2

Please can anyone explain what is the "fight club theory" in Game of Thrones? And does this theory relate to the books in any way?

  • 12
    @Aegon That's a reason to downvote, not a reason to close. – Rand al'Thor Jun 9 '16 at 13:08
  • 5
    The first rule of the Fight Club theory is "You do not talk about the Fight Club theory" – Ginasius Jun 9 '16 at 16:02
  • 2
    @Randal'Thor Are you going to allow a question to be closed because the OP asked something Googleable? I guess no one remembers the meta SE thread in which the ultimatum was: It! Doesn't! Matter! Someone has to be #1 on the search results. We shouldn't avoid asking questions because it's easily Googleable! – Insane Jun 9 '16 at 19:56
  • 2
    @Insane Depends what you mean by "allow" :-) I also think it shouldn't be closed, but I'm not going to modhammer it open when I was the one who answered it. I may write up a meta post about it, unless someone else like you does it first. – Rand al'Thor Jun 9 '16 at 22:04
  • 10
    Please do not vote to close this question again. I am reopening it as a legitimate, if unpopular question. If you find the question objectionable on the basis of its fan-generated speculative nature, that is not, technically a reason to close, but perhaps to downvote. If the theory which has an answer below exists in the fandom it is fair game for both questions and answers. – Thaddeus Howze Jun 9 '16 at 23:26
20

I hadn't heard of this theory, but found it by Googling "fight club theory" "game of thrones".

From TV Guide's Game of Thrones: All the Crazy Arya Theories, Explained:

The Fight Club Theory: Some fans suggest that Arya and the Waif are not actually nemeses, but the same person, with the Waif being the Tyler Durden to Arya's Edward Norton. The meat of this theory is that the Waif and Arya represent her two possible paths - becoming No One and embracing her born identity - and that all the fights between Arya and the Waif are her inner struggles literalized. That would make the Waif's attack on Arya a (failed) last-ditch effort to kill her emotions and officially become No One.

[...]

However, given the absurdity of this theory and the fact that the Waif is equally emotional as Arya, it doesn't quite line up.

This is a reference to the 1999 film Fight Club, and if you read Wikipedia's plot description you'll see why.

The theory may have originated on Reddit last Tuesday (31 May 2016).

As for whether it relates to the books, you have to remember that A Song of Ice and Fire and Game of Thrones have considerably diverged at this point, and the show has moved beyond all the currently existing books. It may be that the theory will also be valid in the books; it may also be that it will be invalidated even in the show when the next episode airs.

  • 1
    Sort of interesting... it seems like way too much theorizing and explaining would be needed to reconcile that with how the faceless man interacts with them - I guess he could be the "Marla" of the situation? Or the entire thing could be in Arya's head? And she was actually the one who killed the people she named after she "met" the faceless man? Seems overly convoluted though. – Todd Wilcox Jun 9 '16 at 13:41
  • 1
    There are some things that speak for this theory, namely that Arya and the kindly man (in the books) always refer to "Arya" in third person. And while Arya becomes "no one" in her day time, she is the "night wolf" in her dreams (warging into Nymeria). "Arya" also hid Needle to retrieve it later, which "Arya" in the tv-show did. However, in the books, the waif is a real person, and it seems a bit too vague for a tv-show to have such a plot. – TLP Jun 9 '16 at 14:00
  • 4
    IIRc, in the books Arya and the Kindly Man talk about the Waif, about her age and appearance. In this conversation Arya learns that the Waif is much older than she looks and this is due to her frequent contact with the death-water in the temple's pool, which the Waif prepares and refills on a daily basis. If this talk really happend (I do have to read the books again!), it would strongly oppose the theory that Arya and the Waif are the same person (in the books). – user1129682 Jun 9 '16 at 14:41
  • 2
    @user1129682 "The poisons" that the waif was exposed to was later revealed to be the ones that her father's new wife gave her, not the poisons in the temple. Her father asked for his wife to be given "the gift", for which he gave his daughter to the faceless men. – TLP Jun 9 '16 at 23:12
  • 3
    I don't know if the Fight Club theory holds water in the TV series. There are several conversations between the Waif and Jaqen H'ghar where Arya isn't present, including one where Jaqen gives the Waif permission to hunt down Arya. – RobertF Jun 10 '16 at 13:57

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.