Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In The Undiscovered Country, the Klingons view Shakespeare as one of their own and the Earth versions as adaptations. How on Earth could that be? Shakespeare was certainly human as forehead ridges would have been noticed even in that period of history.

Is this some cosmic coincidence with similar works by two different writers or did the Klingons like the work so much they retconned him as one of their writers?

share|improve this question
4  
Shouldnt that be: "How on Qo'Nos could that be?" or possibly - given the story "How on Praxis could that be?" –  Steven Wood Apr 3 at 14:53
16  
Has it crossed your mind that the Klingon in question was joking? That is, the Klingon knew perfectly well that Shakespeare was human, and saying he was originally Klingon is a metaphorical way of expressing how much the Klingons admire him. –  Royal Canadian Bandit Apr 3 at 14:54
2  
Is it also possible that Klingons visited Earth incognito around 1560 and left an English version of their favourite playwright there for an enterprising you Will Shakespeare to copy and pass of as his own? –  DJClayworth Apr 3 at 18:25
1  
Wait, it occurs to you that Shakespeare is Klingon, but not that Klingon blood has the wrong color? Or that Worf, who is Kirk's lawyer in that movie, must be around 200 years old in TNG/DS9? –  Damon Apr 4 at 15:19
1  
@Damon actually, it is his grandfather: en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Worf_%28Colonel%29 –  Davidmh Apr 5 at 13:34

2 Answers 2

up vote 42 down vote accepted

Probably the latter. Star Trek seems to like this joke; Chekov claimed many things as "invented in Russia," Spock attributes Sherlock Holmes quotes and Richard Nixon quotes to ancient Vulcans (though the Sherlock thing could be real, I suppose, since Spock is also half human), Quark claims the phrase "discretion is the better part of valor" as a Ferengi proverb, and Khan says "Revenge is a dish best served cold" is a Klingon saying. I think it was just one point on the line of a running gag. (a running gagh?)

Interestingly, the line became a problem in the shooting of The Undiscovered Country, as Mark Okrand (who invented the Klingon language) recounts:

There is one line of Shakespeare that is spoken in Klingon in the film, though it wasn’t part of the original script. That line is “To be or not to be.” When the film’s director, Nick Meyer, asked me to create a Klingon version of that, I said “okay,” but I thought “oh, no.” The problem was that there is no verb in Klingon that means “to be,” and I make a big deal about that in the book. I thought a bit and asked Nick if the line could mean “to live or not to live.” [But Christopher Plummer didn't like it, so] I thought some more, and suggested that taH replace yIn: taH pagh taHbe’. [...] The syllable taH, up until that moment, had been a suffix meaning “to continue doing” whatever the verb it was attached to was, so “eat” plus taH meant “to continue eating.” I sort of gave it a promotion to full verb status, but keeping the same meaning. So a new word meaning “to go on, to continue, to endure,” was created: “To continue or not to continue, to go on or not to go on.”

share|improve this answer
2  
Yes, that seems right. Thanks for the informative answer! –  Valten1992 Apr 3 at 15:00
    
Without having really looked too deeply into it -- I always sort of thought it was because the typical old pictures of Shakespeare one sees (that sort of disembodied head in an oblong) vaguely resembles the Klingons of old… this is a better explain though –  Stick Apr 3 at 16:39
7  
I always assumed that quotes above were universal translator bugs. When translated there were similar meaning earth expressions that meant the same thing. –  sixtyfootersdude Apr 3 at 16:40
2  
I think that would be a great in-universe justification for it, sixtyfootersdude. Though it does sound like something the Klingons would do, stealing a violent playwright from a race of ptaQs who don't deserve him. :-) Same with Ferengi. "They think they know cowardice? They've never even seen cowardice!" –  ilinamorato Apr 3 at 17:51
    
I always assumed it meant the original translation but I like this answer much more! –  Liath Apr 4 at 10:45

A wikipedia article claims that in the audio commentary on Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, Special Collectors Edition, the director N. Meyer claims the idea for having the Klingons claim Shakespeare as their own was based on Nazi Germany's attempt to claim the Bard as German before World War II.

share|improve this answer
    
Those fecking Nazis! Up to no good as usual! –  Daft Oct 8 at 9:56

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.