In Changes, Harry first called Uriel, then he resorted to Mab's offer - becoming winter Knight.

I believe that later on (either Ghost Story, Cold Days, or Skin Game) there is one moment where Harry thinks about what his backup would have been if Mab had refused them. I just recently reread all of them - and I don't want to read them again - but I skimmed them and can't find that passage.

  • Probably whatever ritual that necromancer wanted to do.
    – Adamant
    May 16, 2016 at 0:44

2 Answers 2


Harry had two more backup plans:

I grimaced. “Please don’t take this as an insult. But you’re the least evil of my options.”

The cold voice told me nothing about her reaction. “Explain.”

“The Denarians would have me growing a goatee and gloating malevolently within a few years, if I didn’t break and turn into some kind of murderous tardbeast first. And I’d have to kill a lot of people outright, if I wanted to use the Darkhallow.” I swallowed. “But I’ll do it. If I have no other way to get my child out of their hands, I’ll do it.”

So in the order of "evilness" he had 4 options:

  1. Get help from Uriel (which was refused)
  2. Became a Winter Knight (which was accepted)
  3. Became Denarian
  4. Use the Darkhallow ritual, murder thousands and became a physical god

I'm not sure is the #4 actually feasible, since Darkhallow was requiring lots of preparation, for starters it had to be performed on Halloween and needed support of powerful spirits.

As for #3 it wouldn't be a literal deal with the devil but something very close - Knights of the Blackened Denarius had (mostly) free will and chance for redemption.

It is also worth to point that Harry made deals with real demons before in "Fool Moon":

"Well, you aren't getting my soul today," I told him. "So make me a counteroffer, or we can call a close to the negotiations and I can send you back."

The demon shuddered. "Yes, very well. Let us not be hasty, Harry Dresden. I have the information you need. Additionally, I have more information of which you are not aware, and which would be of great interest to you, and which I judge, additionally, may help to preserve your life and the lives of others.Given the situation, I do not think the price I will ask inappropriate: I wish another of your names."

Harry agrees to that deal, later on he is tempted again but he refuses and breaks the contact:

"The price is comparatively low. What need have you for your immortal soul when your body is finished with it? What harm to pass on to me only one more name? This is not information easily gained, even by my kind. You may not have the chance to garner it again." The demon pressed his pincers against the barrier of the conjuring circle. His beaklike maw fairly trembled with eagerness.

"Forget it," I said quietly. "No deal."

  • I'm aware of that passage in Changes, but I think there was another passage in one of the following books where he mentions his next option after Mab.
    – yulerule
    May 16, 2016 at 1:27
  • @yulerule - following books, no, I don't think so or I don't recall, but he's noted the number of Evil recruitment options earlier in the series, when dealing with Mavra in Dead Beat.
    – Radhil
    May 16, 2016 at 12:36
  • @Radhil I'm aware of that passage, thanks though. I'm searching for a specific passage in following the deal he made with Mab, though.
    – yulerule
    May 16, 2016 at 12:59
  • @yulerule Harryhas more than once wondered has he made deal with devil by agreeing to Mab's offer, I don't believe that he ever considered again Denarian's one.
    – Yasskier
    May 16, 2016 at 21:42
  • @yulerule - I've done a quick reskim as well of the three books following Changes and cannot find what you're looking for. The only other time the Darkhallow gets mentioned is in reference to Corpsetaker, and the Denarians don't come up until Nick takes center stage again.
    – Radhil
    May 18, 2016 at 1:40

Having just finished re-reading them, I can confirm that nowhere in Ghost Story, Cold Days, or Skin Game does Harry think about what his other options were.

The closest is in the flashback scene in Ghost Story, where he

persuades Molly to help him arrange his own murder.

Even then, the other options aren't mentioned explicitly; he just says that Mab is the only acceptable choice, because he has a reasonable chance of tricking her.

Perhaps you were thinking of the scene in Cold Days (chapter 19) where it is revealed that

Harry considered asking Lara to kill him instead of Kincaid?

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.