13

Is anything known about Dragonstone after:

Stannis Baratheon is killed in his bid for the Iron Throne?

As the seat of the naval defense of King's Landing and the birthplace of Daenerys Targaryen, she has a vested interest in taking it.

At the conclusion of Season 6 Episode 10, is Dragonstone unoccupied?

  • I'm hoping all those rumors of dragon eggs on Dragonstone prove true and Dany finds them and gets more dragons. – Brad Jun 27 '16 at 15:05
  • I'd like to think that Daenerys will reclaim her ancestral home on her way back to Westeros, or at least send others to claim it in her name. Now that things are finally moving, we may (emphasis on may) see that fairly soon (ie early next season). – maguirenumber6 Jun 30 '16 at 3:39
  • @Aegon In s5, Dragonstone was discussed. Stannis told (Sam?) that there is a lot of dragonglass on Dragonstone. As viewers, during Hardhome somehow we knew Jon and a Thenn were battling a White Walker for dragonglass that they really did not need. Because of Dragonstone, dragonglass is not rare at all. btw: where were the Thenns at Battle of Bastards??? – Just Someone Jun 30 '16 at 13:17
4

Who holds Dragonstone?

It is unknown as of now according to show canon. Show has not depicted Dragonstone since Season 2 and it is unlikely that they would include it again, except perhaps in Daenerys' scenes. So this is going to speculation. There can be following scenarios:

  1. Dragonstone could still be held by garrison left behind by Stannis Baratheon. But if that's true, it is entirely possible that the Commander/Castellan might have surrendered to the Iron Throne after hearing about Stannis' demise in wake of 1st Battle of Winterfell.
  2. Iron Throne may have dispatched a small naval detachment to retake Dragonstone. It is supported by the Tyrell-Lannister alliance as Tyrells had a very strong Navy, mostly because of their bannermen House Redwyne. So the alliance would have provided Iron throne with much needed naval vessels required to invade Dragonstone as Royal Fleet was destroyed in Battle of King's Landing where it was used as bait for luring Stannis' fleet in to be burnt with wildfire.

In any case, it is unlikely that anyone other than Iron Throne holds the Island.

However, one thing to note is, in Battle of Castle Black, Stannis had ~2800 men. Four episodes before that, in "The Laws of Gods and Men", he says that he has about 4,000 men left overall. If he appears on the wall with ~2800 men, that means he may have left 1200 men as garrison in Dragonstone. Alternative explanations can be that those 1200 men were left behind at East Watch by the Sea.

Importance of Dragonstone

You are incorrect when you say that Dragonstone is the seat of naval defense of King's Landing. That is simply not true.

Dragonstone is a damp and bleak island with very limited resources. It has a port and traditionally hosts few squadrons of Royal Navy but King's Landing on the other hand is a bigger port and main power of the Royal Navy resides there. However, it lies very close to the Gullet and can be used as a base to impose naval blockade on King's landing if the besieging forces have enough naval vessels.

In any case, there is not much strategic importance of the Island.

But of course it has sentimental value for Daenerys because:

  1. It is the ancestral seat of House Targaryen. Since Doom of Valyria, All the Targaryen Lords, Kings and Princes (From Aenar the Exile to Prince Rhaegar) have held Dragonstone as their seat1.
  2. Daenerys was born there.
  3. Daenerys' mother died there giving birth to her so it is plausible that her ashes might be interned there (Since end of Targaryens were writ in flames unlike common men who were buried).

Can Daenerys take it?

Definitely.

Dragonstone is a formidable castle but like every other castle, it is vulnerable from the air. Daenerys has three dragons and therefore aerial superiority.

She also has a strong fleet to besiege the Island from the sea and prevent any reinforcements coming from the mainland. It is unlikely that a large defending force would be stationed in Dragonstone.

But If I were her, I would rather land in Dorne because:

  1. Dorne is much closer when travelling from Meereen as compared to Dragonstone. There is no point in braving the danger of sea voyage unnecessarily.
  2. Dorne is allied with Daenerys along with the Reach. If she lands there, she will find her Westerosi allies and their armies waiting for her, making the invasion all the more easier. If she lands on Dragonstone however, she will probably find foes and waste time on siege and extra travel to Dragonstone. Then she will need to wait for her Allies in Dorne and Highgarden to assemble and March Northwards to King's Landing.
  3. Dragonstone holds no strategic value for her.

Books Perspective

In the Books:

Dragonstone was occupied by Iron throne with a force under command of Ser Loras Tyrell after Stannis departed for the Wall.


1. Targaryen Kings held Dragonstone as their seat only during the period of time they were nominated Prince of Dragonstone by the incumbent King. Although many Kings did not hold either the title or the Island before their coronation. Princess Rhea, Viserys I, Prince Joffrey Velaryon, Aegon III, did not hold the land despite being named Prince(ss) of Dragonstone. Baelor I, Viserys II, Aerys I, Maekar I and Aegon V held neither the title nor the land prior to their coronation.

  • This answer can be updated now that S7E1 was aired – Dunno Jul 17 '17 at 15:55
  • @Dunno I haven't watched it and might not watch it at all. Feel free to add your own answer. I'll upvote it certainly. – Aegon Jul 17 '17 at 16:06
4

As of Season 7 Episode 1:

Daenerys indeed chose Dragonstone as her landing base. She entered it without any resistance and found the palace uninhabited. Cersei and Jaime anticipated this but apparently they lacked resources to seize control over the island and resist Daenerys's landing.

CERSEI: Where will they land?

JAIME: Dragonstone. They have deep-water ports for the ships. Stannis left the castle unoccupied, and that's where she was born.

(...)

CERSEI: How do we proceed?

JAIME: Winter is here. We can't win a war if we can't feed our men and our horses.

However, episode 1 doesn't say anything about the rest of Dragonstone, meaning, we still don't know if there are any rebel armies left hiding there or if the island is completely deserted.

0

In all likelihood, whoever controls Dragonstone, Cersei controls them.

Stannis died while Tommen Baratheon still ruled.

At the time Tommen was Stannis's only living (nominal) blood-relative, and so the holding would rightfully be his (or his Regent's) to retain or grant as he desired. Had Stannis died leaving no one with a particular claim on his titles and holdings, they would revert to crown ownership for the same outcome.

0

I haven't read the books, so I am no expert how banks in game of thrones work, but wouldn't it be possible that iron bank could now own Dragonstone because of Stannis debt? Iron bank will always have its due and this seems most plausible answer.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.