Skip to main content
Latin is a dead language.
Source Link
Kyle Jones
  • 54.1k
  • 14
  • 175
  • 260

Your basic premise is not valid; replicants do feel pain.

Near the end of the film Roy Batty was trying to stave off his impending death. He pushed nails through his palm to provide a strong stimulus; Batty was visibly in agony while doing this. As another example, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard's gunfire were evidence that she experienced pain.

In humans and their meatspace analogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergotherefore there was pain.

Your basic premise is not valid; replicants do feel pain.

Near the end of the film Roy Batty was trying to stave off his impending death. He pushed nails through his palm to provide a strong stimulus; Batty was visibly in agony while doing this. As another example, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard's gunfire were evidence that she experienced pain.

In humans and their meatspace analogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergo there was pain.

Your basic premise is not valid; replicants do feel pain.

Near the end of the film Roy Batty was trying to stave off his impending death. He pushed nails through his palm to provide a strong stimulus; Batty was visibly in agony while doing this. As another example, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard's gunfire were evidence that she experienced pain.

In humans and their meatspace analogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, therefore there was pain.

another example of replicant pain
Source Link
Kyle Jones
  • 54.1k
  • 14
  • 175
  • 260

Your basic premise is not valid; replicants do feel pain.

Near the end of the film Roy Batty was trying to stave off his impending death. He pushed nails through his palm to provide a strong stimulus; Batty was visibly in agony while doing this. As another example, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard's gunfire were evidence that she experienced pain.

In humans and their meatspace analogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergo there was pain.

Also, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard are strong evidence that replicants do feel pain, so I think your founding premise is not valid.

In humans and their meatspace analogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergo there was pain.

Also, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard are strong evidence that replicants do feel pain, so I think your founding premise is not valid.

Your basic premise is not valid; replicants do feel pain.

Near the end of the film Roy Batty was trying to stave off his impending death. He pushed nails through his palm to provide a strong stimulus; Batty was visibly in agony while doing this. As another example, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard's gunfire were evidence that she experienced pain.

In humans and their meatspace analogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergo there was pain.

added 1 character in body
Source Link
Kyle Jones
  • 54.1k
  • 14
  • 175
  • 260

In humans and their meatspace analogsanalogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Batty's Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergo there was pain.

Also, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard are strong evidence that replicants do feel pain, so I think your founding premise is not valid.

In humans and their meatspace analogs pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Batty's hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergo there was pain.

Also, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard are strong evidence that replicants do feel pain, so I think your founding premise is not valid.

In humans and their meatspace analogues, pain response is a symptom of damage in normal situations. So if a replicant's skin is durable enough to not be horribly burned by a plunge into boiling water then there should likewise be no pain response. Pris' hand looked undamaged by the hot water. By contrast, Deckard's fingers were broken or at least dislocated with badly torn ligaments. There was damage, ergo there was pain.

Also, Pris' heel-drumming and demented screaming when wounded by Deckard are strong evidence that replicants do feel pain, so I think your founding premise is not valid.

Source Link
Kyle Jones
  • 54.1k
  • 14
  • 175
  • 260
Loading