Skip to main content
Poster was advised it is Bilbo who found the ring, not Frodo. Poster quoted LoTR in comment and it also says Bilbo.
Source Link

Only Ilúvatar has the power to give, or to deny, his gift. But oaths done in the name of Ilúvatar may have consequences beyond the power of the Valar. Fëanor's oath, as an example. Ilúvatar's will needn't to be perceived by men or elves clearly; his designs may appear in the history just as "Destiny" or "Doom". "Frodo"Bilbo was destined to find the Ring".

There's no text evidence that the Dead Men of Dunharrow made his allegiance to Isildur in the name of Ilúvatar, but the consequences of his perjury say so. Isildur's power is not what doomed them, but "Destiny".

Only Ilúvatar has the power to give, or to deny, his gift. But oaths done in the name of Ilúvatar may have consequences beyond the power of the Valar. Fëanor's oath, as an example. Ilúvatar's will needn't to be perceived by men or elves clearly; his designs may appear in the history just as "Destiny" or "Doom". "Frodo was destined to find the Ring".

There's no text evidence that the Dead Men of Dunharrow made his allegiance to Isildur in the name of Ilúvatar, but the consequences of his perjury say so. Isildur's power is not what doomed them, but "Destiny".

Only Ilúvatar has the power to give, or to deny, his gift. But oaths done in the name of Ilúvatar may have consequences beyond the power of the Valar. Fëanor's oath, as an example. Ilúvatar's will needn't to be perceived by men or elves clearly; his designs may appear in the history just as "Destiny" or "Doom". "Bilbo was destined to find the Ring".

There's no text evidence that the Dead Men of Dunharrow made his allegiance to Isildur in the name of Ilúvatar, but the consequences of his perjury say so. Isildur's power is not what doomed them, but "Destiny".

added 6 characters in body
Source Link
Mithical
  • 39.1k
  • 17
  • 182
  • 230

Only Ilúvatar has the power to give, or to deny, his gift. But oaths done in the name of Ilúvatar may have consecuencesconsequences beyond the power of the Valar. Fëanor's oath, as an example. Ilúvatar's will needn't to be perceived by men or elves clearly; his designs may appear in the history just as "Destiny" or "Doom". "Frodo was destined to find the Ring".

There's no text evidence that the Dead Men of Dunharrow made his allegiance to Isildur in the name of Ilúvatar, but the consecuencesconsequences of his perjury say so. Not Isildur's power is not what doomed them, but "Destiny".

Only Ilúvatar has the power to give, or to deny, his gift. But oaths done in the name of Ilúvatar may have consecuences beyond the power of the Valar. Fëanor's oath, as an example. Ilúvatar's will needn't to be perceived by men or elves clearly; his designs may appear in the history just as "Destiny" or "Doom". "Frodo was destined to find the Ring".

There's no text evidence that the Dead Men of Dunharrow made his allegiance to Isildur in the name of Ilúvatar, but the consecuences of his perjury say so. Not Isildur's power doomed them, but "Destiny".

Only Ilúvatar has the power to give, or to deny, his gift. But oaths done in the name of Ilúvatar may have consequences beyond the power of the Valar. Fëanor's oath, as an example. Ilúvatar's will needn't to be perceived by men or elves clearly; his designs may appear in the history just as "Destiny" or "Doom". "Frodo was destined to find the Ring".

There's no text evidence that the Dead Men of Dunharrow made his allegiance to Isildur in the name of Ilúvatar, but the consequences of his perjury say so. Isildur's power is not what doomed them, but "Destiny".

Source Link
Ginasius
  • 8.2k
  • 1
  • 35
  • 71

Only Ilúvatar has the power to give, or to deny, his gift. But oaths done in the name of Ilúvatar may have consecuences beyond the power of the Valar. Fëanor's oath, as an example. Ilúvatar's will needn't to be perceived by men or elves clearly; his designs may appear in the history just as "Destiny" or "Doom". "Frodo was destined to find the Ring".

There's no text evidence that the Dead Men of Dunharrow made his allegiance to Isildur in the name of Ilúvatar, but the consecuences of his perjury say so. Not Isildur's power doomed them, but "Destiny".