Take the 2-minute tour ×
Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for science fiction and fantasy enthusiasts. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In Philosopher's Stone, Hagrid tells Harry how he was hired by Dumbledore.

"I was at Hogwarts meself but I — er — got expelled, ter tell yeh the truth. In me third year. They snapped me wand in half an’ everything. But Dumbledore let me stay on as gamekeeper. Great man, Dumbledore.”

But in the next book, we learn through Riddle's diary that Dumbledore wasn't the headmaster when Hagrid was expelled, Armando Dippet was. Every indication throughout the books is that headmasters make the hiring decisions, and as Dumbledore states in Order of the Phoenix, only the headmaster can allow people to continue living in Hogwarts:

"As High Inquisitor you have every right to dismiss my teachers. You do not, however, have the authority to send them away from the castle. I am afraid,' he went on, with a courteous little bow, 'that the power to do that still resides with the Headmaster, and it is my wish that Professor Trelawney continue to live at Hogwarts."

Confusing matters even further is that Goblet of Fire implies that when Mrs. Weasley was in school, there was a completely different gamekeeper.

Mrs. Weasley was intrigued by the Whomping Willow, which had been planted after she had left school, and reminisced at length about the gamekeeper before Hagrid, a man called Ogg.

Mrs. Weasley is older than Harry's parents, but surely she can't be THAT old- Hagrid and Voldemort are older than 70. This whole Hagrid timeline just seems completely off. Is this just another famous example of JK Rowling's math ineptitude, or is there another possibility I'm missing?

share|improve this question
9  
Also, before anyone claims that its possible that Dippet retired that year, Tom Riddle apparently asked him for a job after he graduated school two years later. –  TenthJustice Sep 4 at 0:42
24  
Repeat after me: "JKR is awful at maths"! –  DVK Sep 4 at 1:57
6  
@DVK How would you distinguish "awful at maths" from "does not care about maths?" –  Lexible Sep 4 at 3:01
1  
@lexible I think once your awful at numbers in general (e.g. you can take two arbitrary events and intuit an appropriate numerical difference in time) then it's hard to care as when things slip through the cracks you don't notice, so no care of required. –  Pureferret Sep 4 at 5:55
5  
I've not read these books myself, but this doesn't necessarily seem inconsistent. One possibility might be that the headmaster makes HR decisions for teaching staff, but may have delegated responsibility for non-teaching staff. Another possibility is that Dumbledore didn't technically hire Hagrid, but persuaded the then headmaster to hire him, leading Hagrid to credit Dumbledore for hiring him. Yet another possibility is that in the period of time between your two quotes hiring policies changed, but at the time Dumbledore hired Hagrid, the headmaster didn't have exclusive powers over HR. –  tobyink Sep 4 at 8:36

1 Answer 1

up vote 68 down vote accepted

Well, the answer is right there in the second book, chapter 16, The Chamber of Secrets. When Harry met Tom Riddle, and he told him about finding the chamber:

"Hagrid's my friend," said Harry, his voice now shaking. "And you framed him, didn't you? I thought you made a mistake, but -"
Riddle laughed his high laugh again.
"It was my word against Hagrid's, Harry. Well, you can imagine how it looked to old Armando Dippet. On the one hand, Tom Riddle, poor but brilliant, parentless but so brave, school prefect, model student... on the other hand, big, blundering Hagrid, in trouble every other week, trying to raise werewolf cubs under his bed, sneaking off to the Forbidden Forest to wrestle trolls...
but I admit, even I was surprised how well the plan worked. I thought someone must realize that Hagrid couldn't possibly be the Heir of Slytherin. It had taken >me five whole years to find out everything I could about the Chamber of Secrets and discover the secret entrance ... as though Hagrid had the brains, or the power!

And here comes the answer...

"Only the Transfiguration teacher, Dumbledore, seemed to think Hagrid was innocent. He persuaded Dippet to keep Hagrid and train him as gamekeeper. Yes, I think Dumbledore might have guessed .... Dumbledore never seemed to like me as much as the other teachers did ...

So, as we see here, Hagrid wasn't gamekeeper at that time, and Dumbledore kept him, but he persuaded Dippet to keep him and train him to become gamekeeper for later years.

share|improve this answer
1  
You beat me to this. I had the relevant quote under scifi.stackexchange.com/a/26939/4918 –  b_jonas Sep 4 at 7:06
2  
Great find! I guess it requires a rather liberal understanding of Dumbledore "letting" Hagrid stay on and a twenty-year apprenticeship, but it does appear to be the canon answer. –  TenthJustice Sep 4 at 12:11
    
@b_jonas - if you feel it's a dupe, bring it up on Meta. I'd rather not cast a binding VTC without having some sort of a consensus –  DVK Sep 4 at 15:22
    
@DVK: no, the question is not a dupe. –  b_jonas Sep 4 at 16:00

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.