Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Of course, Westeros is the main stage for A Song of Ice and Fire, but how important is it at a ... planetary scope?

There is a lot of civilisation beyond the Narrow Sea and, especially around the Narrow Sea, most of it is very evolved in terms of society and economy. Also the Dothraki may live a very wildling-ish life, but they appear neither afraid of nor foreign to higher cultures. There are also the Wildlings north of the wall, which also seems to be a large civilisation.

So how important is Westeros to the entire planet? Are they a few amongst many or are they the most sophisticated society on that planet and take a rather leading role?


More information I found

I rewatched the TV show and did a little army counting on the side. The numbers don't feel mathematically sound, but maybe the Westerosis are very good at accounting for losses in most recent battles, while I'm not. Give or take a few garrisons, all of Westeros has (had) about 300k soldiers. If I had to guess I'd say that's a little more than the Wildlings and all of Essos put together, but I can't find solid numbers on those. So, measuring in military size and assuming there aren't any other big inhabitated continents we don't know of, Westeros is about half the world. I'm still having trouble gauging the size of Essos.

In Yunkai alone, there are about 200k slaves (according to TV show S3E7). This allows for speculation that Yunkai alone has a population somewhere between 200k and 1m people. If Yunkai does not greatly outsize all other Free Cities, Essos probably has a much larger population than Westeros. Kings Landing has a population of 500k.

share|improve this question
    
This is only a comment, but I will say Westeros is very heavily inspired by medieval England so I'd imagine it could be comparable to England vs mainland Europe in the middle ages. When you look at larger maps including Essos, judging from the comparable geography to that of Europe I'd say Westeros is definitely a great power, but one of several. If Westeros was united and attempted to invade Essos, there'd probably be a stalemate, and a Hundred Years War-type scenario would develop. –  Starkers Apr 20 at 0:16
2  
I think speaking very roughly, the armies in Essos are about the same size and number as the ones in Westeros. Essos seemingly has fewer large cities, but has a few cities that are bigger than many in Westeros. Essos is also wealthier as a whole, because the Iron Bank of Braavos alone can finance so much of the crown's spending, and also more powerful, because even the Iron Bank is in a position to make demands of the crown. –  Superbest Apr 20 at 0:57
1  
This is a great question. Judging from the books, I think Essos is actually more powerful and advanced than Westeros. A mix of Rome (erm, Valyria) and Renaissance states. Westeros looks backwards by comparison, which is funny because it's clear many characters consider the lands "across the Narrow Sea" to be inhabited by exotic barbarians. –  Andres F. Apr 23 at 16:09
    
“Westeros is very heavily inspired by medieval England” — there you go, it’s England. We’re kind of a big deal. –  Paul D. Waite Jun 9 at 16:04
add comment

2 Answers 2

up vote 21 down vote accepted

I think it's important to understand the planet, and how much is known. Currently there are 4 known continents of the known world: Westeros, Essos, Sothoryos, and Ulthos. We should remember that civilisation in the known world is currently at a state where there are many parts of the world still uncharted. It is entirely possible that there are more continents that are not known. Consider the late discovery of the Americas, and the even later discovery of Australia, by Eurasian civilisation.

Further to this, we don't even know a significant amount about the four continents. Little is known about Sothoryos, and almost nothing is known about Ulthos. Even the two continents that are known, Westeros and Essos, are not fully charted. No complete map of Essos exists, and the polar regions to the far north of Westeros, way beyond the Wall are still unexplored. However, these lands are unlikely to contain any great civilisation, if life at all, so we can consider the knowledge to be sufficient.

So this means that any answer can only truly be based on a comparison between Westeros and Essos.

The main difference between Westeros and Essos is that the former is united as The Seven Kingdoms (clearly the civil wars in A Song of Ice and Fire throw this into question, but lets look at this from the start of the series). With the exception of a few raids from the wildlings, a few pirates along the narrow sea, and bandits roaming the kingdom, Westeros has enjoyed relative peace. This has allowed their civilisation to prosper. Lords are free to devote resources to keeping roads safe, and clearing bandit raids, allowing smaller villages and farmsteads to enjoy a safer life.

