Skip to main content
replaced http://scifi.stackexchange.com/ with https://scifi.stackexchange.com/
Source Link

No Official Canon Answer, But Probably (even if they are uncommon)

Wizards and Witches seem to be more cavalier with the ideas of 'personal safety' and 'lives' than Muggles (see: Love Potions being legalLove Potions being legal, despite the fact that Muggles would consider them... uh, certainly not granting 'consent'). An Unbreakable Vow seems pretty impossible to actually force someone to do- i.e. if someone knowingly makes an Unbreakable Vow then breaks it, it's entirely their fault.

Obviously I imagine (but there is no evidence) that tricking someone into making an Unbreakable Vow that you know is impossible to complete will probably still constitute murder, just as the act of casting Stupefy isn't illegal, but you can still kill someone with it if you hit them off a broom or something (as stated by Harry).

It's entirely possible that the Vow won't even work if the task is actually impossible to complete.

That said it's entirely possible it's not a thing ordinary wizards just do. Clearly marriages would be a lot more stable if the wedding vows were Unbreakable, for instance ("I will never cheat on you because if I did I would literally drop dead.").

So why waste time legislating it? If someone wants to risk their life it's their business. If you don't want to make the Vow, just don't make it.

No Official Canon Answer, But Probably (even if they are uncommon)

Wizards and Witches seem to be more cavalier with the ideas of 'personal safety' and 'lives' than Muggles (see: Love Potions being legal, despite the fact that Muggles would consider them... uh, certainly not granting 'consent'). An Unbreakable Vow seems pretty impossible to actually force someone to do- i.e. if someone knowingly makes an Unbreakable Vow then breaks it, it's entirely their fault.

Obviously I imagine (but there is no evidence) that tricking someone into making an Unbreakable Vow that you know is impossible to complete will probably still constitute murder, just as the act of casting Stupefy isn't illegal, but you can still kill someone with it if you hit them off a broom or something (as stated by Harry).

It's entirely possible that the Vow won't even work if the task is actually impossible to complete.

That said it's entirely possible it's not a thing ordinary wizards just do. Clearly marriages would be a lot more stable if the wedding vows were Unbreakable, for instance ("I will never cheat on you because if I did I would literally drop dead.").

So why waste time legislating it? If someone wants to risk their life it's their business. If you don't want to make the Vow, just don't make it.

No Official Canon Answer, But Probably (even if they are uncommon)

Wizards and Witches seem to be more cavalier with the ideas of 'personal safety' and 'lives' than Muggles (see: Love Potions being legal, despite the fact that Muggles would consider them... uh, certainly not granting 'consent'). An Unbreakable Vow seems pretty impossible to actually force someone to do- i.e. if someone knowingly makes an Unbreakable Vow then breaks it, it's entirely their fault.

Obviously I imagine (but there is no evidence) that tricking someone into making an Unbreakable Vow that you know is impossible to complete will probably still constitute murder, just as the act of casting Stupefy isn't illegal, but you can still kill someone with it if you hit them off a broom or something (as stated by Harry).

It's entirely possible that the Vow won't even work if the task is actually impossible to complete.

That said it's entirely possible it's not a thing ordinary wizards just do. Clearly marriages would be a lot more stable if the wedding vows were Unbreakable, for instance ("I will never cheat on you because if I did I would literally drop dead.").

So why waste time legislating it? If someone wants to risk their life it's their business. If you don't want to make the Vow, just don't make it.

added 85 characters in body; edited body
Source Link
user46509
user46509

No Official Canon Answer, But Probably (even if they are uncommon)

Wizards and Witches seem to be more cavalier with the ideas of 'personal safety' and 'lives' than Muggles (see: Love Potions being legalLove Potions being legal, despite the fact that Muggles would consider them... uh, certainly not granting 'consent'). An Unbreakable Vow seems pretty impossible to actually force someone to do- i.e. if someone knowingly makes an Unbreakable Vow then breaks it, it's entirely their fault.

