3

Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader are two different persons inhabiting the same body, who agrees with such a view. The script and novelisations also show that such duality appear to exist between Palpatine and Sidious. In Disney canon, Kylo Ren also appears to consider himself different from his birth identity.

This suggests that, from a philosophical standpoint, one's dark self is different and separate from one's natural birth self. Is this specific only to these three, or is it true of all Sith (Kylo's could be just yet another instance of Vader worship), all dark siders or even all living things in general?

Edit: I included Kylo Ren because it's another case of such a duality that we can observe going on in the novelisations. However, I am interested to know of examples and counterexamples in past and future Sith, including ones in Legends, where such dual identities exist.

  • 2
    so the dark side is actually just a wild case of schizophrenia? looks a lot less badass :( – RiddlerNewComer Feb 25 '16 at 16:06
  • 4
    I think you're taking this a little too far; an alternate identity isn't the same as being two people in one body. – Slacklord the Terrible Feb 25 '16 at 16:09
  • 2
    There's an episode in The Clone Wars where Yoda wrestles with his dark self. This is depicted as a separate entity that Yoda fights with. So, this dark side/light side dual identity thing is not limited to just those who embrace the dark side. – Ellesedil Feb 25 '16 at 18:56
  • So all Anakin needed was some therapy and neuro-meds to keep his dark side self in check? – LincolnMan Jun 22 at 21:12
4

Darth Maul appears to have only a dark side and is thus a counterexample. He was born to Mother Talzin of the Nightsisters (an organization aligned with the dark side) and as revealed in Star Wars: Darth Maul Son of Dathomir he was trained by Darth Sidious since he was a child:

enter image description here

Since he was trained with a dark side alignment from birth, his birth identity was the same as his dark side identity. I'm not aware of any indication that Maul ever had a "good side" or "light self".

The dual identities we see in Vader, Sidious, etc., seem to be mostly due to the fact that they started life aligned with the light (Vader and Kylo Ren) or neutral (e.g., Sidious, who did not become a Sith apprentice until he was an adult). The dual identities are also an artifact of Vader's psychological need to forget his past life with Padme and Sidious' need to publicly separate his Sith identity from his political one.

  • Kylo Ren is also disassociating himself with his birth identity, but in his case it's just normal teenage angst. – IllusiveBrian Feb 25 '16 at 16:45
  • I edited my question to add in the part I missed out: I'm interested to know if there are other dark siders, such as Sith, in past and future (including Legends) who exhibit such dual identities due to the light and dark sides in them. – thegreatjedi Feb 25 '16 at 17:45
  • @thegreatjedi So are you saying my answer doesn't answer your question anymore? – Null Feb 25 '16 at 18:12
  • Well counterexamples do count, but I'm looking for other examples too. Hmm maybe I should modify my question again to reflect this lol – thegreatjedi Feb 26 '16 at 2:17
0

It makes sense, from a certain point of view. Luke saw his philosophical 'dark side' in ESB, when fighting image of what he though was Vader. Yoda battled his dark side in Clone Wars. Vader and Obiwan are pretty clear about Annikan being killed by his dark side, I think even the emperor mentions it.

When they turn, they always change their name. In one of the prequels, can't remember now, someone mentions they have to fight and resist their dark side.

(I know this should be a comment, but can't write them yet)

0

I would say it depends on the point view of the person who falls in the dark side. Darth Maul has only one name and identity as mentioned earlier. Darth Sidious and Palpatine is considered to be the same person. Because they have both personalities and goals.Palpatine's disguise as Supreme Chancellor is a conspiracy to the galaxy. As you see in ROTS, he revealed as a Sith lord. Darth Tyranus and Count Dooku are just one and the same person. Yet,only few people knew that Dooku is Darth Tyranus. Like Sidious(Obviously),Jango Fett and Poggle the Lesser. Dooku's sith identity was secret,like Palpatine. When it comes to Anakin Skywalker and Darth Vader, it is psychologically considered to be different from one another. Like Obi Wan said that "He betrayed and murdered your father". This convince us that anakin and Vader are separated. In ROTJ,Darth Vader tells luke when he hear"Anakin Skywalker", Vader replied "That name has no longer any meaning for me". It means to Vader that He killed Anakin.One episode in Star Wars Rebels,Darth Vader said "Anakin Skywalker was weak, I destroy him".Unlike Sidious and Tyranus they do not separate their sith identity to their public identity.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.