Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

The hand to hand combat prowess of STNG Starfleet's security personnel is lauded by Tasha Yar in the accepted answer to this question.

Tasha: I think you should know that there is no physical training anywhere that matches Starfleet, especially its security people.

It is likely combat training evolved during the time elapsed between TOS and STNG, but Kirk definitely had specific moves which he seemed to be trained in and repeatedly used during his 5 year mission.

While some of the moves are identifiable, I find it difficult to pin a label on the double handed, flying hip check, style William Shatner utilized in his portrayal of James Kirk. According to canon, is Kirk practicing a known fighting style, and if so, what is it?

share|improve this question
13  
In TOS it's called Kirkfu and is one of the greatest fighting styles ever devised, and shows James Tiberius Kirk to be one of the greatest fighting men the galaxy has ever seen. In TNG it's a delicate but powerful blend of Aikido and T'ai chi ch'uan mixed with ballet poses and takes about 10 minutes to learn. –  Morgan May 27 at 4:30
1  
I dispute the duplicity of this question. When I look at the possible duplicate, I see a maneuver named, but not the fighting style. I would imagine that Star Trek lore would name the fighting style, even if it was retroactively identified. –  Major Stackings May 27 at 7:42
1  
@Richard I redefine my objection. IMHO, the other question was not satisfactorily answered, thereby my questions answer cannot be found in the answers that have been provided so far. –  Major Stackings May 27 at 13:47
1  
The double handed axe strike is not a fighting style. It is a fighting move, so IMHO, your opinion is invalid in regards to this question and the accepted answer to the other. –  Major Stackings May 27 at 14:29
2  
Judging by his use of bad dropkicks, crappy double-axe handle smashes, Austin Powers-style "Judo chops", and his ridiculous over-selling of every blow, Kirk's fighting style was apparently second-rate 1980s pro-wrestling. –  James Sheridan May 28 at 1:03

1 Answer 1

up vote 10 down vote accepted

Captain Kirk is shown to be practicing Judo (TOS 1x07, 'Charlie X') but his actual 'fighting style' seems to be made up on the fly with no resemblance to an actual organized form or style.

Captain Kirk practicing Judo

In the Next Generation Lt. Yar conjures up a hododeck Aikido opponent to demonstrate Starfleet Security force training to visiting Dignitaries in (TNG: 1x04 'Code of Honor').

Lt Yar in the holodeck

There have been no other mentions of any 'modern day' form of martial art training, but there has been a couple of made-up (in universe) martial art forms briefly shown in TNG:

Anbo-jyutsu — (TNG: 2x14, "The Icarus Factor") involves wearing helmets that do not allow a combatant to see and using large, electrified pugil sticks that signal when aimed at the opponent. Practitioners of this art include Cmdr. William Riker and his father Kyle.

And

Worf teaches some of the Enterprise crew an art called 'Mok'bara' that looks suspiciously like a bad rendition of T'ai chi ch'uan.

share|improve this answer
    
As an aside and out of universe, if you look at that image of Yar facing off with "Aikido 1", it's painfully clear that Crosby has absolutely no idea what she's doing. –  Morgan May 28 at 2:26
    
That's okay. With the exception of the Voyager episode featuring The Rock, no-one in any of Trek's fight scenes has ever known what they were doing. –  James Sheridan May 29 at 0:35
    
Let me introduce one word that says it all: choreographed. –  WhatRoughBeast May 31 at 2:18
    
Certainly choreographed, and more likely by the dance director than a fight director. –  paul Jun 4 at 2:03

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.