Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

There is a scene in The Clone Wars where Ahsoka is in the middle of hallway, deflecting blaster fire from two directions while carrying on a conversation (Cargo of Doom, I think ... ) and it got me wondering...

In the original trilogy, lightsabers are mostly dueled - but we see Luke successfully ward off blaster fire with 100% success (amended: see Kyle Jones' answer ... nearly 100%). He never gets hit.

In The Clone Wars, there are many examples like Ahsoka's where the Jedi are defending against an amazing amount of blaster fire. Often from multiple angles. Usually while talking.

But in the prequels, we see the defense effective - with the notable exception being when Sidious starts speed dialing Clone Troopers to murder Jedi:

Even then:

  • Master Mundi is clearly shocked at the betrayal and not defending himself fully
  • Secura is shot in the back while she is unarmed. Repeatedly.
  • Plo Koon is shot down while in a Starfighter
  • A Jedi is killed by speeder bike cannon fire (no lightsaber involved)

Obi Wan and Yoda make dramatic escapes. We basically see one lone nameless Jedi get gunned down in what looks like a fair fight. While conjecture might assume there were many more .. what we see onscreen is that the best chance you have to beat a Jedi that is ready and armed with a lightsaber is to bring a cannon.

Are there other notable times when a blaster beats a lightsaber?

share|improve this question
12  
Hokey religions and ancient weapons are no match for a good blaster at your side, kid. –  Jimmy Shelter Mar 14 at 7:49
    
Boba Fett's Father (Jango Fett) supposedly killed 6 jedi with nothing but his bare hands. You just have to know how to beat a Jedi. –  dxVxb Mar 18 at 19:13

4 Answers 4

Absolutely. Throughout the EU, there are cases where Jedi are overwhelmed by blaster fire. Usually they are alone, and often attacked by many others. But the most notable event outside Order 66 was at the Battle of Geonosis:

Of the 212 Jedi who were part of the strike team, an unknown number fought in the arena. Only an estimated thirty of those survived the initial battle, of which at least one more died during the battle that followed, making the losses suffered by the team grave. All of the leaders of the strike force except Coleman Trebor survived, while some others were captured and others (Barriss Offee and Pablo-Jill) escaped the battle. Only the timely arrival of Jedi Master Yoda and the newly-created Grand Army of the Republic saved the strike team from impending destruction. Despite the high casualties suffered by the Jedi, their mission was successful, and Obi-Wan Kenobi, Anakin Skywalker, and Padmé Amidala were rescued from execution. (emphasis mine)

Jedi Knights Sta-Den Eekin, Sarrissa Jeng, Sar Labooda, Sephjet Josall, Ichi-Tan Micoda, Khaat Qiyn, Que-Mars Redath-Gom, Fi-Ek Sirch, Nicanas Tassu, and Lura Tranor were all slain by droid blaster fire.

Also, as noted in the EU novel Labyrinth of Evil, which takes place immediately before Star Wars Episode III, droids were effective at killing Jedi. As droids could not be sensed through the Force due to their inorganic nature, and could have their physical attributes extraordinarily augmented, they could be extremely effective Jedi hunters.

The wookiepedia article on Jedi Hunters described beings and droids that were effective at killing Jedi.

share|improve this answer

Luke was shot in his artificial hand in Return of the Jedi, so forget about 100% success.

enter image description here

At the time he was shouting at Leia trying to get her to point the huge cannon at the deck of the Jabba's flying junk, sail barge or whatever that thing was. So a distracted Jedi can get shot.

share|improve this answer
    
Good catch. One could argue that the net result is the same - but I can't really disagree that the distraction doesn't justify / cause the outcome. –  joshbirk Mar 14 at 4:15

Somewhat related to @Ssumner's answer: During battle of Geonosis, Jango Fett killed a Jedi Master Coleman Trebor with a blaster:

enter image description here

share|improve this answer
    
Also in "The Mandalore Plot", The Clone Wars - two Mandalorians bring down Obi-Wan with blasters. He is clearly armed and ready in the scene. Perhaps the shooting skills of a Mandalore matches the dueling skill of a Jedi? –  joshbirk Mar 14 at 4:58
    
@joshbirk - Mandalorians were very good with blasters. Some, like Fett, were known to be able to hold their own in one-on-one combat –  SSumner Mar 14 at 10:47

I lightsaber can deflect a blaster shot, but only if it comes into contact with it. If the saber blade doesn't hit the shot then it can't do anything. Skilled swordsmen can defend themselves from multiple angles of fire with their saber by deflecting it all. However jedi have been beaten by blaster bolts because they didn't deflect the blasters bolts. Having a lightsaber doesn't make you immune to blaster fire. However if a lightsaber comes into contact with a bolt it will render it useless-ish.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.