3

In Star Trek: Enterprise (S2ep25, "Bounty") Dr. Phlox and other crew found themselves being seduced by T'Pol, who said that if she didn't have sex soon she'd die because of an artifically induced Pon Farr.

enter image description here

Spock also gave this story to the crew of Star Trek TOS.

Is there any reasonable medical explanation for how a humanoid could just up and die unless they had sex?

Based on a literal interpretation of the statements by T'Pol and Spock, the biological pathway whereby sure death would occur from lack of sex would have to be something which could only be satiated by intercourse and which could not be "tricked" by a self gratification.

This leads me to my hypothesis. Is it possible that they would not literally up and die if they didn't find a partner, but rather they meant it metaphorically, like "if I don't get some soon I'll just die!", because they wanted it so badly?

  • 1
    I don't know exactly, but (as Spock alluded to on TOS, I believe) all Pacific Salmon die after mating en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salmon_run – Hack-R Feb 19 '16 at 3:42
  • 1
    There's more on this topic in Voyager, when one of the lower-ranked Vulcans males goes through it, though I forget the episode name. I think it was explained along the lines of, a hormone imbalance that just keeps getting worse, but whatever it was - definitely not just metaphorical. – Izkata Feb 19 '16 at 5:42
  • The vulcans in Voyager are Tuvok, the second officer on the ship, in the episode Body and Soul; and Ensign Vorik, in the episode Blood Fever. Vorik's pon farr was averted by fighting B'Ellana in a ritual fight, the kal if fee. Tuvok just used a hologram of his wife. – MichaelS Feb 19 '16 at 7:04
4

Background

According to Memory Alpha, the pon farr could lead to the plak tow (blood fever), which would literally result in death if not abated within 8 days.

The plak tow was initiated by telepathic contact, which would normally involve another vulcan of the opposite sex, but it was possible to engage it with other species (Ensign Vorik did this with B'Ellana Torres, in the Blood Fever, Voyager). There's no canon evidence I know of to suggest plak tow can or can't be initiated with someone of the same sex.

If the plak tow was initiated, it could be stopped by one of two methods: either mating successfully or engaging in kal if fee, a ritualistic fight to the death (although none of the kal if fee rituals shown in any series resulted in death that I recall).

Holograms

Tuvok satiated his pon farr using a hologram of his wife, though he commented it was lacking compared to the real thing, and it doesn't seem he ever initiated the plak tow. (Body and Soul, Voyager.)

Vorik attempted to use a hologram of a vulcan female, but it was unsuccessful. I don't know if this is because he had already mind-linked with B'Ellana, because the hologram wasn't accurate enough, because he had no prior connection to the holographic female, or because he simply didn't attempt it (he expressed disdain for the idea to Tom Paris before the attempt, so maybe he just went in, waited for Tom to leave, then shut the hologram down).

Inevitability

Spock in TOS (Amok Time) suggested he would die if he couldn't satiate his pon farr. Tuvok, on the other hand, mentioned it could be avoided by intense meditation, though Vorik was unable to meditate successfully, so it may be something only some vulcans can achieve.

Tuvok had access to medicine that Spock didn't, so it could be a matter of advances in medicine between TOS and Voyager, but Vorik had the same medicine available which didn't help (though he also refused to complete the treatments so it may have helped if he wasn't so stubborn).

Given that fighting to the death can cause the pon farr to end, it seems logical to come up with some method of beating the crap out of a vulcan with the pon farr to end it, but that's not canon. Also, beating the crap out of a vulcan is a problem unto itself. So the holodeck method is probably better if it works.

  • "Given that fighting to the death can cause the pon farr to end, it seems logical to come up with some method of beating the crap out of a vulcan with the pon farr to end it" ROFL ROFL. Logical too. – user60653 Feb 19 '16 at 13:28

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy