Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

At one point, Tom Riddle, and perhaps even Salazar Slytherin himself, used the Basilisk to attack, even kill, Muggleborn students at Hogwarts. Tom Riddle said so himself:

‘Haven’t I already told you,’ said Riddle quietly, ‘that killing Mudbloods doesn’t matter to me any more? For many months now, my new target has been – you.’

Harry stared at him.

Chamber of Secrets - page 230 - Bloomsbury - chapter seventeen, The Heir of Slytherin

Presumably, Tom Riddle was setting the Basilisk loose in the castle to kill "Mudbloods" prior to becoming interested in Harry Potter; however, how could the Basilisk tell whether a student (or teacher, I suppose) was Muggleborn or not?

Tom Riddle doesn't say, "Go forth and kill anyone you encounter!" He was specific: He wanted Muggleborns killed.

share|improve this question
    
may be non magic can be smelled? The basilisk's senses seem to be highly developoed –  user13267 Aug 1 at 15:12
    
Do we know if Riddle/Ginny let the Basilisk loose, or did they direct the Basilisk to Muggle-borns? Perhaps it just attacked people that Riddle knew were Muggle-borns. –  alexwlchan Aug 1 at 15:36
    
There appears to be something that allows the basilisk to only obey Riddle's instructions, and not Harry's. I wouldn't be shocked if the basilisk was enchanted by Slytherin to only follow the Heir of Slytherin's instructions. If there's magic that allows it to discern whether someone is descended from a wizard who lived 1000 years ago, presumably there'd be magic for determining whether someone's parents were wizards. –  TenthJustice Aug 1 at 15:48
    
Its a stretch to say that the snake is enchanted to only follow slytherins heir. Simpily the fact that riddle has known the snake for 50 years gives him weight and control over harry. Also why enchant something that only your family can talk to. In the book they never mention anyone outside of Slytherins family that can speak Parsletonge, so that makes things alot simpler. –  Himarm Aug 1 at 15:53
    
@Himarm - Chamber of Secrets addresses the Heir of Slytherin: Hermione’s hand was back in the air. ‘Sir – what exactly do you mean by the ‘horror within’ the Chamber?’ ‘That is believed to be some sort of monster, which the heir of Slytherin alone can control,’ said Professor Binns in his dry, reedy voice. Herpo the Foul was a Parselmouth. Why was Parseltongue passed only down through the Slytherin line? Canon and JKR doesn't say why, but it is canon. We can't just say it's not. –  Slytherincess Aug 2 at 5:18

3 Answers 3

The bit quoted in the question tells one important thing up front:

1. Riddle has the means and ability to successfully tell the Basilisk to target a specific person.

We know a Basilisk can follow orders (from both Magical Beasts and from CoS: "It won’t come until it is called,” said Riddle calmly).

When Riddle says his target has been Harry for months, he doesn't have very many means other than the Basilisk with which to do so - Ginny couldn't be seen behaving too suspiciously out in the open; and Harry ends up hearing the Basilisk in the pipes many times even outside of Myrtle's Bathroom. So it doesn't seem too far-fetched to assume that statement is implying Tom has been having Harry followed around by the Basilisk. Reason being that he knows Harry won't be able to help 'playing the hero' and thereby increases their chances of 'meeting'.

This would also explain, beyond the huge coincidence it looks like, in the books, how Harry is the first one to literally stumble into Justin.

If Tom can tell the Basilisk to specifically target one person aka Harry, presumably he can tell it to do the same for others.

It also tells us that targeting Harry has replaced killing Mudbloods, so it doesn't seem too much of a stretch to assume that the method being used for both was the same; aka specific targeting - the Basilisk cannot be using some 'intrinsic' quality of Muggleborns to target them, because it could not have used that quality to target Harry.


But there's another thing that points to this.

2. Every single Muggleborn attacked was one who would be known to Ginny, and who Ginny would have had reason to talk to Tom about.

We know that Ginny had been confiding to Tom about her school life, and all about her crush on Harry, and all about Harry's school life too.

  1. Colin Creevey: Ginny's Year & Housemate; Both had massive fancrushes on Harry was noted by Ron; Sat next to Ginny in Charms.

