We’re rewarding the question askers & reputations are being recalculated! Read more.
3 added 205 characters in body
source | link

During the climax of Pirates of the Carribbean: At World's End, Will and Elizabeth are married onboard The Black Pearl. The fact is Barbossa's first mutiny should have prevented him to be the "real" captain of the Pearl, but putting this aside I'm fairly sure that when Jack's right in the next ship fighting Jones, Barbossa couldn't be the offical captain of the Pearl. Therefore he shouldn't have the power to perform any marriage ceremony.

What I concluded from this is that their marriage may be in fact unofficial according to the maritime law, making that whole scene pointless. Even if they knew this, it would still disturb me that they consider Barbossa to be the real captain of the Pearl just because it serves them better at that moment. Either way this is one unnecessary plothole. Are they actually married?

Is it possible for them to get a consent from the Church considering they are pirates now. If not, with what we understand from movie's concept, can a captain marry a pirate couple on HIS ship?

During the climax of Pirates of the Carribbean: At World's End, Will and Elizabeth are married onboard The Black Pearl. The fact is Barbossa's first mutiny should have prevented him to be the "real" captain of the Pearl, but putting this aside I'm fairly sure that when Jack's right in the next ship fighting Jones, Barbossa couldn't be the offical captain of the Pearl. Therefore he shouldn't have the power to perform any marriage ceremony.

What I concluded from this is that their marriage may be in fact unofficial according to the maritime law, making that whole scene pointless. Even if they knew this, it would still disturb me that they consider Barbossa to be the real captain of the Pearl just because it serves them better at that moment. Either way this is one unnecessary plothole. Are they actually married?

During the climax of Pirates of the Carribbean: At World's End, Will and Elizabeth are married onboard The Black Pearl. The fact is Barbossa's first mutiny should have prevented him to be the "real" captain of the Pearl, but putting this aside I'm fairly sure that when Jack's right in the next ship fighting Jones, Barbossa couldn't be the offical captain of the Pearl. Therefore he shouldn't have the power to perform any marriage ceremony.

What I concluded from this is that their marriage may be in fact unofficial according to the maritime law, making that whole scene pointless. Even if they knew this, it would still disturb me that they consider Barbossa to be the real captain of the Pearl just because it serves them better at that moment. Either way this is one unnecessary plothole. Are they actually married?

Is it possible for them to get a consent from the Church considering they are pirates now. If not, with what we understand from movie's concept, can a captain marry a pirate couple on HIS ship?

2 Tidied up sentence structure, some grammar changes
source | link

In POTC At World's End Is Elizabeth and Will's Marriage Really Legitimatemarriage legitimate?

From what I can tell they gotDuring the climax of Pirates of the Carribbean: At World's End, Will and Elizabeth are married inonboard The Black Pearl. The fact thatis Barbossa's first mutiny should have prevented him to be the "real" captain of the pearl. ButPearl, but putting this aside, I'm fairly sure that when Jack's right in the next ship fighting Jones, Barbossa couldn't be the offical captain of the pearlPearl. SoTherefore he shouldn't have the power to perform any marriage ceremony. 

What I concluded from this is that their marriage may be in fact unofficial according to the maritime law. Therefore it makes, making that whole scene pointless. And evenEven if they knew this, it would still disturb me that they consider Barbossa to be the real captain of the pearlPearl just because it serves them better at that moment. Either way this is one unnecessary plothole. Do I miss anything?Are they actually married?

In POTC At World's End Is Elizabeth and Will's Marriage Really Legitimate?

From what I can tell they got married in The Black Pearl. The fact that Barbossa's first mutiny should have prevented him to be the "real" captain of the pearl. But putting this aside, I'm fairly sure that when Jack's right in the next ship fighting Jones, Barbossa couldn't be the offical captain of the pearl. So he shouldn't have the power to perform any marriage ceremony. What I concluded from this is that their marriage may be in fact unofficial according to the maritime law. Therefore it makes that whole scene pointless. And even if they knew this, it would still disturb me that they consider Barbossa to be the real captain of the pearl just because it serves them better at that moment. Either way this is one unnecessary plothole. Do I miss anything?

Is Elizabeth and Will's marriage legitimate?

During the climax of Pirates of the Carribbean: At World's End, Will and Elizabeth are married onboard The Black Pearl. The fact is Barbossa's first mutiny should have prevented him to be the "real" captain of the Pearl, but putting this aside I'm fairly sure that when Jack's right in the next ship fighting Jones, Barbossa couldn't be the offical captain of the Pearl. Therefore he shouldn't have the power to perform any marriage ceremony. 

What I concluded from this is that their marriage may be in fact unofficial according to the maritime law, making that whole scene pointless. Even if they knew this, it would still disturb me that they consider Barbossa to be the real captain of the Pearl just because it serves them better at that moment. Either way this is one unnecessary plothole. Are they actually married?

1
source | link

In POTC At World's End Is Elizabeth and Will's Marriage Really Legitimate?

From what I can tell they got married in The Black Pearl. The fact that Barbossa's first mutiny should have prevented him to be the "real" captain of the pearl. But putting this aside, I'm fairly sure that when Jack's right in the next ship fighting Jones, Barbossa couldn't be the offical captain of the pearl. So he shouldn't have the power to perform any marriage ceremony. What I concluded from this is that their marriage may be in fact unofficial according to the maritime law. Therefore it makes that whole scene pointless. And even if they knew this, it would still disturb me that they consider Barbossa to be the real captain of the pearl just because it serves them better at that moment. Either way this is one unnecessary plothole. Do I miss anything?