10

In Pirates of Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl, why does the cursed crew need the blood of a Turner in order to lift the curse?

12

In addition to putting all of the coins back, the blood must be "repaid" for the curse to be broken. Precisely what that means is unclear, but it sounds as though the cursed person must actually die.

Since "Bootstrap" Bill Turner was one of the crew who stole the treasure, they need his blood.

Let's look at the rest of the conversation you referenced. From the script:

WILL
What happened to William Turner?

PINTEL
Ah, William Turner. Stupid blighter. He threw in with us after we relieved Jack Sparrow of his captaincy, but turned out, it never sat well with him-particularly after we found Cortes', and its peculiar condition. He thought we deserved to be cursed, for leaving ol' Jack to the fate we did. That's why he sent off a piece of the treasure -- to you, as it were: so it would never be recovered, and so cursed we remain.

WILL
And then he ran. And he's hiding out someplace where you haven't been able to find him.

PINTEL
That's a nice thought, to be sure, and I wager your da wishes he'd thought it hisself. But, no. See, what he'd done, didn't sit too well with Captain Barbossa ... so he chained a cannon to his legs and dumped him over.

Will reacts with shock at the account of his father's fate.

PINTEL (CONT'D)
Yep, last I saw of Bootstrap Bill, was his face looking up, as he sank down to the crushing black oblivion of Davy Jones' locker. (sighs) It was only after, we found out we needed his blood to solve the curse. That's what you call ironic.

They believe that they may not need Bill Turner specifically, and that his offspring's blood would do.

Barbossa explains this to Elizabeth, who he believes is Bill Turner's daughter at the time.

There is but one way to remove the curse. All of the scattered pieces of the treasure must be restored in full, and the blood repaid.

(he throws the pages aside)

We've recovered every piece -- save for this.

(holds up the medallion)

And as for the blood ... that's what we have you for.

(pleasant, finally getting to his point)

And that's why there's no sense in killing you. Yet.

  • 5
    Because Bootstrap Bill Turner was one of the crew who stole the coins. – phantom42 May 6 '16 at 17:07
  • 6
    Yes, and Bill was part of that crew. – phantom42 May 6 '16 at 19:23
  • 2
    @Leth - in your question you included a picture from the scene where they explain that Bill was on the crew, helped steal the coins, and then turned on the crew by hiding one of the coins. What about that was unclear? Everyone that stole needs to repay in blood. That's why they need a Turner. That's what that scene was about. – Radhil May 6 '16 at 20:28
  • 3
    @KaiQing - He would've been, yeah, up until Davy Jones found him and offered a deal to get out of it, or until the curse ended and let him drown and die. – Radhil May 7 '16 at 2:25
  • 5
    @phantom42 Someone else can ask this question: How were the cursed Pirates, who had no blood after they were cursed, supposed to repay the curse with blood they no longer had? – Major Stackings Sep 17 '16 at 19:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.