At the end of Ring of Solomon Bartimaeus purposefully disobeys (or misobeys) Asmira and returns the Ring to Solomon. Why?

He claims it is because he doesn't think that they should:

Lose the Ring to the sea and doom its Spirit to an even longer captivity.

He suggests here that he wants the Spirit to be free and hiding the ring in the sea would slow that process down however in reality the Spirit is doomed forever no matter what. The Spirit tells Bartimaeus that freeing him is

Beyond your competence.

This suggests that the Ring has a spell more powerful than the normal binding spells attached to it. In fact ti seems likely that the only way to free the Spirit is for multiple powerful magicians to work together to free it. Through the series it is shown that magicians do not work to help spirits. The only humans who might free the Spirit are Kitty and Ptolemy but Barimaeus has not met them yet.

Given that the Spirit cannot be freed why did Bartimaeus return the Ring. Other nations and magicians will still want the Ring so the Ring returning will likely cause the deaths of both men and djinn. Solomon is also likely to die soon so bringing back the Ring will result in either Solomon hiding it (Probably by throwing it in the sea) or Solomon's successor taking the Ring likely resulting in a war. Barimaeus could avoid this by throwing the Ring into the sea. Furthermore Bartimaeus would then not have had to carry the Ring back which would save him a lot of pain.

Given all the good reasons for putting the Ring in the sea why did Bartimaeus keep it with him.


Its six months late but here is the answer:

When Bartimaeus offers to attempt to destroy the ring, Uraziel replies "The Ring cannot yet be broken"

It is entirely possible that a powerful entity of indescribable power and unknown limits can see into the future. OR it merely knows how long the spell will last on the ring, and when it will be weak enough to be broken.

Returning the ring is the only course of action Bartimaeus really has. He does NOT want to piss of Uraziel as compared to him Bartimaeus is a flea. Not returning the ring and causing Uraziel to be in a longer captivity would probably not be a wise move. He is not doing out of the kindness of his heart more watching out for his own skin.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.