Skip to main content

There are two likely explanations that would allow you to avoid considering this a "timeline error".

  1. Luke's training took a lot less time than it may be assumed. Either due to Luke's innate abilities (midichlorian count? :) ) or the fact that Force training to a certain level is a kind of phase shift event - you gain a certain level of control (Which can take any amount fof time from 1 day to 10 years) and you obrainobtain a set of skills/abilities, the rest of "Jedi Training" time is merely honing those.

  2. Travel to Cloud City took a lot longer than to Dagobah. Yeah, Milleniumthe Millennium Falcon is a fast ship, but the galaxy is pretty big AND Han was trying to avoid the Imperials, so may have had to take a somewhat roundabout route.

    P.S. Please note that the extended universe (especially the Bounty Hunter related books) might offer a fairly decent amount of detail to help establish the timeline.

Though, if you ask me to put my money on a specific answer, "timeline error" would be my bet. Remember - Lucas was making a space opera, NOT hard sci-fi.

There are two likely explanations that would allow you to avoid considering this a "timeline error".

  1. Luke's training took a lot less time than it may be assumed. Either due to Luke's innate abilities (midichlorian count? :) ) or the fact that Force training to a certain level is a kind of phase shift event - you gain a certain level of control (Which can take any amount f time from 1 day to 10 years) and you obrain a set of skills/abilities, the rest of "Jedi Training" time is merely honing those.

  2. Travel to Cloud City took a lot longer than to Dagobah. Yeah, Millenium Falcon is a fast ship, but the galaxy is pretty big AND Han was trying to avoid the Imperials, so may have had to take a somewhat roundabout route.

    P.S. Please note that the extended universe (especially the Bounty Hunter related books) might offer a fairly decent amount of detail to help establish the timeline.

Though, if you ask me to put my money on a specific answer, "timeline error" would be my bet. Remember - Lucas was making a space opera, NOT hard sci-fi.

There are two likely explanations that would allow you to avoid considering this a "timeline error".

  1. Luke's training took a lot less time than it may be assumed. Either due to Luke's innate abilities (midichlorian count? :) ) or the fact that Force training to a certain level is a kind of phase shift event - you gain a certain level of control (Which can take any amount of time from 1 day to 10 years) and you obtain a set of skills/abilities, the rest of "Jedi Training" time is merely honing those.

  2. Travel to Cloud City took a lot longer than to Dagobah. Yeah, the Millennium Falcon is a fast ship, but the galaxy is pretty big AND Han was trying to avoid the Imperials, so may have had to take a somewhat roundabout route.

    P.S. Please note that the extended universe (especially the Bounty Hunter related books) might offer a fairly decent amount of detail to help establish the timeline.

Though, if you ask me to put my money on a specific answer, "timeline error" would be my bet. Remember - Lucas was making a space opera, NOT hard sci-fi.

added 172 characters in body
Source Link
DVK-on-Ahch-To
  • 344.1k
  • 162
  • 1.5k
  • 2.1k

There are two likely explanations that would allow you to avoid considering this a "timeline error".

  1. Luke's training took a lot less time than it may be assumed. Either due to Luke's innate abilities (midichlorian count? :) ) or the fact that Force training to a certain level is a kind of phase shift event - you gain a certain level of control (Which can take any amount f time from 1 day to 10 years) and you obrain a set of skills/abilities, the rest of "Jedi Training" time is merely honing those.

  2. Travel to Cloud City took a lot longer than to Dagobah. Yeah, Millenium Falcon is a fast ship, but the galaxy is pretty big AND Han was trying to avoid the Imperials, so may have had to take a somewhat roundabout route.

    P.S. Please note that the extended universe (especially the Bounty Hunter related books) might offer a fairly decent amount of detail to help establish the timeline.

Though, if you ask me to put my money on a specific answer, "timeline error" would be my bet. Remember - Lucas was making a space opera, NOT hard sci-fi.

There are two likely explanations that would allow you to avoid considering this a "timeline error".

  1. Luke's training took a lot less time than it may be assumed. Either due to Luke's innate abilities (midichlorian count? :) ) or the fact that Force training to a certain level is a kind of phase shift event - you gain a certain level of control (Which can take any amount f time from 1 day to 10 years) and you obrain a set of skills/abilities, the rest of "Jedi Training" time is merely honing those.

  2. Travel to Cloud City took a lot longer than to Dagobah. Yeah, Millenium Falcon is a fast ship, but the galaxy is pretty big AND Han was trying to avoid the Imperials, so may have had to take a somewhat roundabout route.

Though, if you ask me to put my money on a specific answer, "timeline error" would be my bet. Remember - Lucas was making a space opera, NOT hard sci-fi.

There are two likely explanations that would allow you to avoid considering this a "timeline error".

  1. Luke's training took a lot less time than it may be assumed. Either due to Luke's innate abilities (midichlorian count? :) ) or the fact that Force training to a certain level is a kind of phase shift event - you gain a certain level of control (Which can take any amount f time from 1 day to 10 years) and you obrain a set of skills/abilities, the rest of "Jedi Training" time is merely honing those.

  2. Travel to Cloud City took a lot longer than to Dagobah. Yeah, Millenium Falcon is a fast ship, but the galaxy is pretty big AND Han was trying to avoid the Imperials, so may have had to take a somewhat roundabout route.

    P.S. Please note that the extended universe (especially the Bounty Hunter related books) might offer a fairly decent amount of detail to help establish the timeline.

Though, if you ask me to put my money on a specific answer, "timeline error" would be my bet. Remember - Lucas was making a space opera, NOT hard sci-fi.

Source Link
DVK-on-Ahch-To
  • 344.1k
  • 162
  • 1.5k
  • 2.1k

There are two likely explanations that would allow you to avoid considering this a "timeline error".

  1. Luke's training took a lot less time than it may be assumed. Either due to Luke's innate abilities (midichlorian count? :) ) or the fact that Force training to a certain level is a kind of phase shift event - you gain a certain level of control (Which can take any amount f time from 1 day to 10 years) and you obrain a set of skills/abilities, the rest of "Jedi Training" time is merely honing those.

  2. Travel to Cloud City took a lot longer than to Dagobah. Yeah, Millenium Falcon is a fast ship, but the galaxy is pretty big AND Han was trying to avoid the Imperials, so may have had to take a somewhat roundabout route.

Though, if you ask me to put my money on a specific answer, "timeline error" would be my bet. Remember - Lucas was making a space opera, NOT hard sci-fi.