Return to Question

The Elendil stone of Emyn Beraid was-

maintained and guarded by Cirdan and the Elves of Lindon

This stone had 'special abilities' in which it was not in accord with the other palantiri. And that it could view the master stone kept in Tol Eressea in Valinor.

[it] looked back with straight sight into the vanished west

It is possible that the elves which traveled to Lindon did so to use the Elendil Stone. (an example of this are the elves Frodo and Sam meet in Fellowship of the Ring who are returning from Lindon led by Gildor)

However my question is: did Cirdan use this Palantir to communicate with the West and possibly pass messages along to the Wise? It seemed the Valar did play some part in the affairs of Mmiddle-earth (sending Gandalf back, gusts of wind to aide Aragorn's ship etc.) and who better to communicate with than the literally ancient and wise elf that Cirdan is?

The Elendil stone of Emyn Beraid was-

maintained and guarded by Cirdan and the Elves of Lindon

This stone had 'special abilities' in which it was not in accord with the other palantiri. And that it could view the master stone kept in Tol Eressea in Valinor.

[it] looked back with straight sight into the vanished west

It is possible that the elves which traveled to Lindon did so to use the Elendil Stone. (an example of this are the elves Frodo and Sam meet in Fellowship of the Ring who are returning from Lindon led by Gildor)

However my question is: did Cirdan use this Palantir to communicate with the West and possibly pass messages along to the Wise? It seemed the Valar did play some part in the affairs of Middle-earth (sending Gandalf back, gusts of wind to aide Aragorn's ship etc.) and who better to communicate with than the literally ancient and wise elf that Cirdan is?

The Elendil stone of Emyn Beraid was-

maintained and guarded by Cirdan and the Elves of Lindon

This stone had 'special abilities' in which it was not in accord with the other palantiri. And that it could view the master stone kept in Tol Eressea in Valinor.

[it] looked back with straight sight into the vanished west

It is possible that the elves which traveled to Lindon did so to use the Elendil Stone. (an example of this are the elves Frodo and Sam meet in FOTR which are returning from Lindon led by Gildor)

However my question is did Cirdan use this Palantir to communicate with the west and possibly pass messages along to the Wise? It seemed the Valar did play some part in the affairs of middle earth (sending Gandalf back, gusts of wind to aide Aragorn's ship etc.) and who better to communicate with than the literally ancient and wise elf that Cirdan is

The Elendil stone of Emyn Beraid was-

maintained and guarded by Cirdan and the Elves of Lindon

This stone had 'special abilities' in which it was not in accord with the other palantiri. And that it could view the master stone kept in Tol Eressea in Valinor.

[it] looked back with straight sight into the vanished west

It is possible that the elves which traveled to Lindon did so to use the Elendil Stone. (an example of this are the elves Frodo and Sam meet in Fellowship of the Ring who are returning from Lindon led by Gildor)

However my question is: did Cirdan use this Palantir to communicate with the West and possibly pass messages along to the Wise? It seemed the Valar did play some part in the affairs of Mmiddle-earth (sending Gandalf back, gusts of wind to aide Aragorn's ship etc.) and who better to communicate with than the literally ancient and wise elf that Cirdan is?