Skip to main content
added 42 characters in body
Source Link
Valorum
  • 717.9k
  • 163
  • 4.8k
  • 5k

This is dealt with in the script.

Ash is the ship's Science Officer (and medical officerMedical Officer pro tem). Although the other crew express concern towards Kanetheir fallen comrade, none of them actively dispute histhat Ash has the right to make decisions regarding hisKane's health and well-being. This point is repeatedly made in the scenes before his deathKane dies.

DALLAS : (to Ash) You're the science officer. It's your decision.

and

RIPLEY : How could you leave that kind of decision to him?

DALLAS : I just run the ship. Anything that has to do with science division, Ash has the final word.

 

The novelisation makes it clear that the cryotube doesn't create a perfect stasis (a la Star Trek) but functions as a suspended animation device, slowing the user's vital signs but not stopping them. Entering in an unwell state might delay your death but it certainly wouldn't stop it.

Ash claims that Kane needs immediate medical attention and then (once he's stabilised) presumably they'll consider placing him back into stasis with the rest of the crew for the return journey to Earth. Obviously the reality is that Ash is a damned liar but we don't find that out until later...

ASH : Running a fever. And still unconscious. The machine will bring his temperature down. His vital functions are strong ... who knows, he may make it.

This is dealt with in the script.

Ash is the ship's Science Officer (and medical officer pro tem). Although the other crew express concern towards Kane, none of them actively dispute his right to make decisions regarding his health and well-being. This point is repeatedly made in the scenes before his death.

DALLAS : (to Ash) You're the science officer. It's your decision.

and

RIPLEY : How could you leave that kind of decision to him?

DALLAS : I just run the ship. Anything that has to do with science division, Ash has the final word.

The novelisation makes it clear that the cryotube doesn't create a perfect stasis (a la Star Trek) but functions as a suspended animation device, slowing the user's vital signs but not stopping them. Entering in an unwell state might delay your death but it certainly wouldn't stop it.

Ash claims that Kane needs immediate medical attention and then (once he's stabilised) presumably they'll consider placing him back into stasis with the rest of the crew for the return journey to Earth. Obviously the reality is that Ash is a damned liar but we don't find that out until later...

ASH : Running a fever. And still unconscious. The machine will bring his temperature down. His vital functions are strong ... who knows, he may make it.

This is dealt with in the script.

Ash is the ship's Science Officer (and Medical Officer pro tem). Although the other crew express concern towards their fallen comrade, none of them actively dispute that Ash has the right to make decisions regarding Kane's health and well-being. This point is repeatedly made in the scenes before Kane dies.

DALLAS : (to Ash) You're the science officer. It's your decision.

and

RIPLEY : How could you leave that kind of decision to him?

DALLAS : I just run the ship. Anything that has to do with science division, Ash has the final word.

 

The novelisation makes it clear that the cryotube doesn't create a perfect stasis (a la Star Trek) but functions as a suspended animation device, slowing the user's vital signs but not stopping them. Entering in an unwell state might delay your death but it certainly wouldn't stop it.

Ash claims that Kane needs immediate medical attention and then (once he's stabilised) presumably they'll consider placing him back into stasis with the rest of the crew for the return journey to Earth. Obviously the reality is that Ash is a damned liar but we don't find that out until later...

ASH : Running a fever. And still unconscious. The machine will bring his temperature down. His vital functions are strong ... who knows, he may make it.

added 796 characters in body
Source Link
Valorum
  • 717.9k
  • 163
  • 4.8k
  • 5k

This is dealt with in the scriptscript.

Ash is the scienceship's Science Officer (and medical officer and the althoughpro tem). Although the other crew members disagree with his decisions regardingexpress concern towards Kane, none of them actively rebel againstdispute his right to make those decisiondecisions regarding his health and well-being. This point is repeatedly made in the scenes before his death.

DALLAS : (to Ash) You're the science officer. It's your decision.

and

RIPLEY : How could you leave that kind of decision to him?

DALLAS : I just run the ship. Anything that has to do with science division, Ash has the final word.

The novelisation makes it clear that the cryotube doesn't create a perfect stasis (a la Star Trek) but functions as a suspended animation device, slowing the user's vital signs but not stopping them. Entering in an unwell state might delay your death but it certainly wouldn't stop it.

Ash claims that Kane needs immediate medical attention and then (once he's stabilised) presumably they'll consider placing him back into stasis with the rest of the crew for the return journey to Earth. Obviously the reality is that Ash is a damned liar but we don't find that out until later...

ASH : Running a fever. And still unconscious. The machine will bring his temperature down. His vital functions are strong ... who knows, he may make it.

This is dealt with in the script.

Ash is the science officer and the although the other crew members disagree with his decisions regarding Kane, none of them actively rebel against his right to make those decision.

DALLAS : You're the science officer. It's your decision.

and

RIPLEY : How could you leave that kind of decision to him?

DALLAS : I just run the ship. Anything that has to do with science division, Ash has the final word.

This is dealt with in the script.

Ash is the ship's Science Officer (and medical officer pro tem). Although the other crew express concern towards Kane, none of them actively dispute his right to make decisions regarding his health and well-being. This point is repeatedly made in the scenes before his death.

DALLAS : (to Ash) You're the science officer. It's your decision.

and

RIPLEY : How could you leave that kind of decision to him?

DALLAS : I just run the ship. Anything that has to do with science division, Ash has the final word.

The novelisation makes it clear that the cryotube doesn't create a perfect stasis (a la Star Trek) but functions as a suspended animation device, slowing the user's vital signs but not stopping them. Entering in an unwell state might delay your death but it certainly wouldn't stop it.

Ash claims that Kane needs immediate medical attention and then (once he's stabilised) presumably they'll consider placing him back into stasis with the rest of the crew for the return journey to Earth. Obviously the reality is that Ash is a damned liar but we don't find that out until later...

ASH : Running a fever. And still unconscious. The machine will bring his temperature down. His vital functions are strong ... who knows, he may make it.

Source Link
Valorum
  • 717.9k
  • 163
  • 4.8k
  • 5k

This is dealt with in the script.

Ash is the science officer and the although the other crew members disagree with his decisions regarding Kane, none of them actively rebel against his right to make those decision.

DALLAS : You're the science officer. It's your decision.

and

RIPLEY : How could you leave that kind of decision to him?

DALLAS : I just run the ship. Anything that has to do with science division, Ash has the final word.