25

In Pixar's Toy Story, we see that:

  1. Toys are not restricted from movement, speech or other signs of "life" in front of humans; and
  2. Buzz Lightyear does not know (or believe) that he is a toy.

So, why does Andy not immediately learn that Buzz is alive when unpacking him from the box?

  • 6
    I don't think we need spoilers hiding the fact that toys are alive in toy story. Given its in the trailers. – user46509 Jan 24 '16 at 19:41
  • @AncalagonTheBlack People may not have seen the trailers. I've been chastised before for not hiding key plot details behind spoiler tags, so just being cautious. – TZHX Jan 24 '16 at 19:42
  • 8
    Killed the spoilers; they're not plot revelations, but the central premise of the narrative. If anyone gives you trouble, point them at me =) – Jason Baker Jan 24 '16 at 19:46
  • 2
    toystoryfangirl.wordpress.com/2015/09/10/… - Buzz feels that he has to freeze. – Valorum Jan 24 '16 at 19:59
12

A possibility is that he was following some space ranger directive. In Toy Story 2, the "Utility Belt Buzz" says the following to Buzz after catching him trying to steal the belt:

New Buzz: "You're in direct violation of Code 6404.5 stating all space rangers are to be in hyper-sleep until awakened by authorized personnel."

Buzz: "Oh no."

New Buzz: "You're breaking ranks, ranger." (opens his wrist communicator) "Buzz Lightyear to Star Command: I've got an AWOL Space Ranger."

One possibility is that Buzz also "has orders" to not to speak or act as alive with humans around.

As a sidenote: Toys see "freezing" as a rule they must follow, but it's a rule they can break (not something they just "can't go against because of their nature"). From Toy Story (scene: Woody planning with Sid's toys how to save Buzz from Sid's rocket launch):

Woody: Okay. I think I know what to do. We're going to have to break a few rules, but if it works, it'll help everybody.

Buzz, by nature, would be able to break the rule. Therefore, I think he doesn't do it because somehow he, as a space ranger, thinks he shouldn't.

11

There's a fairly long answer given in the YouTube explanation by "SuperCarlinBrothers".

Basically, Buzz Freezes for the same reason you and I can't stick our hands into a fire.

I'll transcribe some of the main points here, but I think it's best for you to go and take a look at the video.

3:45 onwards features some of the main points:

"Buzz isn't alone in this camp. There are other toys whose personalities are confined to the type of toy that they are. (...) The green army men know they are toys, but still act like green army men."

Green Army Man: "A good soldier never leaves a man behind!"

"In contrast, toys like Ham, Rex, Slink and Mr Potato head don't act like pigs, dinosaurs, dogs or talking potatoes... they know waht they represent; but their creation as a toy was for the sole intent of being a toy- simply, objects meant to be played with (...)

"Finally, that leads us to Buzz. Buzz is a step in the complete opposite direction. Buzz is the victim of whast we are going to refer to as "placebo branding (...) his mentality is being influenced by extensive branding that comes from being based on a real character."

Woody: "You actually think you're the Buzz Lightyear?!"

"so why does Buzz freeze? Because, no matter how hard you believe it, it doesn't stop the true from being true. (...) you can believe that sticking your hand into a fire isn't going to hurt you, but good luck with that. Buzz can believe he's a space ranger all he wants. But he's still inside this box. The toy box."

All credit goes to the vid, left to myself, I would've said one of the dumb theories mentioned at the beginning of the video (flight or fight etc.)

  • I've stuck my hands into fire plenty of times and not burned myself. How does this account for Woody revealing himself to the neighbor kid? This seems to indicate that the freezing is a deliberate choice of an act rather than an autonomous reaction to the presence of a human. – Broklynite Apr 22 '16 at 9:26
  • 2
    Woody was also based on a real-world character. – Valorum Apr 22 '16 at 9:57
  • 1
    @Richard True, but it got to the point where I didn't want to transcribe every part of the video that didn't directly answer it; he adressed the face that woody had forgotten his brand due to the fact that he'd been played with so much. – Mikasa Apr 22 '16 at 13:27
  • 2
    @Broklynite I'm assuming "real world character" here means a character in that world that has branding associated with it and is not merely a toy. – Mikasa Apr 23 '16 at 10:49
  • 1
    One of the premises of the video for "why are toys alive" is that they are given life by "the love, energy and attention of children". I'm not sure about this, because we see lots of living toys that haven't interacted with children at all (Stinky Pete, for example, or any Buzz after leaving its box). – Racso Sep 7 '18 at 13:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.