In Northern Lights, children (and the adult nurses) undergo intercision at Bolvangar. Many of the children die, but some like Tony Makarios survive (if only for a time) and adults definitely survive. It appears that the bond between human and daemon, in the case of the adults, is broken. So why are the effects much less serious than in the case of a spectre attack? When adults are attacked by spectres, they lose all function and can merely gaze dumbly. So what is the difference between the intercision, where one merely loses one's 'spark', and a spectre attack, where one loses interest even in one's own survival?

1 Answer 1


If you read the article on Intercision on the His Dark Materials wiki, they discuss early forms of Intercision, as performed by the Tartars and African tribes, which resulted in the creation of Zombis, workers who could no longer think for themselves. This sounds very similar to the effect of the spectres eating the daemon.

As to what the difference is, I suspect it is a matter of trauma. The African method is described as a forced separation by steadily increasing the distance between the human and their daemon. Compare this to the Maystadt or Silver Guillotine methods, which cut the bond directly, more surgically, creating less trauma. Much like how it is easier to survive having a limb surgically severed than it is to have the same limb chewed and ripped off, it is easier to survive having one's soul surgically removed than having it ripped away by creatures gnawing away at it.

  • 1
    Perhaps it is the trauma, certainly for the difference between, say, Roger and the nurses at the station. But it seems to me that Lena Feldt has lost more than Tony Makarios. The spectre victims when the witches first encounter them in the World of Citagazze are certainly not capable of even being bossed around. Also, the spectre attacks (iirc) never lead to death (at least not directly), so it still seems to me to be qualitatively different rather than a move severe example of the same thing Commented Jun 21, 2016 at 11:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.