    Ginny Weasley, who sat next to Colin Creevey in Charms, was distraught...

  2. Justin Finch-Fletchley: The boy who accused Harry of being Slytherin's Heir; the one who was highly instrumental in the drama that led to the reveal about Harry being a Parseltongue - an event Ginny would certainly have talked to Tom about!

  3. Hermione Grander: Close friend of Harry and Ron; Cleverest Witch in her year. Presumably Ginny would have talked her both as a friend of her brother, friend of her crush, and for her own "Hermiony-ish"-ness, even if the two of them were not yet friends.

  4. Penelope Clearwater: It is possible she was petrified only because she was with Hermione at the time, but even she is someone Ginny would have had cause to talk to Tom about - she was Percy's "secret girlfriend", and Ginny was the only one aware of this.

Not one of people attacked is a random Muggleborn who Ginny would not have had reason to know, or reason to talk about. Which lends even more credence to the idea that the target needs to be specifically pointed out to the Basilisk.

3. As for how the target is recognized by the Basilisk...

I don't think we have any concrete idea of that. We can speculate, though. Some speculation:

  1. It couldn't be by face, because being hidden in then pipes, the Basilisk would hardly be able to see someone from within without also exposing itself - at which point whether it's seen by the 'right' person or not becomes a moot point. So the basilisk would need to have a way to recognize target before it confronted them.

  2. Tom was having Ginny pick up some item belonging to the targets, which was then used for tracking;

  3. The basilisk might be capable of understanding human speech and identifying students from their conversations and tracking them (by footsteps? smell? body heat? heartbeat?) to situations where they were alone. This could explain why the basilisk attacked Justin in the presence of Nearly-Headless Nick - the basilisk just realize Nick was there.

share|improve this answer
1  
Does the quote in the question really mean that Riddle had directed the basilisk to seek out Harry? I figured he meant that Harry was his "target" in a broader sense, namely that he wanted to lure him into the Chamber. –  TenthJustice Aug 1 at 17:09
    
I've added my assumptions and thought-processes regarding that conclusion in my answer - seems I skipped over that bit. :) Thanks for pointing that out! –  Shisa Aug 1 at 17:51

We know that the Basilisk can speak, so it is intelligent. We can then easily assume that Tom Riddle simple told the Basilisk who to attack. Now the question is did he give the Basilisk a picture? More likely the Basilisk also could smell. Therefore, I think Tom would simply have given the Basilisk something with the scent of a Muggleborn on it, and the Basilisk would be able to track and attack the Muggleborn. One other possibility is that Tom actively was out in the hallways with the Basilisk, or in the pipes, and would guide it to its target.

share|improve this answer
6  
"The ability to speak does not make you intelligent" - Qui-Gon Jinn –  TGnat Aug 1 at 14:51
    
intelligent in this instance is in reference to animal< magical creature <= human. –  Himarm Aug 1 at 14:54
5  
@tgnat - in fairness, jarjar is a respected war leader, diplomat and senator who repeatedly saves his people from enslavement whereas qui-Gon is obsessed with mentoring the next Hitler. I hardly think he's got room to criticise. –  Richard Aug 1 at 14:57
4  
jarjar starts the vote for the emperor to receive executive power in the senate though >.< so hes a little of the fail side too. –  Himarm Aug 1 at 15:06
    
Parselmouths can hear ANY snake speak. So that's no indication of how intelligent it is. –  TenthJustice Aug 1 at 15:43

I think this is easily answered based on the one victim everyone else seems to be ignoring: Mrs. Norris.

I could buy on some level that maybe a basilisk created by Salazar Slytherin and used by Tom Riddle could have been enchanted or trained in some sort of method to seek out a Muggleborn. But to seek out a Squib's cat? That seems highly unlikely.

I think the only explanation is that the basilisk is instructed to seek out specific students, and Riddle knew that each of the victims were Muggleborn because Ginny knew.

share|improve this answer
    
I think the Basilisk encountered Mrs. Norris accidentally. –  Slytherincess Aug 2 at 5:29

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.