Skip to main content
edited title
Link
The Dark Lord
  • 62.1k
  • 39
  • 277
  • 395

Why couldn't Harry summon withuse Accio on the Golden Egg in Goblet of Fire?

Tidying up.
Source Link
The Dark Lord
  • 62.1k
  • 39
  • 277
  • 395

Why couldn't Harry do an "accio" onsummon with Accio the Golden Egg in GoFGoblet of Fire?

In GoFGoblet of Fire, when Harry Potter is faced with a dragon, he used "accio"'Accio' to get his broomstick and then grabbed the golden eggGolden Egg after some flying. My question is that, why couldn't he do an "accio"use 'Accio' on the Golden Egg itself? Is there a rule that the thing he was calling had to belong to him?

For that matter, why couldn't any other champion do this onto the Golden eggEgg? Well, we can make a case for others that theythe others just wouldn't have thought of it but Harry Potter came herethere with the intention of doing this soa Summoning Charm. Surely he must surely havecould've done the simpler thing and called the golden eggGolden Egg itself instead of the broomstick.

BTWBy the way, the book says that the egg was under the dragon's body butbut the movie shows it placed at a prominent location fairlya fair distance away from the dragon and from Harry. So, letslet's talk about book only. Was there a rule that he couldn't summon the egg since it was kind of strangled under the dragon's body?

Why couldn't Harry do an "accio" on Golden Egg in GoF

In GoF, when Harry Potter is faced with a dragon, he used "accio" to get his broomstick and then grabbed the golden egg after some flying. My question is that why couldn't he do an "accio" on the Golden Egg itself? Is there a rule that the thing he was calling had to belong to him?

For that matter, why couldn't any other champion do this on Golden egg? Well, we can make a case for others that they just wouldn't have thought of it but Harry Potter came here with the intention of doing this so he must surely have done the simpler thing and called the golden egg itself instead of the broomstick.

BTW, the book says that the egg was under the dragon's body but the movie shows it placed at a prominent location fairly away from dragon and Harry. So, lets talk about book only. Was there a rule that he couldn't summon the egg since it was kind of strangled under the dragon's body?

Why couldn't Harry summon with Accio the Golden Egg in Goblet of Fire?

In Goblet of Fire, when Harry Potter is faced with a dragon, he used 'Accio' to get his broomstick and then grabbed the Golden Egg after some flying. My question is, why couldn't he use 'Accio' on the Golden Egg itself? Is there a rule that the thing he was calling had to belong to him?

For that matter, why couldn't any other champion do this to the Golden Egg? Well, we can make a case that the others just wouldn't have thought of it but Harry Potter came there with the intention of doing a Summoning Charm. Surely he could've done the simpler thing and called the Golden Egg itself instead of the broomstick.

By the way, the book says that the egg was under the dragon's body but the movie shows it placed at a prominent location a fair distance away from the dragon and from Harry. So, let's talk about book only. Was there a rule that he couldn't summon the egg since it was kind of strangled under the dragon's body?

Tweeted twitter.com/#!/StackSciFi/status/336589719192350720
Source Link
Aamir
  • 283
  • 1
  • 2
  • 6

Why couldn't Harry do an "accio" on Golden Egg in GoF

In GoF, when Harry Potter is faced with a dragon, he used "accio" to get his broomstick and then grabbed the golden egg after some flying. My question is that why couldn't he do an "accio" on the Golden Egg itself? Is there a rule that the thing he was calling had to belong to him?

For that matter, why couldn't any other champion do this on Golden egg? Well, we can make a case for others that they just wouldn't have thought of it but Harry Potter came here with the intention of doing this so he must surely have done the simpler thing and called the golden egg itself instead of the broomstick.

BTW, the book says that the egg was under the dragon's body but the movie shows it placed at a prominent location fairly away from dragon and Harry. So, lets talk about book only. Was there a rule that he couldn't summon the egg since it was kind of strangled under the dragon's body?