12

When Harry leaves the Burrow to go to Diagon Alley by Floo Powder in CoS, he ends up in Knockturn Alley. He sort-of pronounces it wrong:

‘D-Dia-gon Alley,’ he coughed.

How does that equate to "Knockturn Alley"?

Why?

  • In hindi-dubbed book and movie, they cleverly took "Diagon Alley: Choomantar Gali." and "Knockturn Alley: Chumantar Gali". And both of them are pronounced in the same way. – manshu Apr 3 '16 at 3:42
  • @manshu Not completely correct: Diagon Alley was 'Chhoomantar', while Knockturn Alley was 'Shoomantar'. Similar, but not exact. – The Dragon Rider who Lived Apr 6 '16 at 17:22
  • Have you never gotten a weirdo result from Siri or Alexa? :) – Paul Mar 24 '18 at 4:27
15

Because he's unused to Floo and doesn't enunciate his words clearly.

After being overloaded with advice from all the Weasleys, he stutters while trying to say "Diagon Alley" through a mouthful of ash and ends up slightly off-target, landing in Knockturn Alley instead. The reason he ends up in Knockturn Alley (which admittedly doesn't sound much like "D-Dia-gon Alley", nor the "diagonally" of the film) is that he almost made it to Diagon Alley, but his pronunciation sent him slightly off-target to the next street.

This is covered in the book itself:

‘Well ... all right ... you go after Arthur,’ said Mrs Weasley. ‘Now, when you get into the fire, say where you’re going –’

‘And keep your elbows tucked in,’ Ron advised.

‘And your eyes shut,’ said Mrs Weasley. ‘The soot –’

‘Don’t fidget,’ said Ron. ‘Or you might well fall out of the wrong fireplace –’

‘But don’t panic and get out too early, wait until you see Fred and George.’

Trying hard to bear all this in mind, Harry took a pinch of Floo powder and walked to the edge of the fire. He took a deep breath, scattered the powder into the flames and stepped forward; the fire felt like a warm breeze; he opened his mouth and immediately swallowed a lot of hot ash.

‘D-Dia-gon Alley,’ he coughed.

[...]

An old wooden street sign hanging over a shop selling poisonous candles told him he was in Knockturn Alley. This didn’t help, as Harry had never heard of such a place. He supposed he hadn’t spoken clearly enough through his mouthful of ashes back in the Weasleys’ fire. Trying to stay calm, he wondered what to do.

[...]

Harry and Hermione looked around; sprinting up the crowded street were Ron, Fred, George, Percy, and Mr. Weasley.

"Harry," Mr. Weasley panted. "We hoped you'd only gone one grate too far ..." He mopped his glistening bald patch. "Molly's frantic - she's coming now -"

-- HP and the Chamber of Secrets, Chapter 4: Knockturn Alley (emphasis mine)

  • 5
    But why did mispronouncing the word take him out in Borgin and Burke 's? – Valorum Apr 2 '16 at 23:00
  • 6
    @Richard It almost took him to Diagon Alley, but not quite, instead depositing him somewhere quite close by. – Rand al'Thor Apr 2 '16 at 23:01
  • 4
    @Axelonet No. Presumably if you wanted to get to, say, the Gryffindor common room and slightly mispronounced the words, you'd end up somewhere close by, maybe the Ravenclaw common room or whatever is in the same region of Hogwarts as the Gryffindor one. – Rand al'Thor Apr 2 '16 at 23:14
  • 5
    When Harry later meets the Weasleys again, Mrs Weasley says something like “We hoped you only went one grate too far” (can’t look up the exact wording ATM). That would support the close-by theory. – chirlu Apr 3 '16 at 2:08
  • 2
    I like this answer but it's missing that the Floo Network was sensitive to how clear he was in his intent (like many other magical spells). This seems consistent with the Harry Potter world where the same thing can happen while apparating. Distraction can be very bad. I think that implies it had less to do with the Floo Network misunderstanding his pronunciation and sending him to something that sounded like Diagon Alley and more to do with Floo Network doing it's best to comply with Harry's intent (getting him close). It also matches why Mr Weasley said "one grate off." – Captain P Apr 4 '16 at 1:55
1

If you pronounce anything wrong when using floo powder, and are not used to it, you could end up literally anywhere.

It was Harry's first time using floo powder, he stuttered when saying the destination. When using floo powder you are always supposed to speak clearly so that you don't end up in a random place. Anyways, Harry stuttered while saying the destination. ‘D-Dia-gon Alley,’ he coughed. Then, because he stuttered he ended but really close to his destination, the alley right next to Diagon Alley. A quote from the book

'He supposed he hadn’t spoken clearly enough through his mouthful of ashes back in the Weasleys’ fire'.

0

Because when using Floo Powder you need to say where you are going very clearly. Harry tried speaking the words "Diagon Alley" with a mouth full of ashes. Instead he said “diagonally”. I'm guessing he went "diagonally" instead of going "straight" to where he wanted; which lead him to a place where no one wants to go.

-1

Probably the same reason why mispronouncing and casting winguardium leviosa caused another students feather to explode in his face.

-1

He says it good enough, but if you read what Ron and his brothers had told him, Ron said, "don't fidget". While, George and Fred told him not to panic, which he had done both. So he fell out too early, which was obviously the wrong fireplace, which was both of the consequences of his actions. I'm also thinking the reason he panicked was because he had choked and knew he mispronounced Diagon Alley.

-2

The way he would get to diagon alley is by saying di-agon-alley but as Harry is new to this he stutters and says something more like Di-ag-a-na-ly

protected by KutuluMike Mar 24 '18 at 16:05

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.