While it's well-known that Arthur C. Clarke developed the idea of geostationary satellites, it seems far less known that another SciFi author, Jerry Pournelle, developed the idea of kinetic orbital bombardment with metal rods (during his side career as engineer at Boeing):

Project Thor is an idea for a weapons system that launches kinetic projectiles from Earth's orbit to damage targets on the ground. Jerry Pournelle originated the concept while working in operations research at Boeing in the 1950s before becoming a science-fiction writer.

It would make sense if Pournelle (being a SciFi writer) would be the first to use the idea in a SciFi work. But was that really the case?

Wikipedia doesn't seem to offer much clarity (nor certainness) - while all the examples it lists which predate Pournelle's don't fit ("The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress bombardment is Moon based, not from orbit; Lensman series used planetary sized masses instead of small objects). As a matter of fact, Pournelle's own "Footfall" seems to not quite fit the bill, since from what I recall, Fithp don't use artificial objects but instead, meteors.

The first example I saw on Wikipedia that fit 100% and was dated was from 1988:

A smaller "crowbar" variant is mentioned in David's Sling by Marc Stiegler (Baen, 1988)

Question: What was the first instance of SciFi work using the actual Pournelle system? (Specific specs: artificial objects - preferable metal rods - used or deployed as orbital kinetic weapons from Earth Orbit)

  • 1
    Pournelle's idea also has a problem insofar the weapon have to balance energetics against the ability to use on-board sensors for terminal guidance. Come in too fast and the reentry heat screws your guidance. Come in too slow and they lose a huge fraction of their effectiveness. They are also slower and more expensive to deploy than is immediately obvious (unless of course, you are very comfortable with orbital mechanics). – dmckee Nov 29 '15 at 4:23
  • I would not be surprised to hear that Tesla considered this. Given his abstractions for military force, his submarine work, and his work on "death rays" - I would think think this his era of idea, before he was killed. – EngrStudent Dec 2 '15 at 4:48
  • In Niven and Pournelle's novel Footfall they mention "Project Thor" by name, and explaining that the aliens are attacking with "flying crowbars." The only meteor they use is the asteroid they drop on India. – Winchell Chung Feb 24 '16 at 19:05
  • The Moon is in orbit around Earth, so what exactly is the distinction you're drawing between Moon-based and "from orbit"? – Peter Taylor Apr 4 '16 at 22:17
  • Does it have to be a kinetic weapon? Or can it be an actual weapon from a space platform that specifically addresses the gravity well? – JohnP Apr 6 '18 at 15:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.