Obviously I imagine (but there is no evidence) that tricking someone into making an Unbreakable Vow that you know is impossible to complete will probably still constitute murder, just as the act of casting Stupefy isn't illegal, but you can still kill someone with it if you hit them off a broom or something (as stated by Harry).

It's entirely possible that the Vow won't even work if the task is actually impossible to complete.

That said it's entirely possible it's not a thing ordinary wizards just do. Clearly marriages would be a lot more stable if the wedding vows were Unbreakable, for instance ("I will never cheat on you because if I did I would literally drop dead.").

So why waste time legislating it? If someone wants to risk their life it's their business. If you don't want to make the Vow, just don't make it.

No Official Canon Answer, But Probably (even if they are uncommon)

Wizards and Witches seem to be more cavalier with the ideas of 'personal safety' and 'lives' than Muggles (see: Love Potions being legal, despite the fact that Muggles would consider them... uh, certainly not granting 'consent'). An Unbreakable Vow seems pretty impossible to actually force someone to do- i.e. if someone knowingly makes an Unbreakable Vow then breaks it, it's entirely their fault.

Obviously I imagine (but there is no evidence) that tricking someone into making an Unbreakable Vow that you know is impossible to complete will probably still constitute murder, just as the act of casting Stupefy isn't illegal, but you can still kill someone with it if you hit them off a broom or something (as stated by Harry).

It's entirely possible that the Vow won't even work if the task is actually impossible to complete.

That said it's entirely possible it's not a thing ordinary wizards just do. Clearly marriages would be a lot more stable if the wedding vows were Unbreakable, for instance ("I will never cheat on you because if I did I would literally drop dead.").

So why waste time legislating it? If someone wants to risk their life it's their business. If you don't want to make the Vow, just don't make it.

No Official Canon Answer, But Probably (even if they are uncommon)

Wizards and Witches seem to be more cavalier with the ideas of 'personal safety' and 'lives' than Muggles (see: Love Potions being legal, despite the fact that Muggles would consider them... uh, certainly not granting 'consent'). An Unbreakable Vow seems pretty impossible to actually force someone to do- i.e. if someone knowingly makes an Unbreakable Vow then breaks it, it's entirely their fault.

Obviously I imagine (but there is no evidence) that tricking someone into making an Unbreakable Vow that you know is impossible to complete will probably still constitute murder, just as the act of casting Stupefy isn't illegal, but you can still kill someone with it if you hit them off a broom or something (as stated by Harry).

It's entirely possible that the Vow won't even work if the task is actually impossible to complete.

That said it's entirely possible it's not a thing ordinary wizards just do. Clearly marriages would be a lot more stable if the wedding vows were Unbreakable, for instance ("I will never cheat on you because if I did I would literally drop dead.").

So why waste time legislating it? If someone wants to risk their life it's their business. If you don't want to make the Vow, just don't make it.

Source Link

No Official Canon Answer, But Probably (even if they are uncommon)

Wizards and Witches seem to be more cavalier with the ideas of 'personal safety' and 'lives' than Muggles (see: Love Potions being legal, despite the fact that Muggles would consider them... uh, certainly not granting 'consent'). An Unbreakable Vow seems pretty impossible to actually force someone to do- i.e. if someone knowingly makes an Unbreakable Vow then breaks it, it's entirely their fault.

Obviously I imagine (but there is no evidence) that tricking someone into making an Unbreakable Vow that you know is impossible to complete will probably still constitute murder, just as the act of casting Stupefy isn't illegal, but you can still kill someone with it if you hit them off a broom or something (as stated by Harry).

It's entirely possible that the Vow won't even work if the task is actually impossible to complete.

That said it's entirely possible it's not a thing ordinary wizards just do. Clearly marriages would be a lot more stable if the wedding vows were Unbreakable, for instance ("I will never cheat on you because if I did I would literally drop dead.").

So why waste time legislating it? If someone wants to risk their life it's their business. If you don't want to make the Vow, just don't make it.