Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

This question already has an answer here:

I've seen the movies. I know that Dooku cut off Anakin's hand during Episode 2. However, I'm in the process of reading "Dark Force Rising", and in it Mara Jade tells Luke Skywalker that Vader lost his right hand as a result of the Emperor's anger over losing the first Death Star.

So, which is it? Clearly, I'd assume the book is in "error" here. But, is there something more to this?

share|improve this question

marked as duplicate by NikolaiDante, SSumner, Meat Trademark, John O, Eureka Mar 9 at 8:51

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

12  
Movie canon > EU novel canon, I do believe –  joshbirk Feb 28 at 19:00
1  
Yes. Movies trump books. Pretty much everything written about the Mandolorians was overturned by the Close Wars Series, for example. –  swbarnes2 Feb 28 at 19:48
    
Yeah, like all being from New Zealand... (cough cough) –  joshbirk Feb 28 at 20:20
3  
It's not an "error", just a case of g-canon beats EU –  Richard Feb 28 at 20:27
    
I haven't read the books, but is it possible she was just going by hearsay and the information she received and passed on was simply incorrect? Or does the book imply that she was actually there when it happened? –  DondeEstaMiCulo Feb 28 at 23:49

1 Answer 1

up vote 9 down vote accepted

The following quote appears in the book "Heir to the Empire" by Timothy Zahn;

"I don't imagine that the Emperor was pleased," Luke murmured. "No, he wasn't," Mara said, her voice dark with memories of her own. "Vader nearly died for that blunder." Deliberately, she looked over at Luke's hands. "That was when he lost his right hand, in fact."

There is no further explanation given in the book, nor is the the quote consistent with G-Canon since he'd already lost his right hand in a fight with Dooku;

Dooku Fight

share|improve this answer
2  
OK. This is simply a case of film canon just ignoring the books. –  Richard Feb 28 at 19:27
1  
@Richard - the other way around. Heir to the Empire and Dark Force Rising came out years before episode II. –  neilfein Feb 28 at 19:54
4  
@Richard - Next time I'll actually read the comment before replying to it. –  neilfein Feb 28 at 19:59
5  
@neilfein - As long as you hate Jarjar we'll get along fine. –  Richard Feb 28 at 20:00
10  
They could both be correct. He could have had his hand cut off twice. If it's a flesh and bone hand or circuits and actuators, it's irrelevant. It's still 'his hand'. He will get another... –  Morgan Feb 28 at 20:23

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.