5

In Game of Thrones S06E04

Daenerys burns all the Dothraki Khals and then comes out of the burning house. Then all the Dothraki that came to see what was happening knelt before her, considering her the new leader of the horde because she 'defeated' the other Khals.

Why would she be considered a Khaleesi and not a witch? Why did the Dothraki decide to follow her? It's seems like witches are a bad thing in Westeros, Essos and especially in the Dothraki culture. In the eye of a Dothraki man, I feel like she should be seen as a witch for surviving/creating the fire. Also, there are probably a lot of Dothraki/Khalasars that probably don't want to be ruled by some foreign girl.

EDIT : I think the Dothraki in the show does not believe she is a witch because I think Dothraki would not follow a witch. Witches seem to be a very bad thing in the eyes of this culture (see how the Dothraki girls in S06E03 were saying that Daenerys was a witch and that they should kill her, and after the event of the season 1 also).

So, if you think that the Dothraki might think that she's a witch but decide to follow her nonetheless, why would they agree to follow a witch even though witches are known to be a bad thing in this culture?

  • 2
    Who says they don't? If tomorrow someone used some weird magic to burn every world leader alive and then demanded your allegiance, would you kick up a fuss? – TenthJustice Jun 24 '16 at 23:43
  • Good point, however, I still feel like the proud dothrakis would have at least try to fight her. Dothrakis are proud and they're less afraid of death than most people. – 021 Jun 25 '16 at 0:30
  • 3
    The Dothraki seem to have a clear preference for a strong leader. If you think they would not accept a "witch" as their leader, I suggest you edit your question to explain why you think so. – Blackwood Jun 25 '16 at 0:32
  • 1
    Thanks for the suggestion. I'll add that. It seemed obvious for me so I didn't think to add it. – 021 Jun 25 '16 at 0:47
  • 3
    Because her cats are huge and breathe fire. – Misha R Jun 25 '16 at 0:57
8

The Dothraki have no other option. Daenerys has just created a power vacuum where she is the only one to fill the void.

When Khal Drogo died and the dragons were hatched by the fire Daenerys used to burn the witch Mirri Maz Duur, Drogo's khalassar still had other options. They had a choice to stay with Daenerys or join a new khalassar that was formed by Drogo's Bloodrider.

Now, all the other Khals are gone. Daenrys emerges as the one who defeated them. The Dothraki will only follow a winner, a disgraced Khal is no Khal at all.

I think the horde in general will see her more as a god than a witch. She is not performing blood magic or any types of spells. She is immune to fire and can control dragons!

  • 1
    Jorrah Mormont told her as she sailed from Quarth that she would have a Khalassar when she proved herself strong. She has done that. – Andrew Jun 27 '16 at 4:22

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.