Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm reading A Game of Thrones for the first time and absolutely loving it, but I've gotten to a description that doesn't seem to make sense to me. Can anyone explain it?

According to the book, people were only allowed to enter via the Mud Gate...

Every day since her escape from the Red Keep, Arya had visited each of the seven city gates in turn. The Dragon Gate, the Lion Gate, and the Old Gate were closed and barred. The Mud Gate and the Gate of the Gods were open, but only to those who wanted to enter the city; the guards let no one out. Those who were allowed to leave left by the King’s Gate or the Iron Gate, but Lannister men-at-arms in crimson cloaks and lion-crested helms manned the guard posts there. Spying down from the roof of an inn by the King’s Gate, Arya saw them searching wagons and carriages, forcing riders to open their saddlebags, and questioning everyone who tried to pass on foot.

But just a page or two later, she's walking along the River, watching people in the Fishmarket...

The wharfs were oddly quiet when Arya got there. She spied another pair of Gold Cloaks, walking side by side through the fish market, but they never so much as looked at her. Half the stalls were empty, and it seemed to her that there were fewer ships at dock than she remembered... Arya watched them for a bit , then began to make her way along the river... When she saw the guardsmen on the third pier...

I just bought the official maps as part of The Lands of Ice and Fire, and I just don't see how this is possible?

Can anyone explain this so it makes sense?

enter image description here

share|improve this question
1  
The chapter begins at page 716 in the pocket version of AGOT. You're right, there's no explanation that fits with the map. Supposedly she cannot pass the mud gate, yet she is clearly at the docks. She even talks about swimming the Blackwater rush, even though it is clearly outside the city wall on the map. Looks like an oversight on GRRM's part. –  TLP Nov 25 '12 at 15:36
    
Damn, I didn't expect that. Especially after forking out for the official maps :( –  Django Reinhardt Nov 25 '12 at 17:04
1  
Well, the books were written a long time ago, perhaps he did not have the maps all thought out yet when he wrote that chapter. As a rule of thumb, GRRM's style is to focus on events and personalities, and has confessed to being somewhat fuzzy on both timeline and geography. I would expect, however, that the map is correct for the major events in the books, even though there can be minor slips like this one. –  TLP Nov 25 '12 at 17:28
    
Yep. As enjoyable as GoT is (and it's very enjoyable) it doesn't feel anywhere near as "solid" as Tolkien's fantasy. I'm sure there's probably errors in Tolkien's work, but generally it feels incredibly precise and reliable. GRRM's work is more fluid and dramatic, I think. Thanks. –  Django Reinhardt Nov 25 '12 at 18:58
    
Comparing anyone to Tolkien is probably very unfair. ;) Not everyone creates entire languages and mythology around their stories. –  TLP Nov 25 '12 at 19:02

1 Answer 1

up vote 3 down vote accepted

Officially, I don't think it is ever explained in the novels how Arya got through that gate.

Unofficially, the answer to this (IMO) is that Martin made a mistake. The most likely explanation is that his description of traffic through the River Gate is just wrong, because as written it makes no sense.

The "most official" map for King's Landing is the one printed in A Clash of Kings, which you can see here. The River Gate is in the bottom center. The area with the fish markets is very small, and needs to include space for the fish markets themselves, other related shops, probably some inns, warehouse storage for the docks, etc. It's very unlikely that there is much housing outside of the city gates.

But if that's the case, how are the people that work and shop at the fish markets getting there? Arya says there are "fewer" ships and stalls on the wharf, not that there are "no" ships or stalls, so there must still be commerce going on. (As stupid as Joffrey is, I can't imagine he would completely shut down commerce in his own capital.)

Given the geography of the city, and the fact that guards were patrolling the docks and monitoring those entering or leaving by boat, it seems unlikely that they would cut off all traffic through the River Gate.

IMO, it would make more sense to close the King's Gate, which appears to lead to the tournament grounds but nowhere else particularly useful, and allow two-way traffic via the River Gate, especially since the King's Road is on the other side of the river from the River Gate.

share|improve this answer
    
Just wondering: How is that map more "official" than the one included in The Lands of Ice and Fire? –  Django Reinhardt Nov 27 '12 at 18:20
1  
it was drawn at the same time as the book was being written and was included in an actual published work. I'm not discounting the "official" nature of Lands -- Martin worked on it so it's clearly all canon -- but I will always rank the actual novels over any supplemental material. Fortunately, in this case I don't think there's any conflict at all between the two. –  Michael Edenfield Nov 27 '12 at 18:55

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.