Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In the Day of the Doctor, both 10 and 11 remember destroying Gallifrey. Does this mean that in their past, the Interface never showed up? or did he just not listen to her and destroyed the planet right away?

share|improve this question

3 Answers 3

up vote 12 down vote accepted

Hurt's Doctor is a past version of 10 and 11, so all events that happened to Hurt's Doctor happened to 10 and 11 also.

If you recall, at the end of TDOTD, Hurt's Doctor says how he won't remember any of the events that took place, and instead he would only remember destroying Gallifrey in lieu of saving it. But they don't actually destroy Galiffrey do they? So how can 10 and 11 remember destroying Gallifrey? My guess is that whenever 10 and 11 go on about how they destroyed Gallifrey, they weren't being literal in the sense that they actually recall seeing the planet explode.

The War Doctor already had the intention of destroying Gallifrey before the events of the Day of the Doctor, so when he forgot everything that took place from when he stole the Moment up until his regeneration into Eccleston, I guess that afterwards he could logically reason that he must have destroyed Gallifrey and his memory must have been wiped during the ordeal somehow. And as Gallifrey wasn't there anymore when the War Doctor regenerated, the only explanation to that would be that he destroyed it.

Also, we know 10 and 11 couldn't have destroyed Gallifrey, because the Silence wanted to kill him to prevent him from bringing back the Time Lords into the universe (and this was before the Day of the Doctor, before the 11th Doctor had the chance to see his old self again). No Time Lords== No Silence and most of the 11th Doctor events wouldn't have happened.

share|improve this answer
    
One problem with this is that Smith never remembered meeting Tennant and Hurt, so Tennant AND Hurt would have to have forgotten the events, which is why I think they used the Black Archive's memory wiping devices to erase their memories –  DoctorWho22 Jan 2 at 21:10
1  
@DoctorWho22 Your idea couldn't have happened because lije you said in your answer, the11th Doctor clearly stated at the end of the episode that the time streams were out of sync, hence why Hurt and Tennant wouldn't remember any of the events. They couldn't have used the memory erasers because why would Tennant have had to bother asking Smith if he'd retain the events in his mind, and also Hurt and Tennant were already leaving in their Tardises, so how could the period of memory erasing fit in? And anyway with the whole time being out of sync thing why bother? –  83457 Jan 2 at 23:10
    
I'd have to watch the episode again... Because if that's the case Time Crash wouldn't have worked out the way it did... –  DoctorWho22 Jan 20 at 19:57

Actually the answer is quite simple... from what I recall the Black Archive had the memory wiping devices... At the end of the episode of The Day of The Doctor I believe there was some hints to using them to forget the events that happened that day. I believe Hurt said something along the lines of how he will forget what happened and that he will have to live with the fact that he destroyed Gallifrey, because he will be under the assumption that it was destroyed.

Also we never knew about The Silence's true role about bringing back the Time Lords until the Time of The Doctor when Tasha Lem revealed that the splinter faction of the Papal Mainframe went back along The Doctor's Timeline to prevent him from answering the question.

So there's two possibilities in my eyes, either

A. The events that occurred were always meant to happen and Hurt's Doctor and Tennant forgot the events from the memory wiping devices or because of "timey wimey" (you know how the doctor's aren't supposed to cross their own timeline)

B. Changing the past / future has major consequences which is why they had to wipe both Hurt and Tennant's memories of the events so that everything would work out as it did in The Day of the Doctor.

share|improve this answer

When the newest Doctors decided not to destroy Gallifrey they created an alternate timeline and essentially another dimension where in one Gallifrey was destroyed by the Doctor and the other it was saved. Since the past Doctors and their memories were not part of the second timeline they will no memory of Gallifrey being saved.

share|improve this answer
    
Is this based on canon? –  DVK Jan 20 at 7:07

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.