up vote 25 down vote favorite
4
share [g+] share [fb]

The Borg assimilate individuals and their entire mind becomes a part of their collective. Every time they to do this, they must gain the exact experiences and legitimate reasonings as to why other lifeforms do NOT want to be a part of the collective.

The Borg must completely understand a individual's perspective, where in any of the Star Trek series, is there an explanation as to why they continue to assimilate and disregard the individual's reasonings? There must be a reason(s) that the collective has that overrides any individuals's feelings/emotions, reasons, and value of free thought.

link|improve this question
100% accept rate
1  
+1 great question – Anonymous Type Mar 17 '11 at 10:41
feedback

3 Answers

up vote 17 down vote accepted

Picard, Hugh and Seven of Nine all talk about what being part of the collective is like. There are great benefits to being a part of it. Seven at many points describes how being a part of the collective means immortality, safety, security, and never having to be alone.

Presumably, it is only when not part of the collective that any of these people valued their individuality. While in the collective, they revel in lacking it. They are reassured by it. It feeds into all people's desires to not have to make choices on your own. To the extreme, yes, but it must be comforting.

The immortality alone would have me lining up to join them.

link|improve this answer
1  
Plus, note the extreme discomfort that Hugh and Seven experience as they are withdrawn from the collective "It's so quiet, there are no voices" – HorusKol Mar 16 '11 at 22:33
1  
remember though that One was able to be part of the collective and an individual. although he/she/it was a special case – Xantec Mar 16 '11 at 23:02
Remember that the immortality was not necessarily a physical existence. When Seven talked about the effective immortality, it was due to the fact that the memory of her, possibly fragments of her mind, would continue to exist within the hive mind as sort of a secondary thought...but physical immortality wherein you had a cyborg body did not sound like the norm. Borg still died, probably usually through battle, but also due to malfunction. They are still biological and mechanical beings, and parts will still fail. The borg being what they are, they will eventually abandon, rather than repair. – jrista Apr 7 '11 at 20:45
@jrista whatever shred of the mind that remains after assimilation may eventually "die" but, assuming i recall correctly, i remember one episode on Voyager where the crew reactivated a section of a disabled borg cube, at which point a number of drones in that section became active. this indicates that the biological remains of a drone can be resuscitated after death by the implants/nanites (assuming the body remains sufficiently preserved i suppose) which may indeed mean near physical immortality (especially considering the VOY drones (more nanites) verses the TNG drones (more mechanical) – Xantec Apr 7 '11 at 21:30
@Xantec: That would indeed be true, however the Borg cube had only recently been destroyed. I would agree that so long as the biological components had not degraded beyond repair, and the mechanical and nanite parts still functioned properly, there is no reason to assume a borg couldn't be revived some time after its initial shutdown. – jrista Apr 7 '11 at 23:44
feedback
up vote 5 down vote

I think that the Borg, as whole, do understand individuality; they probably understand it better than any single individual does (as you pointed out they assimilate individuals). They disregard the feelings of those they assimilate for two main reasons I can think of off hand; Fear (probably realized more as an autonomic reaction, similar to an immune system) and Lack of Concern (even if a freshly assimilated individual [or planet] is somewhat discordant in the sound of the collective mind it can be easily ignored by the full weight and majority consensus of the collective mind).

if you want to go the other direction, introduced in First Contact, then the Borg is really a Monarchy state merely acting out the wishes of the queen. in this case then the thoughts of people not yet assimilated don't matter because they aren't part of the state and once they are assimilated then they are pawns of the queen.

link|improve this answer
I would be inclined to say it is a combination of both. The queen apparently has the ability to direct and control as she sees fit, but that doesn't seem to diminish the weight of the hive mind overall when she chooses not to interfere. – jrista Apr 7 '11 at 20:43
feedback
up vote 1 down vote

I reckon the Borg can't understand individuality because they are a really really uber powerful lower lifeform. One that evolved through parasitical assimiliation rather than via a society of divergent minds. But one that is still not evolved enough mentally or emotionally to deal with assimilated individuals.
I always wondered why the writers preferred an evil race that didn't just pillage and murder like normal. I always figured it was a plot device used to make the Borg scarier. However maybe the writers wan't us to think about the Borgs lack of apparent self awareness, and absolute compliance.

link|improve this answer
feedback

Your Answer

 
or
required, but never shown
discard

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.