Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

During the attack on Naboo, Padme used a decoy and posed as one of her own handmaidens. When she later reveals herself to the Gungans, Obi Wan looks genuinely surprised but Qui-Gon smiles.

Earlier in the film there are a few exchanges which indicates he either doesn't know (or perhaps he's teasing her?)

Padme - You Jedi are far too reckless, the queen will not...

Qui Gon - The queen trusts my judgement young handmaiden, and so should you.

Do we know for sure he's in the dark as much as anyone else?

share|improve this question
37  
I mis-read this as "Did Qui-Gon know the Queen was doable?" I was thinking; 'Dude's a Jedi, not blind!' –  James Sheridan Jul 22 at 10:19
7  
The Queen was 14 when she met Qui-Gon, so ew. –  George T Jul 22 at 10:20
15  
@GeorgeT That's an acceptable age in some star systems. –  FreeAsInBeer Jul 22 at 12:50
15  
@FreeAsInBeer - That's acceptable age through half of Europe and most of the rest of the world minus United States of Puritanism. –  Davor Jul 22 at 13:48
12  
Being a Jedi master implies at least being able to assume the "I have known it all along" face under any circumstances. Even human consultants can do that ! –  Tom Leek Jul 22 at 19:57

2 Answers 2

up vote 33 down vote accepted

The script makes it clear that Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan both knew (or at least very strongly suspected):

PADME: I am Queen Amidala.

JAR JAR and ANAKIN are stunned.

PADME: (points to Queen) This is my decoy... my protection... my loyal bodyguard.

OBI-WAN and QUI-GON give each other a knowing look.


The Terry Brooks novelisation gives an indication of precisely when Qui-Gon Jinn first began to suspect that something was amiss;

Queen Amidala leaned forward, and a slender white hand came out to touch the droid's domed casing. "Thank you Artoo-Detoo. You have proven both loyal and brave." She glanced over her shoulder. "Padme."

One of her handmaidens came forward. Qui-gon Jinn, listening to the exchange with half an ear as he considered the problems that lay ahead on Tatooine, noticed that it was the young woman who had supported the Queen's decision to escape from Naboo. He frowned. Except, it hadn't been exactly like that . . .

"See to the cleaning up of this little droid." The Queen was speaking to the girl. "Artoo-Detoo deserves our gratitude." She turned back to Panaka. "Please continue with your report Captain."

share|improve this answer
1  
Not to mention that when they are going to look around Tatooine, Qui-Gon gets more upset when the 'hand maid' want's to come along than he has throughout the film to that point. –  xXGrizZ Jul 22 at 11:52
1  
@xXGrizZ - I read that scene as being an indication that they hadn't worked it out yet. It was only after they had a chance to spend time with her that they realised what was going on/ –  Richard Jul 22 at 11:54
26  
This is supposed to be a KNOWING look? Ewan, Liam, you're fired. youtu.be/RNEQ3y1qPAM?t=3m10s –  Plutor Jul 22 at 11:55
1  
@Richard I think they knew the instant they met the double but were playing along because it was a good idea. It wasn't until the actual Queen started interfering and putting herself in danger that Qui-Gon had to say something. I could be wrong but the very first time I saw that scene I said to my self, 'he knows.' –  xXGrizZ Jul 22 at 12:00
1  
@Plutor there's a bunch to hate in the movies, but you can clearly see them almost smirking/ holding in smiles. How much more obvious would an actor have to be? Tapping their noses and winking would hardly be how 2 ambassadors would behave during a diplomatic meeting! –  Shisa Jul 22 at 13:28

One would think that a Jedi Master would know via the Force - the ultimate hunch, if you will. The exchange you quote above is by no means conclusive proof that he didn't know - it sounds to me as if he is using the fact that he knows she is the Queen to end the argument, and also to warn the Queen that she is going to blow her cover by acting 'above her station' (as a handmaiden).

share|improve this answer
    
It is precisely this implied warning that gave me the same impression. –  Bogdan Alexandru Jul 23 at 14:51

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.