Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I can't remember where but I read somewhere that the sword of the king of Numenor was in fact Aranruth - the sword of Elu Thingol.

How is this possible? I assume that Dior took up Thingol's throne in Menegroth and may have inherited the sword, but would the sword have then been given to Elwing and then Elros? Given that he was a small child during the events of the 2nd Kinslaying in Doriath, wouldn't Maedhros, or the Naugrim, have taken the sword at some point?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 3 down vote accepted

Elwing was born in F.A. 503, and the Sack of Doriah (or the 2nd Kinslaying) was in F.A 506. In the Unfinished Tales it says that Elwing recovered Aranrúth (which was then subsequently given to Elros by Eärendil).

So, the question is whether you believe that Elwing would be capable of doing that at the age of 3 : fleeing Doriah, carrying Aranrúth and also a Silmaril. Elwing was pretty hardy, and elves do mature faster than humans - but I don't think that Elwing was entirely alone when fleeing the Doriah.

I have read that Nimloth, daughter of Galathil, escaped with Elwing - but there are also conflicting tales that Nimloth was killed in the battle.

Considering that Elwing arrived at the Havens of Sirion by sea, I think it is reasonable to assume that she was accompanied by at least one other that would have helped carry Aranrúth

share|improve this answer
    
Interesting - Didnt Earendil leave before the final Kinslaying and Elwing cast herself into the sea (and flew to Earendil) during it? In this case Elros would have been very young when he and Elrond were captured by Maedhros and Maglor, Would he have been allowed to keep the sword by Maedhros, with him being so young? –  Steven Wood Feb 20 at 15:00
    
Yes, the sons of Fëanor attacked the Havens of Sirion in F.A 538 and it was then that she cast herself into the sea - but not before leaving Aranrúth to Elros. Elros was born in F.A. 532, so he would have been 6 years old at the time. What happened to Aranrúth during their capture? I'm not certain.. I don't think Maedrhos ever makes any mention of it. You're right, it is a curious point. –  RamblerToning Feb 20 at 15:43

According to the Tolkien Gateway:

Elros, the first King of Númenor received it from his mother, and from there on it became an heirloom of the Kings of Númenor.

According to The Encyclopedia of Arda:

The sword of Thingol, King of Doriath and overlord of the Sindar. We know little of its origins or history, except that its name Aranrúth means 'King's Ire'. After Thingol's fall, it was rescued from the sack of Menegroth and taken south by the survivors in the keeping of Thingol's great-granddaughter Elwing. Elwing in turn gave it to her son Elros, who would become the first King of Númenor, and Aranrúth remained the sword of the Kings of Númenor after his time. The sword's final fate is uncertain: it may have been lost in the Downfall of Númenor, or Ar-Pharazôn may have taken it with him to Aman, in which case it still lies within the Caves of the Forgotten.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.