleague and friend Wonder Woman to use her as bait for Superman, in order to draw him into a wasteland, where Batman was hoping to sap his powers with rays that imitate the light of Superman's native sun.

The plan worked, and Batman then bombarded Superman with simulated red sunlight. But unfortunately for Batman, Wonder Woman breaks free and rescues Superman by removing the generator powering the lamps, although the process (which requires snapping her golden lasso) seriously injures her.

Batman commits suicide to avoid capture, but not before revealing to Superman that Pyotr had a role in the plot. Then, unwilling to be locked up, Batman instead detonated a bomb, and was killed in the explosion.

Wonder Woman Escapes and "removes" the generator powering the lamps, needing no convincing from anyone.

share|improve this answer

There is a Superman/Batman issue (Issue #78) that has them fighting and Batman Ultimately winning through blotting out the sun, though this was all just 2 kids talking about who would win. The issue does point out one of the most important things about this fight...

While Batman will likely die, he ultimately will win, because he has set up so many contingencies to handle the issue if it ever comes down to it. Dying and Losing is not the same thing is something that a lot of these battles don't take into account.

At the end Batman says "The kid had a lot of it right" and that he'd beat Superman without Kryptonite... whether this is a bluff or not...well, if he'd thought of blotting out the sun then it's not.


Another Batman/Superman fight is in Batman: HUSH. Batman does use kryptonite innefectively in the fight and ultimately wins in another way, rather than using the ring.

share|improve this answer
    
Alright I has done it and Good? – Durakken Jul 5 at 12:13
    
It's great thanks for editing – AncientSwordRage Jul 5 at 12:32

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.