Skip to main content
Tweak
Source Link
John Rennie
  • 117k
  • 7
  • 494
  • 577

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

Footnote: Mithoron points out that in the story A Question of Price Ciri's mother Pavetta shows a power very like this when her lover Duny/Urcheon/Emhyr is attacked. It seems very likely that the NetFlix adaptation has bent the plot a bit and given Ciri the same power for dramatic effect.

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

Footnote: Mithoron points out that in the story A Question of Price Ciri's mother Pavetta shows a power very like this when her lover Duny/Urcheon/Emhyr is attacked. It seems very likely that the NetFlix adaptation has bent the plot a bit and given Ciri the same power for dramatic effect.

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

Tweeted twitter.com/StackSciFi/status/1211074522360811525
Tweak
Source Link
John Rennie
  • 117k
  • 7
  • 494
  • 577

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

Footnote: Mithoron points out that in the story A Question of Price Ciri's mother Pavetta shows a power very like this when her lover Duny/Urcheon/Emhyr is attacked. It seems very likely that the NetFlix adaptation has bent the plot a bit and given Ciri the same power for dramatic effect.

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

Footnote: Mithoron points out that in the story A Question of Price Ciri's mother Pavetta shows a power very like this when her lover Duny/Urcheon/Emhyr is attacked. It seems very likely that the NetFlix adaptation has bent the plot a bit and given Ciri the same power for dramatic effect.

Tweak
Source Link
John Rennie
  • 117k
  • 7
  • 494
  • 577

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

I've just watched the first episode of the NetFlix Witcher adaptation, and very good it is too though there was one plot device I'm unsure about.

In the adaptation, as in the books, Ciri is abducted by Cahir at the fall of Cintra. However in the adaptation she:

escapes by using a magical scream to stun him. An earlier scene shows her rattling glasses by screaming.

In the game Witcher 3 there is one scene where she shows a similar power. It's at the siege of Kaer Morhen where she uses it against Eredin. However I don't recall any such power in the books. So my question is whether there is anywhere in the books that she uses a power like this.

Source Link
John Rennie
  • 117k
  • 7
  • 494
  • 577
Loading