Skip to main content
added 2 characters in body
Source Link
TheLethalCarrot
  • 144.3k
  • 65
  • 813
  • 880

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the muggleMuggle vs magical realms.

In Harry PotterHarry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggleMuggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to mugglesMuggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency - it appears to exist in the real world, despite open displays of magic, including the family "clock" device showing the location of various family members, and the dishes washing themselves, and even the improbable structure itself - it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. It ought to be in the magical realm, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and muggleMuggle realms when arriving or leaving.

In which realm (magical or muggleMuggle) does the Burrow exist? How is this apparent inconsistency resolved?

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the muggle vs magical realms.

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency - it appears to exist in the real world, despite open displays of magic, including the family "clock" device showing the location of various family members, and the dishes washing themselves, and even the improbable structure itself - it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. It ought to be in the magical realm, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and muggle realms when arriving or leaving.

In which realm (magical or muggle) does the Burrow exist? How is this apparent inconsistency resolved?

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the Muggle vs magical realms.

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday Muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to Muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency - it appears to exist in the real world, despite open displays of magic, including the family "clock" device showing the location of various family members, and the dishes washing themselves, and even the improbable structure itself - it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. It ought to be in the magical realm, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and Muggle realms when arriving or leaving.

In which realm (magical or Muggle) does the Burrow exist? How is this apparent inconsistency resolved?

Post Reopened by Valorum, DavidW, HorusKol, Matt, Alex
deleted 374 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Anthony X
  • 12k
  • 5
  • 45
  • 82

Is the Weasley's residence "the Burrow" in the magical or non-magical realm? What about the Hogwarts Express?

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the muggle vs magical realms.

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency - it appears to exist in the real world, despite open displays of magic, including the family "clock" device showing the location of various family members, and the dishes washing themselves, and even the improbable structure itself - it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. It ought to be in the magical realm, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and muggle realms when arriving or leaving.

Likewise, the Hogwarts Express line seems inconsistent - platform 9-3/4 is clearly hidden from muggles, but when Harry and Ron take the car (in the muggle world) to catch up to the train, they make no explicit crossing into a magical realm, suggesting that the train is traveling the muggle world despite its departure from a magical platform.

In which realm (magical or muggle) dodoes the Burrow and the Hogwarts Express exist? How are theseis this apparent inconsistenciesinconsistency resolved?

Is the Weasley's residence "the Burrow" in the magical or non-magical realm? What about the Hogwarts Express?

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the muggle vs magical realms.

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency - it appears to exist in the real world, despite open displays of magic, including the family "clock" device showing the location of various family members, and the dishes washing themselves, and even the improbable structure itself - it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. It ought to be in the magical realm, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and muggle realms when arriving or leaving.

Likewise, the Hogwarts Express line seems inconsistent - platform 9-3/4 is clearly hidden from muggles, but when Harry and Ron take the car (in the muggle world) to catch up to the train, they make no explicit crossing into a magical realm, suggesting that the train is traveling the muggle world despite its departure from a magical platform.

In which realm (magical or muggle) do the Burrow and the Hogwarts Express exist? How are these apparent inconsistencies resolved?

Is the Weasley's residence "the Burrow" in the magical or non-magical realm?

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the muggle vs magical realms.

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency - it appears to exist in the real world, despite open displays of magic, including the family "clock" device showing the location of various family members, and the dishes washing themselves, and even the improbable structure itself - it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. It ought to be in the magical realm, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and muggle realms when arriving or leaving.

In which realm (magical or muggle) does the Burrow exist? How is this apparent inconsistency resolved?

added 373 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Anthony X
  • 12k
  • 5
  • 45
  • 82

Magical and Is the Weasley's residence "the Burrow" in the magical or non-magical realms,realm? What about the Burrow, Hogwarts and Hogwarts Express?

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the muggle vs magical realms.

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency (Weasley family residence, first seen in Chamber of Secrets)- it appears (on screen at least) to be a rather improbable structureexist in the real world, filled with magical artifacts (such asdespite open displays of magic, including the family member "clock"). It seems to belong in device showing the magical realmlocation of various family members, yet Harry first encounters Ron onand the muggle platformdishes washing themselves, having to traverse the portal toand even the hidden platform 9improbable structure itself -3/4 it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. Is the BurrowIt ought to be in the magical realm or the, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and muggle realm?realms when arriving or leaving.

Similarly:Likewise, the Hogwarts Express line seems inconsistent - platform 9-3/4 is in the magical realmclearly hidden from muggles, but in Chamber of Secrets, Ron andwhen Harry flyand Ron take the car (in the muggle realmworld) from King's Cross station to catch up withto the train, without explicitlythey make no explicit crossing out ofinto a magical realm, suggesting that the train is traveling the muggle world despite its departure from a magical platform. Does that place the Hogwarts Express line

In which realm (and/or train) in the magicalmagical or muggle world) do the Burrow and the Hogwarts Express exist? How are these apparent inconsistencies resolved?

Magical and non-magical realms, the Burrow, Hogwarts and Hogwarts Express

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow (Weasley family residence, first seen in Chamber of Secrets) appears (on screen at least) to be a rather improbable structure, filled with magical artifacts (such as the family member "clock"). It seems to belong in the magical realm, yet Harry first encounters Ron on the muggle platform, having to traverse the portal to the hidden platform 9-3/4. Is the Burrow in the magical realm or the muggle realm?

Similarly: platform 9-3/4 is in the magical realm, but in Chamber of Secrets, Ron and Harry fly the car (in the muggle realm) from King's Cross station to catch up with the train, without explicitly crossing out of the muggle world. Does that place the Hogwarts Express line (and/or train) in the magical or muggle world?

Is the Weasley's residence "the Burrow" in the magical or non-magical realm? What about the Hogwarts Express?

Based solely on what appears in the Harry Potter movies, there appear to be inconsistencies with the existence of some things in the muggle vs magical realms.

In Harry Potter, there are clearly magical realms overlaid on the everyday muggle world, which are invisible/inaccessible to muggles, at least without magical intervention. Among them, I believe are:

  • Diagon Alley
  • Platform 9-3/4
  • Hogwarts Castle
  • The Black family residence at Grimmauld Place
  • The Ministry of Magic

The Burrow seems to be an inconsistency - it appears to exist in the real world, despite open displays of magic, including the family "clock" device showing the location of various family members, and the dishes washing themselves, and even the improbable structure itself - it seems to need magic just to hold itself up. It ought to be in the magical realm, but there is never any indication that anyone crosses between magical and muggle realms when arriving or leaving.

Likewise, the Hogwarts Express line seems inconsistent - platform 9-3/4 is clearly hidden from muggles, but when Harry and Ron take the car (in the muggle world) to catch up to the train, they make no explicit crossing into a magical realm, suggesting that the train is traveling the muggle world despite its departure from a magical platform.

In which realm (magical or muggle) do the Burrow and the Hogwarts Express exist? How are these apparent inconsistencies resolved?

Post Closed as "Needs details or clarity" by Valorum, Stormblessed, TheLethalCarrot, DavidW, user112267
Source Link
Anthony X
  • 12k
  • 5
  • 45
  • 82
Loading