9

I saw Batman vs. Superman over the weekend, and it was great, but not perfect. In my opinion, the biggest problem was that they sort of glossed over a lot of plot and story elements. For example, Lex's backstory is completely missing.

In fact, my least favorite part of the movie was Lex, but I'm hoping there's a reasonable explanation for his role. The performance, the writing, the story, it all seemed wrong. It seemed more like the Joker than the Lex Luthor that I'm familiar with.

I'm more familiar with Superman and related characters from movies and TV shows such as Smallville and the DCAU, although I've read some of the comics. In particular, I read the Death of Superman story arc as it came out. I recall that the Lex Luthor in that story was some kind of clone with transplanted memories or something.

Is that the case here? Is this actually Lex Luthor, actually his child, or something else?

If this Lex is some kind of clone, then that might explain his apparent mental issues. For example, he appears to break down during his bibliophile speech, and his plan to stop Superman by creating a bigger monster seems completely irrational.

| improve this question | |
  • 6
    I think maybe you should remove your review of the movie and instead just focus on the question. – Jack B Nimble Mar 28 '16 at 18:52
  • @JackBNimble I included that as the motivation for the question. I'll see if I can make the connection clearer. – DCShannon Mar 28 '16 at 19:03
6

enter image description here

Unfortunately, we don't get to know much about Luthor's past beyond the facts he stated: His father left him the business as part of his legacy. The nature of Snyder's DC Universe hints at any number of potential subplots and call-backs to potential stories that have existed in the DC Universe.

In the main DC Universe, Lex Luthor is rarely seen to have offspring. He has, however had extensive cloning facilities used to during the Man of Steel run in the 1990's to clone himself a new body after getting cancer from kryptonite radiation poisoning.

However, the idea that Lex Luthor we see in Batman v. Superman is a clone cannot be substantiated or compared to the story in the Man of Steel comics saga where Luthor contracts cancer from wearing a Kryptonite ring and thus clones a body and transfers his consciousness. [Action Comics, #670] (But I wonder if the scene where he shown standing next to a picture is a call back to Luthor II from Action #670, image below.)

Luthor eventually suffers from severe cancer brought on by long-term radiation exposure to the ring before this, kryptonite was mistakenly assumed to produce a safe radiation that is harmless to humans. His hand requires amputation to prevent the cancer's spread, but by then it has already metastasized, and his condition is terminal.

Luthor decides to fake his own death by piloting a prototype jet on a proposed trip around the world and crashing it in the Andes; this is merely a cover for the removal of his brain from his cancer-ridden body and the growth of a cloned body around it, whereupon he passes himself off as his hitherto unknown, illegitimate 21-year-old son and heir, Lex Luthor II. His deception is benefited by a vibrant new body with a beard and full head of red hair, as well as assuming an Australian accent as part of his fake backstory.

enter image description here

Since Snyder's Luthor did not wear a Kryptonite ring, and until 18 months ago didn't know about the existence of Superman, we have to attribute his eccentricities to other issues. Given that people were surprised by the strange nature of his "speech" at the philanthropic event, we can assume they were as surprised by his difficulties.

It has been hinted during Batman v. Superman that Lex Luthor is dealing with an extraterrestrial intelligence who may be using a form of mind control or mental domination to force him to comply with the entity's wishes. A recently released scene shows Luthor in the presence of a giant alien entity onboard the Kryptonian ship as he is being captured by the authorities. This potential interaction by alien intelligences is bolstered by the dreams Batman had of a future catastrophic Earth complete with the existence of demonic forces.

This entity is probably Darkseid using the mental powers or mind control technology of his lieutenant, Desaad. The Bat-dreams were complete with parademons, Darkseid's most recognizable shock-troops.

Given how erratic Synder's Luthor seemed, it is hard to imagine this sputtering, slightly crazed eccentric could have possibly been able to lead his company in this state. Considering his ranting at the end of the movie, it is apparent Luthor has become unhinged and signs of mind control are evident to Batman.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    That makes sense, thanks. Hopefully they'll elaborate in an upcoming film. I'll wait a few days and see if somebody comes up with something else, but this is certainly a candidate for acceptance. – DCShannon Mar 28 '16 at 20:04
  • Ran across this related article, which contains the deleted scene with Lex getting arrested: screenrant.com/batman-v-superman-deleted-scene-darkseid-lex – DCShannon Mar 29 '16 at 16:58
  • Do you guys think there's a chance it may ultimately turn out that Lex is one of those "not bad after all" characters? Ultimately we learn all his evil was at the behest of the mind control aliens? Is that a possibility based on the corpus? .... ???? – Fattie Mar 29 '16 at 21:48
  • And that 'He is coming', does 'He' refers to Darkseid here? – ABcDexter Mar 30 '16 at 6:20
  • I saw the movie a second time, and I think this is as good as we're going to get without the additional information an extended cut or sequel will hopefully provide. – DCShannon May 18 '16 at 19:59
3

The current existing evidence is that he's Lex Luthor's son: Alexander Luthor, Jr. As seen in the article here. Also, he has the line in the movie "It's my father's company, he put the 'Lex' before 'Corp'".

It is also worth noting that Snyder may be taking artistic license, and this may actually be the Lex Luthor we are all accustomed to.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    That doesn't really clear up whether he's actually his son or a clone masquerading as his son. – DCShannon Mar 28 '16 at 19:47
  • Edited my answer to allow for future story possibilities. – PiousVenom Mar 28 '16 at 19:50
  • Alright, fair enough. – DCShannon Mar 28 '16 at 19:51

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.