Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In the Goblet of Fire, during the Third Task, Harry hears Fleur scream while in the maze. He assumes she is out of action. Later, Krum attacks Cedric with the Cruciatus curse. After Harry stuns Krum, he and Cedric wonder if Krum attacked Fleur, too, which would explain Fleur's scream.

Later, though, when fake Moody is talking to Harry about helping Harry through the task, he says he stunned Fleur and then had Krum attack Cedric. Why would Fleur have screamed? She would have just been knocked out, there wouldn't be any scream. How is this explained?

share|improve this question
2  
That's called a plot hole. A very small one. –  Sulthan Jul 22 at 9:51
8  
She could have screamed at something entirely different. Harry & Cedric only think that's Fleur being taken out, when actually maybe she's just screaming because a giant spider lunged out at her (which she successfully defeated/evaded anyway) and then some time after that Moody takes her out silently. There's no reason to believe the scream from Moody's attack. –  Shisa Jul 22 at 10:32
    
She was scared init? –  Pompom78 Jul 22 at 20:58

2 Answers 2

up vote 4 down vote accepted

It may be because Fleur must have seen someone(fake Moody) in the dark of the maze going to attack her, because he is the one who stunned her. So in that fear she would have screamed.

share|improve this answer

This is what the wikia has to say about it.

However, due to the machinations of Barty Crouch Jr.—disguised, via Polyjuice Potion, as Alastor Moody— Fleur did not last long. Crouch wanted Harry to reach the Triwizard Cup so that he could be transported to meet with Lord Voldemort. To achieve this, he used Moody's magical eye to find Fleur in the maze and stun her.

Also this.

As he patrolled around the labyrinth hedge, he stunned Fleur Delacour and used the Imperius Curse on Viktor to get rid of Cedric, but Viktor Krum was stunned by Harry.

In hindsight I remember this being the canon reason in the books. I will try to find a canon quote though as I don't have the books open in front of me now.

Other theories

Although I think the first theory is the best as it is mostly canon.

Maybe she saw the Fake Mooody about to attack her before she got knocked out. Or maybe she saw Victor having the Imperius curse used on him.

Harry hears Fleur screaming, but, is unable to locate her

Along the way, he hears Fleur scream.

Maybe she saw some of this.

During the task, Barty Crouch Jr, posing as Alastor Moody by way of the Polyjuice Potion, managed to place the Imperius Curse on Viktor as part of his plot to steer Harry Potter to victory in the Tournament. Under Moody's control, he caught up with Cedric and performed the Cruciatus Curse on him. However, he was Stunned by Harry and left unconscious. Cedric, against his better judgement, used his wand to shoot red sparks into the air, allowing him to be rescued from the maze.

Or Was attacked by a creature that was put in the maze.

  1. Spiders
  2. Blast Ended Skrewts

I personally don't think she got that far as the Fake Moody probably got rid of her as fast he could. And since she came into the maze last, she was probably easy pickings. She probably tried to run and fell or something, so she screamed. Or she saw the Fake Moody holding his wand in her face and that scared her.

Below is my old answer, but I think its total rubbish.

Maybe she saw Victor Krum about to attack her before she got knocked out. Or maybe she saw Victor having the Imperius curse used on him.

I don't think it is ever explained in the book. As this is all I think that happens.

Harry hears Fleur screaming, but, is unable to locate her

And from the wikia.

Along the way, he hears Fleur scream.

share|improve this answer
    
Wikia isn't canon –  DVK Jul 23 at 19:58

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.