Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Dolores Umbridge, chapter 13, Detention with Dolores, Harry's scar hurts when Umbridge touches him. However, the canon does not establish any direct connection between Voldemort and Umbridge. Are there any canonical explanations of what happened?

share|improve this question
1  
Good question! Looking forward to reading some good answers. –  Django Reinhardt Jul 19 at 11:13
    
So I trapped into anothother one of Lady R's pitfalls? –  chaosflaws Jul 19 at 11:38
    
Magic!!! ...... –  Awal Garg Jul 20 at 7:38
3  
@AwalGarg - There's no magic in Harry Potter. It's all down to advanced genetics and hidden machinery. –  Richard Jul 20 at 17:01
    
@Richard blasphemer! How dare you deny to the existence of magic in Rowling's sacred world? :P –  Awal Garg Jul 21 at 9:16

1 Answer 1

up vote 25 down vote accepted

It was just a coincidence.

Voldemort is planning the escape of his key lieutenants from Azkhaban and is alternately happy and frustrated. Those strong emotions make Harry's scar tingle. He also feels a similar pain when getting changed after Quidditch in Chapter 18.

‘What happened?’ said Ron, the moment Alicia had disappeared through the door. ‘Was it your scar?’ Harry nodded. ‘But …’ looking scared, Ron strode across to the window and stared out into the rain, ‘he – he can’t be near us now, can he?’ ‘No,’ Harry muttered, sinking on to a bench and rubbing his forehead. ‘He’s probably miles away. It hurt because … he’s … angry.’

A confused tangle of shapes, a howling rush of voices … ‘He wants something done, and it’s not happening fast enough,’ he said. Again, he felt surprised to hear the words coming out of his mouth, and yet was quite certain they were true.

and

‘Is this what it was about last time?’ said Ron in a hushed voice. ‘When your scar hurt in Umbridge’s office? You-Know-Who was angry?’

Harry shook his head.

‘What is it, then?’

Harry was thinking himself back. He had been looking into Umbridge’s face … his scar had hurt … and he had had that odd feeling in his stomach … a strange, leaping feeling … a happy feeling … but of course, he had not recognised it for what it was, as he had been feeling so miserable himself …

‘Last time, it was because he was pleased,’ he said. ‘Really pleased. He thought … something good was going to happen. And the night before we came back to Hogwarts …’ he thought back

Ron later identifies (in chapter 25) what kept making Voldemort so frustrated/happy;

"The Ministry of Magic announced late last night that there has been a mass breakout from Azkaban. Speaking to reporters in his private office, Cornelius Fudge, Minister for Magic, confirmed that ten high-security prisoners escaped in the early hours of yesterday evening and that he has already informed the Muggle Prime Minister of the dangerous nature of these individuals.

‘There you are, Harry,’ said Ron, looking awestruck. ‘That’s why he was happy last night.’"

share|improve this answer
    
This takes place in chapter 26. It refers to Harry’s scar hurting in chapter 25, when he’s in the Gryffindor dormitory, not in detention with Umbridge. Do we know if the detention scar pain was related to the Azkaban breakout? –  alexwlchan Jul 19 at 11:02
    
@alexwlchan - The planning of the breakout takes a few chapters. He's probably happy because the Dementors have agreed to turn a blind eye or because he's gotten a message to his followers inside the prison. –  Richard Jul 19 at 11:07
1  
Well, the pain described when Umbridge touches him is distinct from the one described here: It's a sharp, sudden pain. This is a reasonable explanation, but how do you account for that? –  chaosflaws Jul 19 at 11:55
5  
@chaosflaws - The pains are caused by his connection with Voldemort, plain and simple. The fact that it happened when Umbridge was touching him is merely a coincidence, albeit one that JKR intentionally created in order to cast suspicion on her as a potential death-eater. –  Richard Jul 19 at 12:19

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.