18

There's a few parts to this question. When the Sorting Hat was on Harry Potter, it picked up the part of Voldemort's soul and suggested Harry would do well in Slytherin, but went with Harry's interest in Gryffindor instead. This shows the Sorting Hat does not always have a quick and easy answer and that some decisions are more difficult than others. That leads to several questions:

  • Does the Sorting Hat take into account the student's stated desires when making a decision?
  • Does the Sorting Hat ever get stumped on where to put a student?
  • Does the Sorting Hat ever ask for a student's preference to resolve an "even-split" decision?
Improve this question
5
  • 3
    I just found it interesting you noted that the consideration of Slytherin was due to detecting the piece of Voldemort's soul. Is there a canon reference to that? I'm just stretching my memory of it but it's coming up blank at the moment. I've always taken it to mean that Harry, being talented and driven, could have been suited to the "who you know" angle of Slytherin.
    – dlanod
    Feb 15, 2012 at 5:37
  • @dlanod: It's been referenced in other questions on this site. I don't know the canon reference, but it has been sited as canon, either as in the book or Word of God.
    – Tango
    Feb 15, 2012 at 5:40
  • 5
    "I always imagine that the Sorting Hat detected the presence of that piece of soul when Harry first tried it on, because it's strongly tempted to put him in Slytherin. So that's how I see it." JK Rowling - Pottercast 12.23.07 - The Leaky Cauldron
    – dlanod
    Feb 15, 2012 at 6:31
  • The magical instrument in Professor Dumbledore's office has represented the Dark Lord's soul as being divided to two snakes. Would that make him an even split between Slytherin and Slytherin?
    – b_jonas
    Jan 24, 2014 at 15:07
  • As for the hat getting stumped, Harry was certainly affraid of this before he got sorted. From Stone ch. 7: “A horrible thought struck Harry, as horrible thoughts always do when you're very nervous. What if he wasn't chosen at all? What if he just sat there with the hat over his eyes for ages, until Professor McGonagall jerked it off his head and said there had obviously been a mistake and he'd better get back on the train?”
    – b_jonas
    Jan 24, 2014 at 21:16

1 Answer 1

Reset to default
23

  • Does the Sorting Hat take into account the student's stated desires when making a decision?

    Yes. It did with Harry Potter, when he asked to be in Gryffindor.

  • Does the Sorting Hat ever get stumped on where to put a student?

    Yes. It took a long time with both Neville (src: PotterCast #122) and Hermione.

    According to Pottermore, this situation actually has an official name in-universe: Hatstall.

  • Does the Sorting Hat ever ask for a student's preference to resolve an "even-split" decision?

    Yes. Hermione. Or Harry if you consider his case to be "even-split".

Improve this answer
5
  • 1
    It's interesting that all the special cases you cite (Neville, Hermione, Harry) ended up in Gryffindor. Is there maybe something special about Gryffindorians that makes them particularly hard to sort?
    – Iszi
    Feb 15, 2012 at 5:39
  • @Iszi: Maybe they're just a sorded (oops -- did I misspell that?) bunch?
    – Tango
    Feb 15, 2012 at 7:09
  • 8
    I found it more apt that Hermione and Neville are often sorted into different houses in fanfiction; many feel Hermione is more Ravenclaw than Gryffindor, and that Neville would make a great Hufflepuff. Maybe it takes a few minutes for the hat to determine you ought to be a main character? >.>
    – Yamikuronue
    Feb 15, 2012 at 20:48
  • 2
    @Iszi, Yes. It's where Rowling put all the main characters ;)
    – Brian S
    Jan 24, 2014 at 14:54
  • 3
    @Iszi Gryffindor is a tricky one to sort into, since one of the main aspects (definately not the only one) is courage. How do you put a worth to courage, especially against something so easily measured like 'wit beyond measure'...
    – Möoz
    Apr 29, 2014 at 5:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge that you have read and understand our privacy policy and code of conduct.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.