Essos consists of many different peoples. A few of the most significant are the Dothraki, the Free Cities, the Lhazareen, Qarth, and many other regions. One of the main territories was the Valyrian Freehold. Once a great, powerful and knowledgeable territory, left in ruins and all but extinct since the Doom of Valyria.

As Essos is not united, the internal fighting, and the threat of the fierce Dothraki, has shaped the continent into a very different civilisation to Westeros. Rather than many villages and farms surrounding a Lord's castle, as is the case with Westeros, much of the Essos civilisation consists of huge, fruitful cities, with high walls and little outside. An obvious example of this is Qarth. An impressive port city, booming on trade, but surrounded by nothing but wasteland. The reason for this sort of growth, is that smaller villages struggle to withstand the Dothraki. The Lhazareen are constantly under attack from the Dothraki, and the Kingdom of Sarnor has been left in ruins from Dothraki attack. Therefore the best option for civilisation in Essos is a concentrated city, near the sea, allowing them to amass a large, single army to defend them, surrounded by high city walls.

It's hard to compare different civilisations in this world, as it is not a global world such as our own. Westeros is quite insular, but is clearly a significant land mass and civilisation within the known world. I'll try and find canon examples of mentions of Westeros' significance, but hopefully this will provide you with enough information.

share|improve this answer
    
At least this draws a picture of what we (may) know. I started wondering, because it "only" takes a one month travel by horse from Kingslanding in the far south to Winterfell, which is only a few days from the Wall. Clearly, Westeros stretches much further north-south than east-west. However, we also believe that the planet is much larger than earth, making Westeros really tiny in comparison ... –  user1129682 Apr 19 at 15:11
1  
There's definitely some logic to the accents. People from the north have Northern English accents. Of course this isn't perfect. For example, both Ned Stark and Robert Baratheon have Northern accents, but Robert was from the Stormlands, and both of them grew up in the Eyrie. –  Moogle Apr 19 at 15:57
2  
@Moogle: then there’s Littlefinger’s accent. No-one in the UK has any idea what that’s meant to be. –  Paul D. Waite Jun 9 at 17:20
1  
@PaulD.Waite Although it seems to have become more Irish as the show progresses. In Season 1 there was no trace of his Irish accent. By season 4 it's heavily permeating his "Petyr Baelish" accent. –  Moogle Jun 9 at 18:34
3  
@Moogle: yeah, kind of I guess. But it’s not particularly Irish even now — no-one in Ireland sounds like that unless they’re really drunk, and that’s obviously pretty rare. –  Paul D. Waite Jun 9 at 18:37
show 3 more comments

I would say that it has never been properly established. In some ways, individuals and cities seem very wealthy in Essos, and there are rumours of magic in Asshai, but there has never really been any fair measure shown to compare them.

Some characters in the books refer to the other side as barbarians, and such, but GRRM is infamous in his use of subjective opinions, so that does not really say anything.

I would say that one thing that Westeros has going for it is that it is united. The entire continent is ruled by one king (or it used to be, at least), whereas Essos consists of many large cities, with lots of wilderness in between (or so it seems, in the travel descriptions and the maps). Pentos, Braavos, Mereen, Astapor, Yunkai, Qarth, Volantis, these are all cities -- not countries -- and there is no king or ruler over all of Essos.

In the days before the Doom of Valyria, the Valyrian Freehold ruled the world, with dragons and magic, but they never travelled to Westeros, until the Targaryens built Dragonstone. After the Doom, the Targaryens conquered Westeros with their dragons and created the Seven Kingdoms of Westeros.

If anything, it has been hinted that Valyria was the supreme nation of the world, and that after its Doom, the rest of the world has been left without a clear leader.

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.