Yes they are.
In Harry Potter and The HalfbloodHalf-blood Prince we see Dumbledore showing Harry a memory
Dumbledore showing Harry a memory of Slughorn that Dumbledore himself has already used.
that Dumbledore himself has already used.
Edited to only hide the core of what is apparently a terrible secret; the rest is simply a direct response to the question.
jscs
- 269
- 2
- 10
