Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Seeing as Clara has been in the Tardis - which automatically gives people(/living organisms) the ability to understand all languages - why doesn't she understand Dinosaur?

share|improve this question
6  
Maybe it had a lisp, or a strong (Southern) Gwondanan accent.. –  Andrew Thompson Sep 1 at 5:10
    
You assume that having been in the TARDIS gives people the ability to understand all languages. However, that's not how it works. The TARDIS itself does the translating for you. So, you have to be in close proximity to the TARDIS in order to understand what is being said (or, as appropriate, written). The Doctor, however, speaks the language of the dinosaur himself, without needing a machine translator. –  Mr Lister Sep 3 at 13:15
    
@MrLister do you have a source for this? –  tryingToGetProgrammingStraight Sep 5 at 4:36
    
Which one, the Doctor speaking dinosaur or the TARDIS doing the translations? –  Mr Lister Sep 5 at 8:08
    
@MrLister i was to TARDIS giving translation, but can i have both? –  tryingToGetProgrammingStraight Sep 5 at 21:19

2 Answers 2

up vote 16 down vote accepted

The specific limits of the TARDIS translation matrix have never been explicitly detailed (rendering it a slight case of "new rules as the plot demands," or it could always just be the Doctor talking nonsense, which would not be unusual), but it would seem that the translation matrix appears to draw the line at structurally "crude" languages, which is why the Doctor has also had to translate for babies ("A Good Man Goes to War", "Closing Time"), horses ("A Town Called Mercy"), and a Minotaur ("The God Complex"). Since none of them spoke in such a way that could be converted into a clear, formal language, the Doctor, who has some telepathic ability as well as just a general prowess for reading people and/or situations, had to cover for all of the aforementioned beings, as well as the dinosaur in "Deep Breath".

share|improve this answer
    
source for "some telepathic ability"? –  tryingToGetProgrammingStraight Sep 1 at 5:53
5  
The Doctor has limited telepathic abilities. The Tenth Doctor showed touch telepathic ability. So did the Eleventh. –  Thaddeus Sep 1 at 6:29
1  
@MacCooper In "The Impossible Planet" is is indicated the TARDIS can translate written text. –  S Vilcans Sep 1 at 11:44
3  
@SVilcans Written text. I know I know I said visual but I knew what I meant :) I'll give an example: When a dog is happy he wags his tail. Say the Doctor brought an alien to Earth, one that has never seen an animal with a tail before. The dog sees the alien, barks and wags his tail. Now to the Doctor, who knows what a dog is, will say the dog is happy. But would the TARDIS translate the barking and the wagging as words to the alien? The movement an animal makes is an important part of its language: without movement it's gibberish. –  Mac Cooper Sep 1 at 11:51
1  
@tryingToGetProgrammingStraight, ahh so he does. Um..... yeah I give up :-) –  Mac Cooper Sep 3 at 10:11

In the story The Christmas Invasion it was implied that the translation circuit was linked to the Doctor being conscious. In that story the Doctor has recently regenerated and was unconscious, thereby the translation circuit didn't work.

In Deep Breath the Doctor was also recently regenerated, and has not yet recuperated from the trauma, so it's safe to assume that the translation circuit was still not working properly when the dinosaur was talking. (The Doctor probably didn't use the TARDIS to translate the reptile's speech, or the circuit was only partially working and could only translate to the Doctor and not to anyone else)

Once the Doctor regained his strength the dinosaur was already dead, so we wouldn't know whether the TARDIS could translate its words or not.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.