6

In the Deathly Hallows, with the 7 Potters, Fleur still talks with a french accent, in the book and the recording.

“Bah,” said Fleur, checking herself in the microwave door, “Bill, don’t look at me—I’m ’ideous.”

But something that was not addressed in this question, is that when listening to the recording, when Hermione changes into Malfada Hopkirk, she completely alters her voice, along with Harry and Ron. (Sorry, no evidence.)

What is the explanation for this?

marked as duplicate by Rogue Jedi, Janus Bahs Jacquet, Chenmunka, Community Mar 19 '16 at 18:48

This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

  • What recording are you talking about? The movie? The audio-book (which one? The only one I know of has Stephen Fry reading all the characters, and he doesn't do that many individual character voices)? I don't see how this isn't a duplicate of the question you mention in the text: the answer is given right there. Anatomical attributes (vocal chords, etc.) are changed to the person you morph into, but things like accents (which are not anatomical) must be changed by imitation. How does this not precisely answer your question? – Janus Bahs Jacquet Mar 19 '16 at 18:36
19

The potion does change the voice, as can be seen in the second book when the Polyjuice Potion is first taken.

Then he [Harry] realized that his glasses were clouding his eyes because Goyle obviously didn't need them - he took them off and called, "Are you two okay?" Goyle's low rasp of a voice issued from his mouth. "Yeah," came the deep grunt of Crabbe from his right.

(Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Chapter 12)

Then there's other evidence, such as that fake Moody in the fourth book could fool the people who knew the real Moody well, or other cases such as the Mafalda or Lestrange transformations from the last book.

The potion does change the voice, but not the person's natural speech patterns. In the case of an accent, there may be sounds it's difficult for the person to say, and also sounds that the person simply pronounces in a particular way, although also able to do otherwise.

In the passage you quote, it's likely that Fleur's natural inclination is not to pronounce the initial h-sound in "hideous", because of how her French accent works (we know from her other dialogue that she always treats initial-h as silent), so she maintains that distinctive pronunciation despite having her voice modified.

Another case potentially supporting this is just a couple paragraphs after Fleur's quote:

“The pairs will be as follows: Mundungus will be traveling with me, by broom –“

“Why’m I with you?” grunted the Harry nearest the back door.

The "why'm" is typical of Mundungus Fletcher. For instance, this is him in the Order of the Phoenix:

'Some'n say m'name?' Mundungus mumbled sleepily.

(There's much more of the same in that book)

This would indicate that masterful deception using the polyjuice potion has a training element as well, as the person must train themselves to use the accent and speech patterns of whomever they are impersonating.

  • 1
    Seconding all this. The movies did an important mistake in having characters speak in their original voices. It makes for funnier situations and kids might like it more, but the inconsistencies... – Pwassonne Mar 19 '16 at 15:34
2

Polyjuice potion alters physical characteristics but leaves the mind alone. So the depth and tone of voice would be altered by the changes to the throat and mouth, but accent and speech patterns are products of the mind and would be unaltered.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.