Skip to main content
switch to https
Source Link
DavidW
  • 142.6k
  • 34
  • 608
  • 750

Speculation

The Necromancer / Sauron

If we presume "Morgul" as the term used to be linked with Minas MorgulMinas Morgul, which thus implies a domain  / strongholdstronghold of Sauron, then we can look to early drafts of The Fellowship of the RingThe Fellowship of the Ring:

Gandalf calls the weapon that was used 'a deadly blade, the knife of the the Necromancer which remains in the wound', not a 'Morgul-knife'

The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1, Christopher Tolkien - p.211

-p.211

In a later draft:

The 'Morgul-knife' is still the 'knife of the Necromancer'

The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1, Christopher Tolkien - p.363

p.363

Thus - we can see that originally, Tolkien was associating the one named weapon in the text very directly with Sauron. He later changed it of course to 'Morgul-knife' but again, given the association of Minas Morgul and Sauron, it isn't unreasonable to presume then that Sauron or someone quite close to him constructed their weapons.

Source: The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1 - Christopher Tolkien

Speculation

The Necromancer / Sauron

If we presume "Morgul" as the term used to be linked with Minas Morgul, which thus implies a domain  / stronghold of Sauron, then we can look to early drafts of The Fellowship of the Ring:

Gandalf calls the weapon that was used 'a deadly blade, the knife of the Necromancer which remains in the wound', not a 'Morgul-knife'

-p.211

In a later draft:

The 'Morgul-knife' is still the 'knife of the Necromancer'

p.363

Thus - we can see that originally, Tolkien was associating the one named weapon in the text very directly with Sauron. He later changed it of course to 'Morgul-knife' but again, given the association of Minas Morgul and Sauron, it isn't unreasonable to presume then that Sauron or someone quite close to him constructed their weapons.

Source: The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1 - Christopher Tolkien

Speculation

The Necromancer / Sauron

If we presume "Morgul" as the term used to be linked with Minas Morgul, which thus implies a domain/stronghold of Sauron, then we can look to early drafts of The Fellowship of the Ring:

Gandalf calls the weapon that was used 'a deadly blade, the knife of the Necromancer which remains in the wound', not a 'Morgul-knife'

The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1, Christopher Tolkien - p.211

In a later draft:

The 'Morgul-knife' is still the 'knife of the Necromancer'

The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1, Christopher Tolkien - p.363

Thus - we can see that originally, Tolkien was associating the one named weapon in the text very directly with Sauron. He later changed it of course to 'Morgul-knife' but again, given the association of Minas Morgul and Sauron, it isn't unreasonable to presume then that Sauron or someone quite close to him constructed their weapons.

Commonmark migration
Source Link

###Speculation

Speculation

#The Necromancer / Sauron

The Necromancer / Sauron

If we presume "Morgul" as the term used to be linked with Minas Morgul, which thus implies a domain / stronghold of Sauron, then we can look to early drafts of The Fellowship of the Ring:

Gandalf calls the weapon that was used 'a deadly blade, the knife of the Necromancer which remains in the wound', not a 'Morgul-knife'

-p.211

In a later draft:

The 'Morgul-knife' is still the 'knife of the Necromancer'

p.363

Thus - we can see that originally, Tolkien was associating the one named weapon in the text very directly with Sauron. He later changed it of course to 'Morgul-knife' but again, given the association of Minas Morgul and Sauron, it isn't unreasonable to presume then that Sauron or someone quite close to him constructed their weapons.

Source: The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1 - Christopher Tolkien

###Speculation

#The Necromancer / Sauron

If we presume "Morgul" as the term used to be linked with Minas Morgul, which thus implies a domain / stronghold of Sauron, then we can look to early drafts of The Fellowship of the Ring:

Gandalf calls the weapon that was used 'a deadly blade, the knife of the Necromancer which remains in the wound', not a 'Morgul-knife'

-p.211

In a later draft:

The 'Morgul-knife' is still the 'knife of the Necromancer'

p.363

Thus - we can see that originally, Tolkien was associating the one named weapon in the text very directly with Sauron. He later changed it of course to 'Morgul-knife' but again, given the association of Minas Morgul and Sauron, it isn't unreasonable to presume then that Sauron or someone quite close to him constructed their weapons.

Source: The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1 - Christopher Tolkien

Speculation

The Necromancer / Sauron

If we presume "Morgul" as the term used to be linked with Minas Morgul, which thus implies a domain / stronghold of Sauron, then we can look to early drafts of The Fellowship of the Ring:

Gandalf calls the weapon that was used 'a deadly blade, the knife of the Necromancer which remains in the wound', not a 'Morgul-knife'

-p.211

In a later draft:

The 'Morgul-knife' is still the 'knife of the Necromancer'

p.363

Thus - we can see that originally, Tolkien was associating the one named weapon in the text very directly with Sauron. He later changed it of course to 'Morgul-knife' but again, given the association of Minas Morgul and Sauron, it isn't unreasonable to presume then that Sauron or someone quite close to him constructed their weapons.

Source: The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1 - Christopher Tolkien

Source Link
NKCampbell
  • 40.2k
  • 13
  • 150
  • 205

###Speculation

#The Necromancer / Sauron

If we presume "Morgul" as the term used to be linked with Minas Morgul, which thus implies a domain / stronghold of Sauron, then we can look to early drafts of The Fellowship of the Ring:

Gandalf calls the weapon that was used 'a deadly blade, the knife of the Necromancer which remains in the wound', not a 'Morgul-knife'

-p.211

In a later draft:

The 'Morgul-knife' is still the 'knife of the Necromancer'

p.363

Thus - we can see that originally, Tolkien was associating the one named weapon in the text very directly with Sauron. He later changed it of course to 'Morgul-knife' but again, given the association of Minas Morgul and Sauron, it isn't unreasonable to presume then that Sauron or someone quite close to him constructed their weapons.

Source: The Return of the Shadow: The History of the Lord of the Rings, Pt1 - Christopher Tolkien