6

Is there an exact height given in Tolkien's work that reveals the height of the Trees or is just that they lit up Valinor and were treasured by the Elves?.

  • They only lit up Valinor. Everywhere else remained dark. – Shamshiel Nov 15 '15 at 13:46
  • @Shamshiel That's not what the asker meant. Better phrased, he means "Did Tolkien reveal the exact height of the trees in his work or is all that is mentioned simply that the Trees lit up Valinor and were treasured by the Elves?" – thegreatjedi Nov 15 '15 at 14:23
  • If I had to guess I would say probably as tall as the Twin Towers. – user35326 Nov 17 '15 at 16:25
7

For this particular question, there sadly doesn't exist an answer in any canon work, as far as I have found. There are plenty of illustrations by several artists that show the trees in varying heights and although they are always shown as taller than the surrounding trees, no exact height is ever given. A couple of examples of what the tree heights might be:

enter image description here

enter image description here

Although we don't know for sure as it has never been explained by Tolkien himself. You can attempt to apply math and physics to it: if you know the total square mile area of Valinor, you could attempt to calculate out how tall the trees would have to be to illuminate the entire land mass without blinding those standing too close to them. Although, in all likelihood, the light from the two trees was magical in nature and wouldn't have been affected by real-world physics or mathematics. Tolkien was a skilled myth-writer, not a hard-SF writer. Many specific details are left out of his works, so we are left to guess on some matters.

To summarize: no, Tolkien never revealed the exact height of the trees in his work. It was only ever mentioned that the trees lit up all of Valinor (with some other minor details not related to the stated question).

3

As the Book of Lost Tales puts it, they were trees "of mighty stature, and all the Valar and their folk might sit beneath their branches.

And from reading Tolkien's works, I believe that the Valar were very tall in their physical shape.

If anything, I'd imagine those trees being probably taller than the sequoias.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.