Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In the pilot episode of Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. TV series, Agent Coulson (who isn't dead) promoted Agent Ward to clearance level 7. Lower levels, including members of The Avengers don't know that Agent Coulson is alive. Agent Coulson has level 8 clearance and is able to do powerful things like keeping a new element classified even inside S.H.I.E.L.D.

Director Fury has got Level 10 clearance who seems to be able to do anything like faking official reports and using a non-sanctioned lab to revive a dead person using classified tech. But, he doesn't look like on Top level of clearance.

  • In Avengers movie, Director Fury was overridden in Nuclear Weapon launch authorization scene.

  • In the episode T.A.H.I.T.I. of Marvel's Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. TV series, the cover of the file describing how they revived Agent Coulson showed this:
    File describing how S.H.I.E.L.D. revived Agent Coulson from dead
    It says Security Level 10 or above required...

If Director Fury isn't at the Top level of clearance, who's on the Top?

share|improve this question
2  
In a later episode, I think Coulson mentions “Level 8” clearance (when meeting Agent Hand). According to Wikipedia and Marvel Wikia, the highest level is “Level 10” (which includes Hills and Fury), but I don’t have a canon source for that. –  alexwlchan Feb 18 at 22:02
2  
Aren't the Avengers (other than Black Widow and Hawkeye) not part of SHIELD, but rather just work with them for the duration of the movie? –  Andy Feb 18 at 22:10
1  
@Andy In this video, you can see Captain America saying, "I joined S.H.I.E.L.D. to protect people.": youtube.com/watch?v=7SlILk2WMTI –  Sachin Shekhar Feb 19 at 0:03
4  
Oh, +1 just for "(who isn't dead)." Made me laugh. –  Meat Trademark Feb 19 at 10:00
1  
@Richard I am unable to get what you want to say. See the title edit (and last paragraph) now. –  Sachin Shekhar Mar 6 at 0:11

4 Answers 4

  • Agent Phil Coulson: mentions that he is level 8 early in the show, and in the final episodes of S1 of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.

is upgraded to Level 10 when he assumes command of S.H.I.E.L.D.

  • Agent Victoria Hand: mentions that she is level 8 in the show.
  • Deputy Director Hill: is listed on wikia as level 9, but is unsourced
  • Director Fury is identified as the only level 10 operative in S01E14 (T.A.H.I.T.I)
  • Alexander Pierce is no longer an Agent of S.H.I.E.L.D, but has a Level 10 Clearance Level.
  • In Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Pierce and Fury are identified as "Alpha Level" members. Whether or not this is a reflection of their Level 10 Clearance, or something else (like the fact that Fury is the Director and Pierce is on the WSC) is left unclear.

Wikia's logic for Deputy Director Hill makes a fair bit of sense saying that Coulson and Hand are close to the top, with Fury being at a maximum level 10, but this information has not been specified yet.

As to "Who's On First Top", as @anthonygrist points out in the comments, there is really no "on top" when it comes to clearances.

Two people can have the same clearances but different authority levels. Similarly, two people can have the same authority level but different clearances. The fact Alexander Pierce has Level 10 clearance is proof that clearance level is not quite the same as operational authority within the organization.

The fact that the file folder says it requires "Level 10 Or Above" clearance is not enough to prove that any levels above 10 currently exist.

Consider the following conditional:

if x >= 10 then access_granted = true
else access_granted = false 

This does not necessarily mean that x can ever equal 11 or even 10.1. It just means that my code is not specifically looking for an exact value of 10 and only 10.

If for some reason an additional level of clearance was ever added to S.H.I.E.L.D's system, anyone 10 or above would be allowed access without having to go restamp all the files.

It's also entirely possible that something like a standard adjustable stamp was used. They typically have a standard bit of text or two and selectable values as evidenced by this recent publicity photo which appears to have identical stamps aside from the clearance level number.

folder stamp

share|improve this answer
2  
I don't think Fury is at Top level of clearance as he was overridden in Avengers movie (Nuclear Weapon launch authorization scene). –  Sachin Shekhar Feb 18 at 22:11
1  
He was being overridden by the council, not by other agents of SHIELD. –  phantom42 Feb 18 at 22:15
3  
@phantom42 then what exactly is The Council? –  FoxMan2099 Feb 18 at 22:42
2  
SHIELD is a US program, overseen by what appears to be an international body. The identities of the members of the World Security Council have not been revealed other than Alexander Pierce (in Captain America 2). –  phantom42 Feb 19 at 13:37
2  
@SachinShekhar They also get support from foreign (from a US standpoint) governments when conducting operations overseas, though that doesn't necessarily indicate anything either way. Also worth mentioning that clearance level isn't necessarily synonymous with rank; your clearance level would dictate what information you're allowed access to, but you could still have one clearance level 7 operative that is higher on the chain of command than another level 7 operative. They can know the same things, but one of them is still giving the orders. –  Anthony Grist Feb 19 at 15:07

Even Nick Fury Has A Boss

Although sometimes he kinda ignores them. In the cinematic universe, the entity that most directly sits "above" Fury is the World Security Council:

enter image description here

While the WSC, and other high-level political powers, are not actually part of the SHIELD hierarchy - they do have command and control authority over SHIELD. So while Nick Fury may have Clearance Level 10 - it is well within the power of the WSC to simply withhold information from Fury if they see fit.

In other words - the WSC can make the clearance level moot. Or to put it another way - within SHIELD it is nearly impossible to keep a secret from Fury. Outside of SHIELD, it becomes a little easier.

The structure is meant to provide a watchdog over SHIELD, however it also helps lead to the events of Captain America: Winter Soldier.

share|improve this answer

The override was performed by the WSC in a watchdog position (to watch over SHIELD). Even if they cannot directly override Fury it is possible they were committed to a radio-silence mission by someone on the same level as Fury. Either way, this can happen somehow.

The document seems to be made according to a template, and for level 10 the statement is meaningless unless an eleventh level will ever be made. In which case it will be useless for level 11.

Don't forget that there may always be more levels and complexities hidden from anyone ever shown on screen, if the writers need there to be. The level 10 or above is a goof. The WSC and how they could launch a nuclear fighter whilst evading Fury is mysterious but it was plot essential. If ever plot makes need, additional levels are waiting in the unknown. (Note: nobody can give you an in-series conclusive answer, because it could be secret from all those we know.)

share|improve this answer

Officialy Fury is the highest ranking S.H.I.E.L.D operative at level 10. The World Security Council can override Fury's ruling on Alexader Pierce's call. Some areas or files as seen in Captain America 2, require Alpha level access which has been shown to be posessed only by Fury and Pierce and requires 2 alpha level operatives to use alpha level systems or data

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.